INDUSTRIAL & OFFLINE
OF BROOKLYN, QUEENS, STATEN ISLAND, BRONX AND MANHATTAN:
Update List (past 60 days)
It is with deepest apologies to fans and readers of this website that updates have not been more forthcoming.
As I am sure most of you are aware, as one gets
older there comes increased familial responsibilies for one's parent
Hopefully now these matters have been resolved and smoothed out, you can at least expect some long overdue updates!
I thank you sincerely for your understanding...
I am almost always available to assist or answer inquiries, and I answer
emails promptly (usually within an hour or two)
so please do not hestitate in contacting me:
Please Note: As much as it pains me to insist upon this as it goes against everything I authored and published this website for, but
copying (in either electronic or printed form) and re-distribution (either
electronically or in printed form)
Unfortunately, it has come to my attention that
someone has been using images, scans of documents and my personally notated
maps (of which there cannot be any others)
(with subchapter listing)
A substantial amount of documents, newspaper articles,
large images, technical drawings, maps and graphics were placed on their
* = .pdf file with no return link to this page - right click and open file in new window or use back arrow on your web browser to return to this website!
For those interested parties, I have authored two other websites pertaining to locomotives and railroads in the New York Metropolitan Area. As a result of my BEDT interests, I continue to compile detailed histories of terminals and industries located in Brooklyn, Queens, Staten Island, Bronx & Manhattan:
& OFFLINE TERMINAL RAILROADS
OF BROOKLYN, QUEENS, STATEN ISLAND, BRONX & MANHATTAN, NY
In conjunction with that research, I have also compiled a list of locations and rosters of locomotives that operated on Military Bases & Installations in the New York Metropolitan Area:
RAILROADS & LOCOMOTIVES
OF THE NEW YORK METROPOLITAN AREA
Welcome! You have found the most comprehensive and authoritative website on the world wide web regarding the facilities & operations known as Palmer's Dock, East River Terminal Railroad and the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal. As information continues to be located, submitted and obtained on a frequent basis, I strongly recommend that you bookmark this website and check back frequently, as this website is updated as that information arrives.
This website originally started out as a mere roster and photo album of only the steam locomotives; yet has progressed into a detailed history of the people, the properties and all the equipment that eventually went on to be known as the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal. This historical accounting has even exceeded my expectations, and is made possible with the assistance of many fine and established historians and BEDT fans including: Robert Brendel, Jose Feliciano,Thomas Flagg, Tom Hendrickson, Joseph Roborecky, Paul Strubeck and Jay Wanczyk; and it is only fair they receive credit for their contributions. This website is as much theirs as it is mine and everyone who has contributed to this website appears in the special thanks chapter in alphabetical order.
Not forgetting what I set out to do, I am also proud to acknowledge that this website also contains the largest photo archives of Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal motive power you are ever likely to see on the web. The collection of images on this website, contains the images from several notable "old time" collections; F. Rodney Dirkes, Harold Fagerberg, Gerald Landau, and Steve Meyer to name a few. This collection of images continues to grow and now contains the expansive collection of the late Frank Zahn.
It is also due to the unprecedented and selfless cooperation of many other renowned photographers, (as well the current owners of those photo archives), such as: Art Bink, Seth Bramson, Gene Collora, Tim Darnell, Al Galanty, Theodore Gleichmann, David Keller, Norman & Marie Wright, Ron Ziel and many others. They made their generous contributions to this website in good will and for the entire railroading community to share, in admiration of this Fallen Flag Railroad.
Therefore, I ask that you please respect the ownership copyrights on those said images where listed. Other than that, please enjoy the website and don't forget to sign the guestbook!
~ Philip M. Goldstein ~
A Brief History Of Marine - Rail Traffic in New York
A Glimpse of the Way Things Were
It is the year 1870. Ulysses S. Grant is in the White House after being elected president following a successful victory in the Civil War. Walrus mustaches are popular among men, and tops hats are in. The Department of Justice is created as a government agency. The Army Weather Bureau is created, and this would become the National Weather Service and the current Cape Hatteras Lighthouse is placed in service. The transcontinental railroad celebrates it's 1 year anniversary. There are no electric lights and either the mail or the telegraph is the means of communicating long distance, (even though a gentleman inventor named Alexander Graham Bell is tinkering with acoustic telegraphy, which in a a few years yields a device that will eventually become known as the telephone).
In New York City; the Statue of Liberty does not exist and just north, Ellis Island, known then as Castle Garden, is beginning to bustle with freshly arrived immigrants looking to become Americans. North Manhattan is wild forests. Staten Island is similar with a smattering of farms. Brooklyn and Queens are highly developed the closer you get to New York Harbor, but the eastern edges of Brooklyn & Queens are what would be considered "rural", and farmland dominated the view. Long distance travel, primarily via horse drawn wagon; is beginning to give way to the railroads. But, horse drawn carriages and small steam locomotive drawn street cars were the way to travel anywhere out of walking distance within the city.
Long Island (which is comprised of Kings [Brooklyn], Queens, Nassau & Suffolk Counties), and Staten Island (Richmond County) were truly isolated from the mainland US. There are no bridges or tunnels spanning the East or Hudson Rivers. The Brooklyn Bridge would not be opened until 1883 and the Manhattan, Williamsburg, Queensboro or George Washington Bridges would not be built until may years after that. There are no Holland, Lincoln or Queens Midtown Tunnels. The only way to transport anything to these locations was by water: either by ship, boat, lighter or barge. If you found it necessary to go from Brooklyn or Queens to Manhattan, or from Staten Island or New Jersey to Manhattan, you would have to take a ferry. The waterborne vessels of this period are powered either by wind and sail or primitive steam power and coal is starting to increase as the fuel of choice for furnaces and boilers, which are used for heat or propulsion power.
The "second" industrial revolution is underway in earnest, and the mass production of consumer goods is taking hold. To get the raw materials, commodities and items from the mainland to Long Island, everything was shipped by water from New Jersey to Manhattan and Long Island. Today, it is difficult to envision this isolation with the myriad of bridges, highways, and tunnels (and gridlock!) linking Brooklyn, Queens and Long Island with the mainland.
As a result of this waterborne traffic, many dockside terminals and warehouses were built around the New York City proper for storage. The large mainland trunk line (or known later on as Class 1) railroads had their own equipment and properties; namely: tugboats, lighters, barges and ferries to bring these commodities to and from various mainland railroad points around the NY Harbor. To get the commodities to the New Jersey shoreline; many railroads, their locomotives themselves powered by steam, have built a vast network of tracks radiating towards the New York area.
In the pre-float bridge days, freight had to be manually transferred at the docks and wharves from newly arrived trains to barges and lighters (a lighter is essentially a barge with an enclosed structure on it, similar in design to a one room warehouse). Of the lighters that carried products that need to be kept chilled, (i.e.: milk, meat, fruits and vegetables), these lighters were insulated (usually with double walls filled with sawdust) and were equipped with roof hatches for the loading of ice to be carried on board.
