.
.
...............................................................................................................................................................................
from the collection of P. M. GOLDSTEIN
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Hello & Welcome to another of my websites!
My name is Phil, and this website showcases my interests in collecting railroad emphera, exonumia and memorabilia from the following topics:
Railroads that operated in the
Northern Catskill region of New York State, more specifically: Delaware,
Ulster and Greene Counties;
.
"Freight only" (industrial & offline
terminal) railroads located in Brooklyn, Queens, Staten Island, Bronx and
Manhattan, NY;
.
Military Railroads
that operated in the New York Metropolitan
Area
.
Erie Railroad L-1 class
locomotives;
Amtrak #16000 double-ended
wrecker;
.
Transportation Emphera from New York City
Transit & its predecessor Transportation
Companies;
.
Idlewild Airport Baggage Destination Tags;
(ok, so it's not railroad, but it is transportation
related!)
x |
This webpage is respectively divided into those sections :
Industrial & Offline Terminal |
||
Memorabilia and Information of
Railroads operating in the Northern
Catskills Region of New York:
|
. . |
|
I primarily collect all types of memorabilia from the
following Railroads that operated in
Delaware, Ulster, Greene & Schoharie
Counties of New York State, i.e.:
| ANDES & DELHI | ... | ELLENVILLE & KINGSTON | ... | NEW YORK & OSWEGO MIDLAND |
| ANDES & MIDDLETOWN | HANCOCK & EAST BRANCH | OTIS ELEVATING | ||
| CAIRO | HANCOCK & WILKES-BARRE | PENN CENTRAL (Catskill Mountain Branch) | ||
| CANAJOHARIE & CATSKILL | HOBART BRANCH | RONDOUT & OSWEGO | ||
| CATSKILL MOUNTAIN | KAATERSKILL | SCHENECTADY & MARGARETVILLE | ||
| CATSKILL & TANNERSVILLE | KINGSTON & RONDOUT (streetcar) | SOUTH CAIRO & EAST DURHAM | ||
| DELAWARE & EASTERN | KINGSTON & RONDOUT VALLEY | STONY CLOVE & CATSKILL MOUNTAIN | ||
| DELAWARE & NORTHERN | KINGSTON & LAKE KATRINE | ULSTER & DELAWARE | ||
| DELAWARE VALLEY & KINGSTON | § NEW YORK, ONTARIO & WESTERN | WALLKILL VALLEY | ||
DELHI & MIDDLETOWN |
NEW YORK, KINGSTON & SYRACUSE | § WEST SHORE (Catskill Mountain Branch) |
§ = As the
WEST SHORE
RAILROAD (New York Central)
connected with the Ulster & Delaware at Kingston, NY;
and the NEW YORK, ONTARIO
& WESTERN connected with the Delaware &
Eastern / Delaware & Northern
at East Branch, NY; and the Ulster & Delaware in Kingston, NY:
I also collect those items from the West Shore and NYO&W when also
marked with a railroad from above..
As a result of this collecting, I have begun updating old data, and collating new data pertaining to the information of those railroads listed above.
Northern Catskills Railroad Collection Showcase
Please click on the link to view items for
the topic listed.
Duplicate items are not shown unless differences or significant history is
evident.
These pages are updated individually as warranted. Please check
back frequently.
|
Too big to scan, or not yet photographed, I own the following:
.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Eventually, all the material in my collection will be photographed or scanned and shown here.
x |
I have, for the convenience of historians and collectors;
compiled and created a webpage with information pertaining to these railroads
listed above.
Please feel free to visit it at:
Delaware,
Ulster, Greene & Schoharie County, NY;
Railroad Information
Offline Freight Terminal, Industrial
& Pier Stations operating
in:
Brooklyn, Queens, Staten Island, Bronx and Manhattan,
NY
I am a historian of, and collect all memorabilia
from the following "Freight Only" Industrial & Terminal
Railroads,
which operated in:
Brooklyn, Queens, Staten Island, Bronx and
Manhattan, NY:
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Please visit my websites on these subjects at:
Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal
|
...... |
Industrial & Offline Terminal Railroads of
|
.
x |
Military Railroads operating
in:
The New York Metropolitan Area
I am a historian of, and collect all memorabilia
and photographs of Military Railroads that operated in
which operated in:
New York (Manhattan), Kings (Brooklyn), Queens, Richmond (Staten Island),
Bronx Counties, NY:
| GOVERNORS ISLAND / FORT JAY | Manhattan | ... | BROOKLYN NAVY YARD | Brooklyn |
| FORT HAMILTON | Brooklyn | BROOKLYN ARMY TERMINAL | Brooklyn | |
| FORT SCHUYLER | Bronx | FORT WADSWORTH | Staten Island | |
| FORT TILDEN | Queens | FORT TERRY | Suffolk |
Please visit my website on this subject at:
Military Railroads of the
New York Metropolitan Area
.
x |
Erie
RR L-1 class
0-8-8-0
#2600, #2601 &
#2602
Simply put: I also collect
anything in reference to Erie
Railroad L1 Class Locomotives #2600, 2601 &
2602:
.