This was a time consuming and back breaking method, of having to unload a freight car on the dock, load it onto a lighter or barge, transport the lighter cross-harbor to Brooklyn, then unload it. Then repeat the process again for the trip back. It also required vast labor pools. There had to be a better way...
of Carfloats & Float bridges
(or how to get freight cars from here to there by water)
So in order to load and unload the railcars themselves from the carfloats, the carfloats would be moored to the device known as the float bridge and that's where the pontoon type float bridge came in. But, the actual design of the local float bridge had to be figured out at that point.
This dilemma had been solved by the invention and development of the carfloating and the "float bridge" or "transfer bridge". The history of the the first railroad car transfer bridge in the United States, reflects that it was built in 1838 under a joint venture by the Camden & Amboy and Baltimore & Potomac Railroads to provide passenger car ferry service across the Susquehanna River at Harve De Grace and Perryville, Maryland.
Understanding the Differences between "Carferrying" and "Carfloating"
It should be understood that the primary difference between carferrying and carfloating is thus:
Car ferrying essentially is a way to take entire trains (freight or passenger) across bodies of water; at a location where for various reasons a bridge or tunnel would have been impractical. Once this train has been ferried from one shore to the other, it would continue on its journey to its final destination, which may be hundreds of more miles from the ferrying point. Of course, when a bridge could be built over (or a tunnel under) that waterway at a later date, it would be; thereby greatly reducing those delays in those trains having to use car ferry transportation.
Carfloating on the other hand, at least in regard to New York Area operations, started primarily as an extension to a terminal operation dedicated specifically for freight, which is quite different from car ferrying. Of course, carfloating was used where a bridge was impractical as well. This became especially so, as freight traffic grew and destinations all around the harbor were added to the terminal. Many bridges would be needed to span the Hudson, East & Harlem Rivers and since the bridges and their associated approaches would need to be built tall enough as not to impede the marine traffic, a great deal of very valuable real estate would be wasted on the shores of New York Harbor and connecting estuaries! Carfloats however, could deliver anywhere along the hundreds of miles of waterfront in the region, over tax-free "real estate" maintained by the government, i.e: the harbor waters. So the carfloating system remained in use.
The Advent of Carfloating
first intensive use of the dedicated carfloating of freight in the United
States seems to have occurred during the Civil War, when freight cars were
floated on makeshift barges along the Potomac River, to serve places where
existing rail lines could not reach for various reasons. As published
in "American Railroad Freight Car", by John H. White, Jr. (1993, Johns
Hopkins University Press) credits Brigadier General Herman Haupt for
first carfloating on a barge in 1862, during the Civil War. In the October
2000 issue of "Model Railroader" magazine, p. 82-85 there is an illustrated
article on the November 1862 construction, under the direction of Brigadier
General Herman Haupt, of a carfloat operation for the Union Army at Alexandria,
Haupt had been the Chief Engineer of the Pennsylvania Railroad and was in the process of constructing the Hoosac Tunnel when he was "conscripted" to run the U. S. Military Railroad. Two steamtug drawn floats were constructed, each holding 8 cars transversely, and they were served by triple-track aprons at the transfer landings, running from Alexandria, Virginia, down the Potomac River 60 miles to Aquia Landing, about 10 miles northeast of Fredericksburg, Maryland.
In addition, George Abdill on page 48 of his book "Civil War Railroads: A Pictorial Story of the War between the States, 1861-1865 "(1961, Indiana University Press) calls it "pioneer car ferry" which it wasn't. Instead, it was the pioneer carfloat in the U. S. The article has three images from National Archives, but Kempinski's reproduction was far better.
General Haupt supervised the construction of these transfer bridges at both terminals of this proposed water route. General Haupt also designed, requisitioned materials and built the unique railroad float barges. The carfloats consisted of two large-sized Schuylkill type barges moored side by side, across both of which long timbers were placed supporting eight tracks mounted transversely (from port to starboard instead of the modern configuration of bow to stern).
At Alexandria, VA; the loaded freightcars were placed singly aboard each of the eight tracks of the carfloat. The carfloat was then towed sixty miles by steam tug to Aquia Landing, VA. Once at this location, railroad crews unloaded the carfloats by pulling the cars.
Brigadier General Herman Haupt
But here is something unusual that is seen in the photos: At one terminal there are five sets of track on the bulkhead which appear to be for the loading of the eight tracks on the carfloat. However, there does not appear and movement to them i.e. to raise and lower. Were these rails actually used to load the carfloat? If so, that would require moving the carfloat to load the remaining three tracks.
At the other terminal, there were three transfer bridges consisted of only three single tracks (in individual bridge spans)! After the first set of three cars was unloaded, this arrangement would necessitate the need to move the carfloat to unload the next set of three car, and move the carfloat once more to unload the final two freight cars. A very labor intensive method.
While not this has not been confirmed, it appears from maps and background detail that the three transfer bridges were located in Alexandria, VA; and the eight track bulkhead was at Aquia Landing, VA. We were able to locate three images of the operation in searching the web. All three images are attributed to the National Archives, but were located on a very nice website showcasing Bernard Kempinki's "The American Civil War in Miniature".
All three photos:
Once the freight cars were unloaded, they were then able to forward those freight cars with their contents, without the need of "breaking bulk" (unloading the freight from the car) along the rebuilt rail line of the Richmond, Fredericksburg and Potomac Railroad to Falmouth, across from Fredericksburg, VA; on the north bank of the Rappahannock River.
According to Haupt this was:
"the first known attempt to transport cars by water with their cargoes unbroken. The Schuylkill barges performed admirably and thus was formed a new era in military railroad transportation. The length of the barges were sufficient for 8 tracks carrying eight cars, and two such floats would carry the sixteen cars which constituted a train."
All of this construction occurred over a period of two weeks. Haupt was ready to support further military operations by November 17th, 1862. As to how the cars were loaded onto the barges, the technology was already in place for carferrying. So the Civil War usage of carfloating maybe was more of an inspiration than an invention, inspiring the New Jersey railroads about how to serve Manhattan without having to unload everything out of the cars onto ferryboats or sail lighters on the Jersey side.
Carfloating comes to New York Harbor
The first mention of carfloating in New York Harbor can be read in the (Trenton) Daily State Gazette, November 13, 1866, p. 3:
"CENTRAL RAILROAD: The Central Railroad Company [of New Jersey] are having a large scow constructed for the purpose of conveying the freighter cars directly from Communipaw to the New York side. It is large enough to hold eight cars which will be run in on rails from the track on this side. It will be in operation next week. The Western mail which has heretofore been carried by the Erie Railway has been transferred to the Central Road."
As to this and the early history of carfloating in general, why do we call this only a "hint" ? While this article does state fact, it turns out that there were forces behind this operation that were more complex than mentioned here. Believe it or not, the Pennsylvania Railroad was the real sponsor, even though at the time its own tracks came nowhere near New York Harbor!
As read in "History of the Pennsylvania Railroad", by J. Elfreth Watkins, 1896; the Empire Transportation Company's line was organized in 1866, it wished to deliver to Manhattan and since the Pennsylvania Railroad did not reach or have a terminal at that location, it contracted with the Central Railroad of New Jersey, which did build the first carfloat for that purpose. Early in 1867, the operation began with the first carfloats carrying those freight cars across the Hudson River. The "car-ferry" route was from Communipaw, NJ Terminal to Pier 14, on Manhattan's west side, which was occupied at the time by the Central Railroad of New Jersey.
By this method, the Empire Transportation Company was able to load & unload its freight cars at Pier 14 in New York City and transport said freight to its destinations without the need to "break bulk". Arrangements were then made by the Union Railroad and Transportation Company with the Camden & Amboy Railroad and the New Jersey Railroad & Transportation Company for hauling these freight cars through Jersey City, instead of unloading the freight in New Jersey, and transporting it via steamboat between South Amboy and Pier 2 in Manhattan, which had been the existing procedure. As the remainder of the railroads in New York Harbor saw the advantages of carfloating, it rapidly gained acceptance and use. Lighters by the way, weren't totally obsolete, as some railroads still maintained "pier stations" along the waterfronts, where there was insufficient room for a rail terminal and float bridge.
Lowell Palmer also recognized the usefulness of carfloating, and as discussed later on this website, he would install his first float bridge on the Williamsburg waterfront in 1876. According to research, this would be the very first float bridge constructed for use by a Brooklyn rail terminal; and in all likelihood, the first float bridge for a rail terminal anywhere east of the Hudson River.
Should you be interested in an in-depth comprehensive look at the development, designs and histories of carfloat transfer / float bridges in the New York Harbor area, please refer to this page of the website: Development of Carfloat Transfer Bridges in New York Harbor.
If you would like to learn how carfloats
were "moored" to the float bridges, and the proper procedure for such, please
visit the following chapter through this link:
Mooring & Pinning Procedures.
Railroads on the Shores
of New York Harbor
There were dozens of railroads that took up residence on the Hudson River shoreline, some with more than one railyard. Many of those railroads would merge with another throughout their history, and henceforth bring about a name change, but for historical purposes I will name each railroad as an individual, as this website applies to the cumulative history since 1870. A list of those railroads, throughout the history of New York Marine Rail operations, are as follows:
1943 Terminal & Facilities Map for the Port of New York
Mere words cannot show the prevalence of the mainline railroads on the shores of the Hudson River, so I have included a excerpt from a 1943 Terminal & Facilities Map for the Port of New York, issued by the New York Central Railroad. You can view a large image by clicking on the thumbnail:
Throughout those ensuing years however; while almost all these railroads would have some sort of facility on the the west bank of the mighty Hudson River (also referred to as the North River), those shipments from New Jersey that were destined for Brooklyn, Queens and Long Island; meant going through the four Brooklyn and one Queens terminals.
Only a small handful of the trunk line / class 1 railroads had terminals in Brooklyn and Queens that were equipped with float bridges for carfloating operations, those being:
Baltimore & Ohio / New York New Haven & Hartford RR
Long Island RR / New York New Haven & Hartford RR
Delaware, Lackawanna & Western RR
Delaware, Lackawanna & Western RR
Long Island RR / Pennsylvania RR
*Footnote: the Pennsylvania yard at North
4th Street was surrounded by BEDT and yet had no physical connection
to the BEDT tracks that surrounded it, as was the BEDT Pidgeon Street yard
was across the street from the LIRR yard, but again there would be no track
connection between the
two. The only interchange
connections between these railroad terminals was by carfloat.
Independent / Contract Terminals of Brooklyn
In addition to the large trunk line or "class 1" railroads carfloating to and from Manhattan and New Jersey, there were also the "independent" or "contract" terminals located in Brooklyn. These were known as "contract terminals", as they would be contracted by the trunk line / class 1 railroads to deliver the freight cars to their final destinations in Brooklyn and Queens, which of course in most cases those trunk line / class 1 railroads could not do.
These terminals, such as the Brooklyn Dock & Terminal and Brooklyn Wharf & Warehouse would be eventually absorbed by the larger terminals and after they were absorbed, history may have forgotten their names until now. These contract terminals would prosper, expand, and some would eventually utilize steam, diesel & electric locomotives for the unloading and loading of rail traffic transported by barge, lighter and carfloat.
The recognized "independent" or "contract" (non-class 1) terminals with railroads in Brooklyn were:
It should also be understood that Palmer's Dock / East River Terminal Railroad / Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal, New York Dock, Bush Terminal and Jay Street Connecting offline terminals were known collectively as the "Union Freight Terminals". This was due to the fact that the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal, Bush Terminal and New York Dock all handled freight for many of the Class 1 railroads. This is in contrast to the Class 1 owned offline terminals, where almost all of the freight handled was consigned to that sole specific railroad.
Palmer's Dock would be organized this year, 1870; and thus is the reason this year is the starting point for our journey through history above. Palmer's Dock, and through it's successors: the East River Terminal and the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal, operated until 1983 and at it's peak, would have a total capacity of 1000+ cars, would transport 27,000 cars per year and the distinction of serving the New York "Brooklyn" Navy Yard.
Palmer's Dock / East River Terminal Railroad
/ Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal had many float bridges throughout
its history, which were located at:
|North 3 Street||Williamsburg, Brooklyn|
|North 5 Street||Williamsburg, Brooklyn|
|North 6 Street||Williamsburg, Brooklyn|
|North 9 Street||Williamsburg, Brooklyn|
|Wallabout Terminal||Wallabout Basin, Brooklyn|
|Brooklyn Navy Yard||Wallabout Basin, Brooklyn|
|Pidgeon Street||Long Island City, Queens|
|Warren Street||Jersey City, NJ|
as well as pier stations, which were located at:
|13th Street "Queensboro Terminal"||Long Island City, Queens|
|South 3 Street||Williamsburg, Brooklyn|
I myself, am particularly interested in the history of the Palmer's Dock / East River Terminal Railroad / Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal; and this website reflects that interest. Now that we can understand of the mechanics of carfloating and the importance of the contract terminal in Brooklyn, we will now delve into the intricate and detailed history of the Palmer's Dock / East River Terminal / Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal.
Palmer's Dock / East River Terminal Railroad
Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal
Significant Dates In
Palmers Dock / East River Terminal / Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal History
I felt it was important for the reader to comprehend the significant dates in Palmer's Dock, East River Terminal and Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal history. Therefore, this chapter outlines those significant dates, in chronological order.
|1870:||Palmer's Dock wharf facilities organized|
|1873:||First carfloat & tugboat purchased by Lowell Palmer, and Erie RR is sole interchange customer / partner|
|1874:||Palmer's Dock railyard construction begins
Palmer's Dock establishes and leases a terminal to Erie Railroad
Partnership with Havemeyer & Elder begins
|1875:||First steam locomotive purchased
Palmer's Dock begins interchange with NYC, WS, CRRNJ, DL&W & PRR railroads
|1876:||First float bridge installed along Kent Avenue in Williamsburg, Brooklyn|
|1905:||Lowell Palmer disassociates from Palmer's Dock operations|
|1906:||Palmer's Dock properties is incorporated by Havemeyer's &
into Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal (navigation corp.)