![]() |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Erie RR - L1 Class #2600
L-1 class Specifications
|
At the time of their construction in 1907
and for several years of operation, these L-1 Class engines were the largest
steam locomotives built, and they operated in pusher service over the famed
Starrucca Viaduct on the New York - Pennsylvania border.
The L-1 class were the only Articulated Camelback steam locomotives
ever built.
Necessity dictated the cab be located on the center of the boiler
instead of on the rear as normal, and this was due to the availability of
anthracite coal in the Eastern U.S. It should be noted, these locomotives
has 100 sq. ft. of grate area, and were hand fired!
As anthracite coal was harder than bituminous (soft) coal, and
taking longer to burn, locomotives using anthracite therefore needed
more "grate area" to sufficiently "fire" a locomotive. As a result, oversized
"Wootten" fireboxes took up most if not all of the space on the rear of the
boiler, and the cab was relocated to middle of the boiler. Such locomotives
became known as "Camelbacks" or "Mother Hubbards".
In 1921, Baldwin Locomotive Works was contracted to rebuild these three L-1 class locomotives into rear cab 2-8-8-2 locomotives. Upon rebuilding, they were also equipped with superheaters, automatic stokers and feedwater heaters. Just nine years later, all three of these behemoths would be scrapped.
There is not much in the way of memorabilia for these engines, with the exception of postcards and litho prints, which I collect as they present themselves.
There are commercially produced scale models of this class of locomotive in both HO Scale (brass - unknown manufacturer ca. 1970's) (brass - current - Daiyoung) and O Scale (current - MTH), but all of these are cost prohibitive for a casual modeller like myself to own (all are currently in excess of $1400 retail). So, I scratchbuilt my own. This was my second attempt at scratchbuilding any locomotive in any scale. My first scratchbuilding attempt being 0-6-0T BEDT #16 in HO scale and I already modified ready to run locomotives into either BEDT #14 and #15 or Camelback 4-4-2 Atlantics. While I am particularly critical of my own creations (I have no patience painting, but will spend hours custom fabricating or modifying frames) I am quite proud of this attempt.

unknown railroad modelers magazine
(if any reader knows which magazine this is from, please let me know
at bedt14@aol.com)
.
The locomotive started as an undecorated Mantua HO scale 2-6-6-2 logging loco (catalog #334) and the tender is from the Mantua 4-4-2 #460 "Lindbergh Special" (catalog #460) or PRR #7002 (catalog #336) locomotives (as well as used by other locomotives in the catalog). This tender closely conforms to the silhouette of the tenders used on the L1's. I purchased super-detailing parts (valves, boiler plugs, handrail standoffs from various venders in Walthers Catalog and through local fellow modeller Frank Bell as well as Mantua. Frank was also generous enough to lend me his copy of Al Staufer's "Erie Power", and somewhere along the line, I had located and acquired HO scale drawings of the Erie L1 class in one of the railroad modeller magazines.
The cab is an "as molded" from Mantua as are the domes and front headlight (which I know is incorrect). Front cylinders are Mantua castings from the 2-6-6-2T Booth Kelly logger, (catalog #326) while rear cylinders were original to this model. Hoses and piping are custom bent brass rod and various diameter solder. The live steam crossover is large diameter solder with heat shrink tubing. The valve in front of the cab is a custom hand filed piece of solder. The reversing bell crank is styrene and bronze phosphor wire, as are the handrails. The firebox is from the shell of a Mantua camelback locomotive (although I can't recall which one though, either a 4-6-2 or 2-8-2). The boiler in front of the cab is from the same Mantua kit. The section of boiler between the firebox and cab is heated and bent styrene sheet, as are the running boards.