|1906:||Pidgeon Street Terminal, Long Island City opens|
|1907:||East River Terminal Railroad incorporated by Havemeyer's & Elder|
|1910:||Warren Street Terminal, Jersey City opens|
|1914:||Queensboro Terminal (pier station), Long Island City opens|
|1915:||ERT (railroad) & BEDT (navigation) consolidated and re-incorporated as BEDT (a consolidated "freight terminal" corp.)|
|1928?||Warren Street Terminal, Jersey City closes|
|1936:||Wallabout Market Terminal, Brooklyn opens|
|1940:||(Possibly 1941) Operations begin in New York Navy Yard, Brooklyn|
|1941:||Wallabout Market Terminal, Brooklyn closed due to expansion of New York Navy Yard, Brooklyn|
|1962:||First diesel-electric locomotive purchased|
|1963:||Steam locomotive operations cease|
|1964:||Bulk Flour Terminal opens|
|1966:||US Government sells Brooklyn Navy Yard to NY City for private development (operations continue)|
|1967?:||North 5 Street float bridge use discontinued (possibly North 3rd Street as well)|
|1972:||BEDT purchased by Petro Oil / Burmah Oil|
|1976?||Petro / Burmah Oil (and BEDT) purchased by R. J. Reynolds Tobacco and merged with Aminoil|
|1976:||BEDT receives contract from ConRail to carfloat for themselves & New York Dock|
|1977:||(possibly 1978) Pidgeon Street Terminal, Long Island City closed|
|1978:||Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal purchased by New York Dock|
|1983:||Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal / New York Dock ceases all operations|
Palmer's Dock / East River
Terminal Railroad / Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal -
Corporation Flow Chart: 1870 - 1972:
I have taken the time to draw up a flow chart, to better show the dates of incorporation and the principles involved with those corporations. This chart was originally in two parts in the Palmer's Dock and Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal chapters:
Palmer's Dock; 1870 - 1906
Lowell Mason Palmer
| Lowell Mason Palmer, for whom Palmer's
Dock was named for; was a significant manufacturer of barrels and casks in
the New York area. These barrels and casks were how large amounts of refined
sugar, among many other commodities, was shipped in those days.
Lowell Mason Palmer was born on March 11, 1845; in Chester, Ohio. Lowell was the oldest of two children from the marriage of Chester Palmer and Achsah Smith Melvin and could trace his roots on his mothers side to the Mayflower.
Lowell Palmer was educated in public schools and attended Western Reserve College where he was a student until the outbreak of the Civil War.
Upon the fall of Fort Sumter in 1861, and the call for 75,000 volunteers by President Lincoln, Lowell Palmer enlisted at the age of 16. He would fight in all the the battles of the Cumberland including: Chickamauga under General Thomas; in General Schofield's Corps in the Atlantic Campaign under General Sherman; and he participated in the battles of Franklin and Nashville. He became a member of General Schofield's staff, and would rise to the rank of Captain.
Lowell Palmer would marry Grace Humphrey Foote on October 24, 1877. Together, they would have eight children:
To those of you who are paying attention:
you will notice these children's names match the names of the original group
of locomotives purchased by Lowell Palmer listed in the steam locomotive
roster! There is one exception however: no locomotive ever bore Harold's
My hypothesis is that Harold either died at childbirth or shortly after. As it turns out this my hypothesis is correct, as Harold died at 9 years of age.
Locomotive #7 would be named "Chester", and presumably named after Palmer's birthplace of Chester, Ohio.
Lowell Palmer was a proponent of righteousness and beneficent action in business and citizenship, and his values won him the respect of many of the foremost business men in New York City. He was also a great lover of art (one of the very few things he had in common with Henry Havemeyer), and from 1900 to the time of his passing, he would be trustee of the Brooklyn Gallery of Arts & Sciences. The gallery of paintings in his home in Brooklyn was considered one of the most noted in the City of Brooklyn and his library contained many first editions.
Lowell Palmer died at 70 years of age in Stamford, Connecticut; on September 30, 1915. At the time of his death, he was:
president of: E . R. Squibb (pharmaceuticals);
His son, Lowell Melvin Palmer, eventually rose to the position of president for the Brooklyn Cooperage Co. From the maps you will see below, you will find many structures labeled for Brooklyn Cooperage in the Palmer's Dock area, so it appears that Palmer utilized their properties along the Williamsburg waterfront to further their investments.
Palmer's company was located in the Williamsburg section of Brooklyn on the East River waterfront. The property was immediately north of, and adjoined the American Sugar Refining plant located at South 3rd Street, in the area formerly known as "Palmer's Dock" or "Palmer's Cooperage". A cooperage is the manufacture and / or repair of wood barrels and casks.
The Palmer Cooperage was organized in 1867 and it was known at the time as "Palmer's Cooper Shop". Sometime in the late 1870's or early 1880's, Palmer relocated his cooperage to the property that was bounded by 1st and 2nd Streets and by North 6th and North 7th Streets. "1st Street" was later renamed Kent Avenue, and "2nd Street" was renamed Wythe Avenue. Palmer would construct another building between North 5th and North 6th Streets a short time afterwards.
Palmer's Cooperage, would supply all the wood casks and barrels to most, if not all, of the Sugar Refiners in the Williamsburg area (Havemeyer & Elder were not the only one) and would eventually expand further north to include properties around North 7th Street and Kent Avenue, as well as the horse stable between North 9th and North 10th Streets and Kent and Wythe Avenues. His great success caught the attention of Frederick C. Havemeyer and in 1874, Havemeyer & Elder turned over all their cooperage interests to Lowell Palmer, and the Brooklyn Cooperage Company was organized, with Mr. Palmer (Sr.) as president.
It was also at this time that Palmer and the Havemeyer's formed a co-partnership and organized the terminal and railroad "Palmer's Dock".
Palmer's Dock - Property & History
The Beginning - Sugar
The Palmer's Dock facilities, ultimately were created as a result from the sugar refiners of the area (American Sugar only being one of many) having so much raw material to receive and so much refined product for shipment. In short: Havemeyer & Elder, the owners of American Sugar, would receive raw sugar through Palmer's Dock and then refine it. Then Palmer would package it for shipment and ship it as well. As a result, Lowell Palmer eventually recognized the lucrativeness in creating freight depots in the area to handle freight, and in 1870, he began to do so.
As per Tom Flagg, in a document viewed by him; BEDT Vice President Edward C. Potter Jr. gave a lecture to the "Brooklyn Traffic Club" on April 25, 1913, in which it explains how Lowell Palmer purchased a carfloat and a tugboat in 1873 to transport freight cars to and from the Williamsburg location. These freight cars would be loaded aboard the carfloat and picked up at the Erie facility (in New Jersey) and then brought to and unloaded along the bulkhead in Williamsburg. At this early point in time, they were not removed from the carfloat.
Not only was the Brooklyn Cooperage formed (mentioned in Palmer's Cooperage chapter above), and as his early business partnership with Havemeyer & Elder apparently was quite successful, they would enter partnership once again in 1874, in which the Palmer's Dock railroad terminal was established. Acquisition / merger details of Palmer's' Dock and Havemeyer & Elder are scarce, but it has been recorded that Lowell Palmer supervised operations after it's organization.
Freight Terminal & Steam Locomotive
Also in 1874, Palmer established a freight terminal on North 5th Street between Wythe Avenue and Berry Street. Palmer began laying a network of railroad tracks to move that freight to and from the East River bulkhead and the freighthouse. He leased that freighthouse to the Erie Railroad. In 1875, the first steam locomotive for Palmer's Dock was constructed by Baldwin locomotive works, and it would be named after the Havemeyer founder, Frederick C. Havemeyer. Afterwards, other locomotives would follow as the railroad expanded.
Palmer would conduct business with Erie Railroad exclusively for about one year, at which time he would now begin to interchange with other railroads: New York Central & Hudson River, West Shore, Central RR of New Jersey, among other several others. From historical accounts, the first trackage was laid in the vicinity of North 5th Street. As the other railroads leased property from Palmer and the freighthouses constructed, the trackage would expand north.
First Float Bridge In Brooklyn
In 1876, Palmer constructed and installed what is understood to be the first float bridge in the Williamsburg area, much less all of Brooklyn. Early property maps and the Galt & Hoy drawing below show the concentration of trackage in the North 5th Street area, and this is where the first float bridge was installed. The significance of this may be lost in this modern era of "door to door" shipping; but in 1876, this was a substantial leap forward in the the transportation of freight cars via water. Being the success that it was, other Brooklyn based terminals would follow Palmer's lead and install float bridges at their terminals as well.
Tom Flagg generously submitted the following item from his archives. It is a Galt & Hoy Panoramic Drawing from 1879 of the Palmer's Dock facilities. What makes it more unique is the fact that it was done from an aerial perspective. It shows a single float bridge located between North 5th and North 6th Streets with trackage extending east along North 5th Street as previously discussed.
Galt & Hoy - 1879
Special thanks to Tom Flagg for this beauty!
Consolidation and Expansion
In 1890, Palmer's growing property acquisitions necessitated the need for him to began to reconstruct and consolidate his property. His property now housed many more freight depots, structures and team tracks for the growing railroad and by this point in time, the Palmer property now comprised of the area between North 4th Street and North 10th Street, and between the East River bulkhead and Berry Street.
Tom Hendrickson located the following newspaper article on Palmer's Dock, which is dated Aug 17, 1890 and was printed in the Brooklyn Eagle. This article is a very interesting read, as it not only describes the local merchants, but the sizes of the structures and estimated cost for the construction of same:
|"A Huge Railroad Depot"- Brooklyn Eagle, August 17, 1890|
Palmer's Board of Trade - Hay & Produce Market
Also, according to City of New York Department of Health Annual Reports (1905 & 1907) and the August, 17, 1890 Brooklyn Eagle article above; Palmer's Dock was also the chief place for the importation and distribution of vegetables in bulk in Brooklyn. Palmer also organized an entity known as the "Palmer's Dock Hay & Produce Board of Trade". The nature of this "Board of Trade", from what I comprehend it to be, was a operating entity of Palmer's Dock as to secure a better lot price on the bulk purchase of hay and produce, to be distributed from a centralized location (Palmer's Dock).
The original farmers market was located in the Wallabout Market some distance south (by the Brooklyn Navy Yard). According to newspaper accounts this Wallabout facility was crowded and dilapidated. Palmer recognized the need for a newer, larger facility and commenced construction of such in Williamsburg. There would be several instances of the Pennsylvania Railroad filing a lawsuit against this Palmer's Board of Trade, for offering lower than reasonable rates in competition to the Pennsylvania, and not furnishing the same terminal facilities to the Pennsylvania RR as Palmer would do for others. This new Hay & Produce Market, was a huge success and help bolster Palmer's reputation, as well as keep the Williamsburg waterfront in active competition with the other developing terminals and markets.
In 1892, Lowell Palmer constructed a huge coal depot at North 9th Street between Kent Avenue and the East River. This coal depot was actually multi-story, and served by an elevated coal trestle extending out onto the pier and into a covered piershed. This coal depot replaced the coal shed of the Philadelphia and Reading Railroad as well as a few other minor coal dealers.
Please note, it was first thought that the original coal depot was located on North 5th Street and Berry Street. This is not the case and was an error on the author's part. The cylindrical concrete coal silos located on North 5th Street between Wythe Avenue and Berry Street (that appears in some of the locomotive images) was actually the Lehigh & Scranton Coal Co. and was built in the late 1910's or early 1920's. It is NOT the original Palmers Coal Depot as previously stated here. Palmer's Coal Depot is marked as such on the 1898 Belcher Hyde Property Map in the Terminals, Facilities & Yards chapter.
By building this coal depot, Palmer could buy coal at cost, transport to his facility, and resell at great profit to coal dealers in the area. The new coal depot was more of a coal trestle with storage bins underneath. The hopper cars would be brought up an incline by locomotive and located over the bins, and discharge their load into the bins below. Then, the coal retailer would back his "wagon" under the silo, and the coal was screened and dispensed directly into the wagon, to be delivered to the customer's homes and businesses.
Portions of the elevated coal trestle and pier can be seen in the 1914 photo that appeared in the weekly publication of the Merchants Association of New York: "Greater New York". This image is available for viewing below in the East River Terminal chapter; East River Terminal Property Photo.
This new coal depot was a significant improvement in reducing labor and handling time, as the previous method employed by the Philadelphia & Reading Railroad required many men to first shovel it out of the barges into tubs that would be hoisted to the dock side. Then it would be shoveled into wheel barrows, and then walked up a few blocks to their shed, then shovel it once again. This was very time consuming, labor intensive and costly. As Palmer's new facility directly transferred coal into the depot from the hopper car, this cut back significantly on manpower, and likewise labor cost. As a result of this "new" cost efficient method, Palmer and his coal depot prospered. Here is an "in depth" article:
|"Palmer's Coal Depot" - Brooklyn Eagle, October 12, 1892|
Palmer's Dock would go on to construct a pier warehouse at the foot of North 7th Street with other structures served by rail on both sides of North 9th Street west of Kent Avenue. Palmer's Dock also had several buildings including a stable throughout the surrounding neighborhood.
Palmer's Dock trackage also continued to serve the main warehouse of Brooklyn Cooperage which was located between North 6th and North 7th Streets, (which divided the two railyards) by way of a service track on North 7th Street. Please refer to the 1898 Belcher Hyde Property Map and 1907 / 1908 Bromley Property Map in the Terminals, Facilities & Yards chapter.
Oddly, from referencing these property maps, Palmer's Dock trackage did not extend south to North 4th Street where the American Sugar Refinery was located; which from all accounts was the reason Havemeyer & Elder and Palmer's Cooperage united to form the Palmer's Dock and which in turn would eventually become the BEDT.
Research by Jay Wanczyk located the following entries in a book titled "The Eastern District of Brooklyn", by Ambrose Armbruster. It was first published in 1912, with additions in 1941. All references are short, and not all have dates, and they are listed by street. The following are excerpts from the listings:
Kent Avenue pages:
"Lowell M. PALMER, established 1870, a terminus
of the Erie R. R. at PALMER'S Dock.
"It soon got very crowded. The water front, including
the dock at the foot of North 6th Street,
"PALMER'S Cooperage, a 6 story brick building on Kent between North 6th & North 7th."
"The great fire in DICK & MEYER'S Sugar Factory
so badly damaged these buildings that they
"Lowell M. PALMER had erected a new cooperage between
North 5th & 6th Streets.
"Austin NICHOLS & Co. erected their warehouse at North 3rd to North 4th Streets in 1914."