The frames are Mantua zamac castings for the 2-6-6-2 locomotive (three axles per frame), which as it turned out driver diameter and axle spacing was close enough to satisfy my needs and I think both were only off by a few scale inches). As I required a four axle per frame arrangement for my 0-8-8-0, I purchased four frames (two front, two rear) from Mantua and proceeded cut the first of the three axles off the rear frames and the last of the three axles on the front frames, making a total of four two axle half frames. Then placing them in a jig, I scored the parts with guide lines for alignment, measuring axle spacing, and proceeded to file the mating surfaces with a jewelers file. I bored holes lengthwise on the cut ends of the four pieces, and using solid brass rod as alignment pins and a dot of two part epoxy on the ends of pins, I proceeded to mate the two halves together for each frame and clamped for an hour. Also, the bottom frame covers (which hold the axles in place) were made using the same techinque (two each cut in halves), only they are not joined and are four pieces, each held in place by the original screw at each end of the frame.
Once the frame pins cured, I assembled the drive wheels with connecting rods (but not main rods) and checked for alignment and binding movement. Fortunately, the design of the frame has brass 'u' shaped axle bearing sleeves that are the full width of the frame, so I only had to file to "tweak" alignment on one bearing sleeve. Once I was satisfied with the axle alignments, I assembled the sub-chassis and motor drive, lubricated all axle bearing surfaces with graphite and sewing machine oil lubricant of my own concoction, and ran the mechanism for two hours in a vise to break in the mechanisms, rods, pistons and other reciprocating parts.
While this was going on, I finished super-detailing the body and began painting. The smokebox is FloQuil flat black with the rest of the body being Floquil semigloss black, applied with a sable brush. Like I said, I am not patient when it comes to painting. My personal philosophy has always been that freight and industrial engines were for the most part grimy and dented and a shiny, perfect paint job just doesn't capture the "grit and use" of a freight engine.
While I used the cast zamac boiler weights from the original model, I added a substantial amount of lead weight to fill in the remainder of the open space within the body shell. I then test assembled the body and chassis for fit, and tweaked accordingly.
Upon completion and my satisfaction of fit, I took the locomotive to the Catskill Mountain Model Railroaders club (then located in Kelly Corners, NY in the Hubble Brothers building), I test ran the locomotive on an actual layout with various radius curves and grades.. After some minor tweaking of the articulating frames, I operated the locomotive at various speeds, loads and direction for several hours. It ran flawlessly! I returned home, finished painting, and applied decals. Funny sideline here: I wanted to number the locomotive 2600, but the 2600 decal wouldn't fit the brass number plate I had purchased for the smokebox front. So, I numbered it 2601! Also, all the lead and solder I packed into the body cavities brings the weight of the locomotive without tender to 2.2 pounds!
The next operating day of the Catskill Model Railroaders Club, I unveiled #2601 in front of the other members. Frank Bell, (who supplied some of the parts and Erie fan) was so totally taken aback by the locomotive, he immediately offered me a substantial amount of money for it! As much as I liked Frank, I just couldn't bear to part with "my 2601". We held a little contest on the layout, pitting #2601 against the other locos. For starters, 2601 out-pulled every other single locomotive in presence. Then we did a "load test". We kept adding cars to a train pulled by #2601, which included a 2.5% grade containing a 20" radius reversing 's' curve (somewhat replicating the famous Ulster & Delaware Railroad's Pine Hill double horseshoe curve here in NY). #2601 only stalled out after 49 cars weighing around 1.5 to 3 ounces each (the Catskill layout standard weight was 1.5 oz., while my personal cars were weighted for 3 oz, due to poor trackage on my old home layout.) This 49 car train this may not seem like much, but keep in mind this was on a scale 2.5% grade with a double 's' curve. I would eventually like to see what #2601 could pull on the straight & level with a consistent 1.25 or 1.5 oz car weight for all the cars.
Other members tried pulling the same train with one, or in some cases two or three locomotives, and failed. In one case, another member had two diesel locomotives with six powered axles attempting to pull the 49 car train, but stalled just past the double 's' turn (point of maximum resistance both on grade and lateral). I ran 2601 up behind the train, and shoved, "pushing" the train just like the prototype in 1907 (albeit this with steam locomotives on the head end)!
I never got around to installing DCC into the locomotive, so for the most part, 2601 now sits on a piece of panel track in my china cabinet on display. Every so often I take it out, put in locomotive cradle and run it to keep the mechanism in working order. Someday, I hope to take a trip over to Starrucca Viaduct and take better images with Starrucca as a back drop. (You'd think I would have already done so, as Starrucca is only about an hour and half away from me!)