"HAVEMEYER'S old sugar refinery later covered this
site. The HAVEMEYER'S began
N. 5th Street pages:
"Lowell PALMER'S cooperage, Kent Avenue, damaged
by fire, May 28, 1887
"A freight station of the Pennsylvania Rail Road
Co., in 1905 was here, another at Wallabout.
N. 6th Street pages:
"West Shore Rail Road, had its freight yard at Kent Avenue."
"Lowell M. PALMER docks, 1905, at the foot of the
"WINTJEN, DICK & SCHUMACHER, 1858, sugar refinery,
(This Dick & Meyer sugar refinery might be the one that became part of the "freight yard" noted above under Kent Avenue.)
"The sugar house on North 8th Street, near the river
front was destroyed by fire."
"Lehigh Valley Rail Road, had a freight station at Kent Avenue."
Other Palmer Locations
Lowell Palmer would also have an "L" shaped piershed located in Jersey City around 1908 (possibly prior to this date) through 1919. This piershed would also go on to serve BEDT and American Sugar Refiners at their Warren Street Terminal.
This piershed can been seen (barely) in the photos of the Warren Street vicinity and on the Hopkins Property Map of that area, of which both can be viewed in the Terminals, Facilities & Yards chapter.
Palmer Relinquishment / Havemeyer Takeover
Information that is continuing to be collated by Tom Hendrickson, is showing there was "parting of the ways" between the Havemeyer's and Palmer in the years after 1900. The exact causes are unknown to us this time, but it appears that Lowell Palmer became disenchanted with the operations in Williamsburg, and left the organization around 1905 to devote his time to Squibb pharmaceuticals and his other business interests.
It has been put forth by Tom, that Palmer wished to distance himself from the Havemeyer's, due to their growing scandals and less than ethical business practices. Whether there is any truth or basis to this theory, remains to be confirmed.
We know clearly enough through historical
documentation, that the Havemeyer's eventually incorporated the navigation
portion of Palmer's Dock operations into the Brooklyn Eastern District
Terminal in 1906 and the railroad portion into the East River Terminal Railroad
Palmer's Dock - Equipment
Returning to the railroading history of
the Palmer's Dock; throughout it's existence; Palmer owned a total of eight
0-4-0T and 0-6-0T steam locomotives.
|Frederick C. Havemeyer...|
The first locomotive was named Frederick C. Havemeyer, rather than numbered. The remaining locomotives bore both numbers and the names of Lowell Palmer's children and of Palmer's birthplace: Chester, Ohio. These locomotives were built by Baldwin Locomotive Works and were originally built as "Steam Dummies" (steam locomotive with a dummy or false street car body over engine).
The purpose of this was to avoid the frightening of horses in the streets, which from other accounts the horses were startled by the steam "whooshing' and reciprocating machinery. Apparently the horses had grown accustomed to and were comfortable (for the most part) around streetcars & trolleys, and therefore steam locomotives were disguised to resembled street cars. Here is what the steam dummies of the period looked like:
ERT "Chester" / #7
with Street Car shell a/k/a "Steam Dummy"
Baldwin Locomotive records, researched and furnished by Tim Moore; show that these eight locomotives were ordered and built for both Lowell M. Palmer (of Palmer's Dock), and Havemeyer & Elder.
For the most part, these locomotives were small and "only" weighed in around 34-59 tons. At the time, they were sufficient for the movement of the short (35' foot or so), wood freight cars of the period. As the internal combustion engine gained usage and trucks replaced horses, the need for the dummy shell was eliminated. Palmer's Dock removed the shells, and modified the better of the locomotives for longer endurance and efficiency, and eventually converting a few of them to oil fired and larger water tanks.
When Palmer's Dock was re-incorporated as the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal (as a navigation company) in 1906 and East River Terminal Railroad in 1907 (the Bromley map of 1907/1908 still shows the property listed as Palmer's Dock); most of the equipment, including the steam locomotives, tugboats, carfloats, and the properties were "inherited" by the ERT/BEDT. Locomotives 6, 7 and 9 would go on to operate into the 1930's for the BEDT. Number 8 would be scrapped first, followed later by the others.
The following article was discovered within the Official Proceedings of September 1900 for the monthly meeting of the Western Railway Club. In this discussion, it specifies the design of the trackage, how the locomotive is used at the Palmer's Dock:
Official Proceedings of the Western Railway Club -
added 22 October 2010
So far, not much has been located denoting the trackage capacities of Palmer's Dock. However, according to the "Report of the Committee on Terminals and Transportation of the New York State Food Investigating Commission" published 1913; the car capacity of Palmer's Dock in 1903 was:
|delivery trackage:||304 cars|
|storage trackage:||290 cars|
|freight house capacity: ..||47,733 square feet *|
* = "Capacity given is that of the loading and unloading platforms, terminal is not equipped with freighthouse."
Palmer's Dock - Lessees & Interchange Partners
Railroad cars would arrive at the various yards of the mainland railroads (as mentioned above). These cars would be sorted according to destination in classification yards for transfer or interchange to other railroads. For cars destined to businesses served by Palmer's Dock; Palmer's Dock would dispatch tugboats with carfloats to those mainland terminals, which would arrive and moor. The mainland railroad would load the railroad cars onto that carfloat and Palmer's Dock would "pick up" those carfloats. More often than not, the carfloats would be loaded quickly, and tugboat would just wait until loaded and set sail. In reciprocation, railcars belonging to those mainland railroads would be returned at same time.
After 1875 when Palmer was no longer exclusively dealing with the Erie and throughout the ensuing years, other railroads and steamship lines leased space in the Palmer's Dock facilities or used Palmer's Dock to handle and store their freight. Combining the names listed from the Brooklyn Eagle news release in 1890 and from an advertisement in the journal "Railroad Men" from February 1903, Vol...... XVI, No. V; Palmer had the eventual presence of the following railroads and steamship lines in Williamsburg:
|Baltimore & Ohio||Citizens Line for Troy|
|Canada Southern||Murray's Barge Line for Albany & Troy|
|Central Railroad of New Jersey||People's Line for Albany|
|Central Vermont||Old Dominion Steamship|
|Chesapeake & Ohio|
|Delaware & Hudson Canal Railroad|
|Elmira, Cortlandt & Northern|
|New York Central & Hudson River||.....|
|New York, Lake Erie & Western|
|New York, Ontario & Western|
|New York, West Shore & Buffalo|
|Philadelphia & Reading|
|Rome, Watertown & Ogdensburg|
The Pennsylvania would eventually open their own freight station / terminal at North 4th Street, and the New York, New Haven & Hartford would open a freight station / terminal at North 1st Street. But the other railroads would go on to continue to use Palmer's Dock and subsequently the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal for transporting their freight into Brooklyn.
The history of Palmer's Dock, as well as the East River Terminal Railroad and subsequently the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal, also starts with the Havemeyer family; brothers William & Frederick; Frederick's sons: Henry Osborne and Theodore; and Theodore's' son Henry Osborne. (This is not a mistake, Theo named his son after his brother.)
The Havemeyer's would make their fortune in the sugar business. They owned several sugar refineries in the NY area, and would consolidate their interests on the shores of Williamsburg. Not only would the Havemeyer's find financial success, they would also come to be most influential in local politics as well, even in the face of tribulation and scandal.
Havemeyer Family Tree:
< brothers >
Jr.(NY, 1807 -
& Sarah Osborne née Townsend
Augustus (NY, 1839 - 1897)
children to include:)
Henry Osborne, Jr. (?, 1903 - ?)
Timeline - The Havemeyer
Wm. & F. C. Havemeyer Sugar;
Havemeyer, Townsend & Co.;
Havemeyer & Elder;
American Sugar Refining Co;
How sweet it was!
|1799:||William Frederick Havemeyer Sr. accepts invitation to relocate to NY to work in Mr. Seamen's sugar refinery on Pine Street in Manhattan, New York.|
|1802:||Frederick Christian Havemeyer, Sr. emigrates from England after completing his apprenticeship and joins William.|
|1805:||Frederick C. Sr. and his brother William F. Sr. lease land and open the Wm. and F. C. Havemeyer Sugar Refinery at 87 Van Dam Street (formally Budd Street) in Manhattan. This is partially in response to the growing demand for sugar, and as other prominent names of New York history had entered sugar business, including the Livingston's, Bayard's, Cuyler's, Roosevelt's, Stewart's, and Van Cortlandt's.|
|1807:||Frederick C. Sr. & William F. Sr. become American citizens.|
|1828:||William Sr. and Frederick Sr. sell their company to their respective sons William F. Jr. and Frederick C. Jr.|
|1839:||Theodore A. is born to Frederick Jr.|
|1841:||Frederick C. Sr. passes away. Frederick C. Jr.
turns over control of Sugar Company to other members of the Havemeyer
William F. Jr. leaves the sugar business to enter politics.
|1845:||William F. Havemeyer Jr. is elected mayor of New York City.|
|1847:||Henry Osborne (the uncle) was born.|
|1855:||Frederick C. Havemeyer, Jr. reenters the sugar business and relocates the Havemeyer sugar company from 87 Van Dam Street in Manhattan, to the waterfront on South 3rd Street, in the Williamsburg section of Brooklyn, where undeveloped land, a deep-water harbor, and abundant cheap labor soon attracted other refineries.|
|1857:||The Havemeyer corporation name changes over the
years to reflect the various partnerships entered into, and the Havemeyer,
Townsend and Company was organized to include in-laws and other investors,
Daily refined sugar output capacity: 300,000 lbs.
|1863:||Havemeyer Townsend & Co. renamed Havemeyer & Elder.|
|1865:||As a result of the Civil War, the sugar industry in the Gulf states was destroyed, and sugar refining becomes concentrated in New York City, where the port had become the largest in the country, the transportation system was extensive, and banks were numerous.|
|1873:||Daily refined sugar output capacity: 1,000,000 + lbs.|
|1875:||The Havemeyer's consolidate their sugar business
with Palmer's Dock; which was named for Lowell Palmer.
Henry O. Havemeyer (the uncle) elected president of Long Island Rail Road.
|1876:||Theodore and his wife Emilie (who was daughter
of Austrian Consul General in NY) have a son, and name him Henry Osborne
as well, and would be nephew to the first Henry Osborne, and of
whom would take the helm of BEDT later in it's history.
Because of the intense competition of sugar refineries in the City, the City of New York tries to fix sugar prices.
|1882:||The Havemeyer and Elder Sugar Refinery catches fire on January 9th, and is partially gutted. Most of the damage is contained to the 10 story brick "sugarhouse" between South 3rd and South 4th Street. It would be rebuilt.|
|1883:||Henry (the uncle) divorces his wife Mary Louis
Elder, and marries her niece Louisine Elder. Henry O. and Louisine have distinct
parallel tastes for art that compliment each other, and Louisine is
very good friends with Mary Cassatt, a most famous and renowned
Meanwhile, Henry O. Havemeyer (the nephew) was being privately schooled, and moved seasonally with his family between the family's three homes in Manhattan, NY; Newport, RI; and Mahwah, NJ; except from 1884-86 when the Havemeyer's took up residence in Europe.
Daily refined sugar output capacity: 3,000,000 lbs.
|1887:||The City of New York's failure to fix sugar pricing leads Henry (the uncle) to form the Sugar Refineries Company (known as the Sugar Trust) to control the price of sugar and the labor pool. This trust consolidated most of the major refineries in Brooklyn.|
|1891:||Frederick passed away. Henry (the uncle) inherits
the sugar refining entities and expanded them with assistance from his brother,
Theodore. Henry holds position as chairman, Theodore holds position
This was accomplished when, after being ruled illegal by the New York State Supreme Court; the sugar trust is reorganized by the Havemeyer's, who re-incorporate as the American Sugar Refining Company in New Jersey and retain headquarters in NY on Wall Street.
Henry (the uncle) is the main driving force behind Havemeyer and Elder Co.; and becomes president of the American Sugar Refining Company.
|1896:||Henry (the nephew) enters Yale College, but does not return the following year after his father Theodore's death in 1897. Uncle Henry persuades his nephew Henry to stay in Brooklyn and learn the sugar business. Henry (the nephew), receives his education by working on the Brooklyn Docks, by starting as a sugar sampler, and within two years he advances to the position of Assistant Superintendent.|
|1899:||Henry (the nephew) returned to Yale, received his degree and graduated in June 1900.|
|1900:||Henry (the nephew) marries Charlotte Whiting of Newport, RI; in July and the newlyweds go on a grand tour of Europe for their honeymoon. Upon his return to New York, Henry (the nephew) enters the main Wall Street office of American Sugar Refining Co. (the parent company of Havemeyer & Elder) to learn the accounting and financial aspects of the family business.|
|Havemeyer & Elder eliminates the little remaining competition in the region, by consolidating the surviving refineries in NY City into the National Sugar Refining Company of New Jersey. The American Sugar Refining Company was the most important firm of the Sugar Trust, and the loose network of companies controlled by the Havemeyer's dominates the market.|
|1903:||Henry (the nephew) and his wife Charlotte are parents to Henry Osborne, (Junior).; who would also become involved in railroading operations in Brooklyn.|
|1906:||Henry (the nephew) leaves his position with American Sugar and becomes president of the newly organized Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal, a navigation company, that is a subsidiary of the Havemeyer & Elder firm and handles the transportation of sugar in and out of New York.|
|1907:||Henry O. Havemeyer (the uncle) founder of
Havemeyer & Elder dies of a ruptured pancreas, also presumably of
stress as a result of the criminal charges entered against him as a result
of an "under-weighing" scandal the Havemeyer & Elder / American
Sugar Company was embroiled in.
American Sugar, directly and indirectly accounted for 98 percent of the national production of sugar by 1907. From that year, the American Sugar Company engaged in a protracted legal battle with the federal government over its control of the trust, during which its share of the cane market fell from 53 percent to 32 percent.
Until this time however; the Havemeyer & Elder company would come to control half the sugar refining capacity of the United States. Sugar refining was the New York City's most profitable manufacturing industry from 1870 until the First World War; and 59 percent of the country's imported raw sugar was processed here in 1872 and 68 percent by 1887.)