Erie L1 Art, Postcards &
Pictures
|
|
| . | |
|
|
| . | |
|
|
| . | |
|
|
| . | |
|
|
| . | |
|
|
|
|
x |
Amtrak (ex-Penn Central) 16000
In 1983, my father and I made one of regular "jaunts" to Sunnyside Yards in Queens, NY. This former Pennsylvania Railroad facility was now the scene for Amtrak, Long Island Railroad and fledgling Erie Lackawanna passenger service (pre-New Jersey Transit) action. Don't ask how or why, but we had unparalleled access to the entire yard for many years.
One of my favorite pieces of equipment, was / is a double ended heavy wrecker: Amtrak 16000. Dad photographed this wrecker in April 1983 with Ektachrome.
|
| .
. |
|
| .
. |
|
| .
. |
|
| .
. |
|
I have no information on it's original owner (prior to Penn Central), or which firm built it; or its current wherabouts and / or disposition. I have managed to located.
I welcome all information and photos.
Please contact me at:
New
York City Subway & Surface
Transportation Companies
Now, after the present day New York City Transit Authority absorbed the Brooklyn passenger railroads (mentioned below), and likewise the other individually owned and operated transportation companies, I find that these items have a place in my collection as well.
There were dozens of competing transportation companies in the City of New York before the formation of the present Transit Authority. While not listed here, I have in my collection a 3 cent ticket from the horsedrawn 5th Avenue "stage" line. So, in short; I collect tickets, tokens, coupons, passes, transfers, metrocards and other fiscal memorabilia from these companies.
Of these, a particularly favorite topic
of mine are the school / student passes of the New York City Transit Authority.
As a former student of the NYC Board of Education myself, I have many fond
memories of these passes. Here is a small sampling of my NYC Transit school
pass collection:
.

.
.
As my entire collection of New York City Transit Memorabilia is quite vast, and it would be extremely labor intensive to scan all the items in my collection, so unfortunately, I do not have them available for viewing. However, if there is something specific you request to see, I would be most pleased to accommodate.
By no means have I listed all the companies below, and the names below are merely an incomplete representative listing.
INTERBOROUGH RAPID TRANSIT |
R.T. CORP |
NEW YORK & QUEENS COUNTY |
INDEPENDENT RAPID TRANSIT |
CHELSEA LINE |
NEW YORK & BROOKLYN BRIDGE |
BROOKLYN MANHATTAN TRANSIT |
ROOSEVELT ISLAND TRAMWAY |
DEPT P & S BRIDGE RAILROAD |
BROOKLYN RAPID TRANSIT |
HUDSON & MANHATTAN |
RICHMOND L & RR CO |
CITY OF NY BOARD OF TRANSPORTATION |
EAST SIDE OMNIBUS |
QUEENSBORO BRIDGE RAILWAY |
NY RAPID TRANSIT |
COMPREHENSIVE OMNIBUS |
JAMAICA BUSES |
NYC TRANSIT SYSTEM |
METROPOLITAN STREET |
GREEN BUS LINES |
| NYC TRANSIT AUTHORITY | WESTCHESTER STREET | TRIBORO COACH |
| AVENUE B & E. BROADWAY TRANSP CO | WEST END STREET | PORT AUTHORITY TRANS HUDSON |
| NEW YORK CITY RAILWAY | BROADWAY BRANCH | OGDEN AVENUE |
CHRISTOPHER & 10TH STREET |
WESTCHESTER AVENUE |
STATEN ISLAND RAPID TRANSIT |
|
UNION RAILWAY CO | |
METROPOLITAN TRANSPORTATION AUTHORITY |
||
SECOND; THIRD; FOURTH; FIFTH; SIXTH; SEVENTH; EIGHTH & TENTH AVENUE LINES |
||
13 & 15TH STREET; 23RD STREET & 34TH STREET CROSSTOWN LINES |
||
42ND STREET, MANHATTANVILLE & ST. NICHOLAS AVE RAILWAY |
||
Passenger Railroads of Brooklyn,
NY
Also gaining favoritism in my topics of
collecting, is exonumia and emphera from railroads that operated in the City
of Brooklyn, NY. Most of these railroads were created to service the growing
visitors to the hotels located at that glorious resort by the sea; Coney
Island, and the Brighton and Manhattan Beaches.
As these railroads changed names whenever
a new owner purchased it, one railroad may have had several names during
it's operational lifespan. These railroads were eventually purchased and
consolidated into the Brooklyn Rapid Transit Co.; and which after many years
of successful operation, the BRT itself was absorbed into the present day
New York City Transit Authority.
| BRIGHTON BEACH | BROOKLYN RAPID TRANSIT |
| BROOKLYN, BATH & CONEY ISLAND | BROOKLYN MANHATTAN TRANSIT |
| BROOKLYN, BATH & WEST END | CONEY ISLAND & BROOKLYN |
| BROOKLYN BUS CORP. | CONEY ISLAND & GRAVESEND |
| BROOKLYN CITY | EAST NEW YORK |
| BROOKLYN CROSS TOWN | FORT HAMILTON |
| BROOKLYN ELEVATED | KINGS COUNTY ELEVATED |
| BROOKLYN, FLATBUSH & CONEY ISLAND | MANHATTAN BEACH |
| BROOKLYN HEIGHTS | NASSAU |
| BROOKLYN UNION ELEVATED | NEW YORK & CONEY ISLAND |
| BROOKLYN & BRIGHTON BEACH | NEW YORK & MANHATTAN BEACH |
| BROOKLYN & JAMAICA | NEW YORK & SEA BEACH |
| BROOKLYN & ROCKAWAY BEACH | PROSPECT PARK & CONEY ISLAND |
| BROOKLYN & QUEENS TRANSIT CORP. | SEA BEACH & BRIGHTON |
SOUTH BROOKLYN |
|
x |
Idlewild Airport
Baggage Destination Tags
About the oddest items I collect
and that I am most fondest of, are Baggage Destination Tags, marked "IDL"
for Idlewild Airport, NY (now known as John F. Kennedy International Airport).
The name change took place to honor the slain president, so this dates all
IDL baggage tags to pre-1964.
My first IDL baggage tag was found hanging from a piece of luggage amongst a huge pile of others set by the curb outside an apartment house for sanitation department removal. I happened to be going by on my bike and saw the tag from Trans World Airlines (TWA) swirling in the breeze. I cut it off and brought home where I show my father, who smiles and says follow me. He brings me to our basement, roots around under some boxes and pulls out his old army issue duffle bag from his service days. What should happen to be attached to the canvas strap handle? Another IDL Tag from Eastern Airlines! Well, I put both in my miscellaneous album.
Well, several years pass, and I locate only one other IDL Baggage Tag on eBay, this one from American Airlines (AA). I email the seller and it turns out, he has two others (United, KLM). Many years pass, and I was unable to locate any others, but wouldn't you know it; two show up on eBay at the same time! (Pan Am & BOAC).
So, in short; I collect these very obscure
markers of aviation history.
.
.
.
x (similar or identical to those above) Please feel free to contact me at: |
.
Suggested Reading:
title |
author |
publisher |
pub. date | isbn |
|
| The Damn Nuisance (Delaware & Northern) |
Archer, Harry D. |
unattributed | 1971 |
I am proud owner of copy
#91 |
|
| The Delaware & Northern | Horton, Gertrude Fitch |
Purple Mountain Press Fleischmanns, NY |
1989 |
0-935796-15-0 (hc) 0-935796-15-4 (pb) |
|
| Rip Van Winkle Railroads | Helmer, William F. |
Howell-North Berkeley, CA |
1970 |
0-8310-7079-X | |
| The Ulster & Delaware | Best, Gerald M. |
Golden West Pub. San Marino, CA |
1972 |
87095-041-X | |
| To the Mountains By Rail (New York, Ontario & Western) |
Wakefield, Manville B. |
Wakefair Press Grahamsville, NY |
1970 | 0-935796-13-4 | |
| Listen To The Whistle (Wallkill Valley) |
Mabee, Carlton |
Purple Mountain Press Fleischmanns, NY |
1995 | 0-935796-69-X | |
| Brooklyn's Waterfront Railways | Bendersky, Jay |
Weekend Chief Mineola, NY |
1988 | 0-9620237-0-1 | |
| New York Harbor Railroads (2 volume set) |
Flagg, Thomas R. |
Morning Sun Books Scotch Plains, NJ |
2002 | Vol 1: 1-58248-042-6 Vol 2: 1-58248-048-6 |
Contact
Me
If you should find errors on this website; should you
wish to contact me regarding any of the above topics, whether it be for
information you need, or to offer me something you have; please feel free
to contact me at:
P. M. Goldstein
(845) 586 - 4672
This website is fondly dedicated to the memory of my father Stan.
Quite simply, he is solely responsible for my interest in railroading, and for that I shall forever be indebted.
See you at the next stop dad.

.
STANLEY
GOLDSTEIN |
![]() |
This website and all text All rights reserved.
P. M. Goldstein |
GFY RFM DK NM JL