This legal struggle would not end until 1922, with a settlement that allowed the firm to remain intact but would force it to refrain from unfair business practices. As a result, competition revives and the Havemeyer & Elder firm ceases to dominate the sugar industry. After the Depression the sugar refining industry declined in the city as alternatives to sugar and modern technology were introduced. (Details about this scandal can be read below in the excerpt from T. Roosevelt's auto-biography).
Henry (the nephew) would pick up the pieces and with his new company, the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal; will become a fundamental part of railroad freight movement in the New York Harbor.
The East River Terminal Railroad is incorporated this year, as a steam railroad company. This railroad handles the railroad traffic from the carfloats of the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal Navigation Company.
|1915||The East River Terminal Railroad and Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal (a navigation corp.) are merged and re-incorporated as the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal, (a freight terminal corp.)|
|1917||The refined sugar warehouse and packaging warehouse are seriously damaged by fire.|
|1924||American Sugar Refinery in Jersey City (Warren Street) totally destroyed in fire.|
|1927||Entire Kent Avenue site undergoes major renovation, which include the boilerhouse and raw sugar warehouse (both structures of which remain today).|
Henry Osborne Havemeyer (the uncle)
Next to Lowell Palmer, Henry Osborne Havemeyer would have to be the most influential person in the history of the Palmer's Dock, East River Terminal, and by his legacy; the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal.
Henry would also serve as president of the Long Island Rail Road, and was elected to that position on April 13, 1875 and held that position for one term. Other than art, as mentioned above, the other business interests of Henry Havemeyer would include sugar trusts, mining, insurance and banking.
The Sugar Trusts, as they was popularly called, was the result of the Havemeyer's buying up the independent sugar refineries in the New York City area and consolidating them. This gave the Havemeyer's a great deal of power in the sugar industry. As we all know, this type of business power often leads to legal skirmishes. Some of these were the result of competitor's jealousies, and some were the result of genuine violations of law.
Henry's business practices, upon review of historical documents; were tenacious. Some of these tactics are questionable under todays ethics, and in some cases were punishable by law. But as we all can recognize, the Havemeyer's were not doing anything that was not being done by other influential business men of the era, such as the Vanderbilt's, Morgan's, Gould's, etc. If there was a dollar to be made, he found or deduced a way to make it.
As one can expect; the Havemeyer's and
their associates would prosper.
|| The New York residence of Henry O.
Havemeyer was located
on the corner of Fifth Avenue and Sixty-sixth Street
and consisted of a modernized French Renaissance mansion.
The Havemeyer's also maintained homes in Newport, RI;
Mahwah, NJ; and Lake Wales, FL.
In 1883, Henry divorced his wife Mary Louis Elder, and would marry her niece Louisine Elder. Louisine was the daughter of George Elder and wife Mathilda Waldron. The Elder's were business partners with the Havemeyer's in the sugar industry.
Henry and Louisine had distinct parallel tastes for art that complimented each other, and Louisine was very good friends with Mary Cassatt, a most famous and renowned artist. Henry and Louisine would have three children: Adaline (b. 1884); Horace (b. 1886) and Electra (b. 1888). Electra would be the only offspring to follow in her parents art collecting habits and she would go on to create the Shelburne Museum. In 1929, a substantial portion of Henry's collection was bequeathed by Louisine to the Metropolitan Museum of Art, in New York; where it formed the foundation of the "European Impressionist" collection.
Horace would follow in his father's footsteps and eventually become partners with his father, uncle, cousin and a few other close business associates, in the formation of the East River Terminal and Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal.
Henry was a member of several prominent social clubs and societies, namely: the Sons of the American Revolution (peculiar, as the Havemeyer's were partially of British descent) and the St. Nicholas Society. Henry & Louisine collected art, mostly of European artists, such as Degas and Monet.
At some point in time, the City of Brooklyn named a thoroughfare in Williamsburg "Havemeyer Street", in recognition for the Havemeyer's. Havemeyer Street runs for approximately 15 blocks from Division Avenue to Union Avenue. Havemeyer Street runs parallel to the East River on a north by northeasterly course and it is six blocks southeast of Kent Avenue, where the East River Terminal operated.
When Henry Havemeyer passed away on December
4, 1907; the streets surrounding his home: Fifth Avenue, Madison Avenue and
the side street East Sixty Sixth Street were blocked with automobiles and
horse drawn carriages of the attendees. His funeral was widely attended by
many business leaders and notable Americans:
(Arbuckle Brothers, Jay Street Terminal; acting president of American Sugar)
(attorney & diplomat)
as well as deputations from:
The casket was borne by American Sugar Refining employees to a simple black hearse drawn by two horses. The funeral procession consisting of carriages of Havemeyer family proceeded to Greenwood Cemetery in Brooklyn; where Henry Havemeyer was interred in the family vault.
Havemeyer family vault
Green-Wood Cemetery, Brooklyn, NY - 26 January 2010
Henry Osborne Havemeyer, nephew
Henry's nephew, also named Henry Osborne Havemeyer, (to whom I formerly referred to as "the younger") would become instrumental in guiding the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal. Nephew Henry and his wife Charlotte, would have a son, whom would be named (you guessed it) Henry Osborne Havemeyer as well. He was the third male to carry the name Henry Osborne, but since this latest edition of the Henry Osborne heritage is actually the son of the nephew, I will refer to him as Henry Jr.
Henry Sr. and his wife Charlotte would
collect Americana, including paper currency, pamphlets, coverlets, manuscripts,
snuff boxes, portrait busts, cartoons, medals and prints. Henry donated to
the New York Historical Society, thousands of portraits of prominent
Americans. These items are still on
Henry Osborne Havemeyer, Jr.
Henry Osborne Havemeyer Jr., by the way, would also go work for the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal, and hold the position of assistant to the President.
Keeping true to the Havemeyer's family contributions to railroading (whether infamous or beneficial), Henry Jr's. claim to fame would be that he invented an apparatus for float bridge and carfloat track alignment and mating, and he applied for and received patent #1,591,086 for this device in 1926. Paul Strubeck located the following patent application in one of searches.
Basically, this device is similar in principle to a "guarded frog" on a turnout, but his design was not a "V" as used in a frog situation, but rather a simple guard on one side of the rail to prevent derailments when the wheel set of a freight car transgressed from the float bridge rail to the carfloat rail.
His patent application better explains
the device, so I highly recommend you view the patent drawing and application
|H. O. Havemeyer Jr., Patent Application; December 29, 1925|
I am also at this time, going to ask that any descendents of the Havemeyer family pllease take the time to contact me at email@example.com
Tribulations & Scandal
The Havemeyer's and their relatives (Townsend's, Elder's), through consolidation of their 15 sugar refineries and through their political connections, would eventually become known as the "Sugar Trust". They would become extremely successful in the business world of America.
The success of the Havemeyer's is not to say that the Havemeyer and Elder sugar interests were without tribulation or scandal. As mentioned above, there were many investigations and indictments throughout their early history. Speaking frankly, it appears that the Havemeyer's almost always seemed to be embroiled in some legal folderol.
These lawsuits varied greatly in topic, and most were filed in connection either with: receiving secret rebates from other railroads, fixing sugar prices (after the City of New York failed to), and in an under-weighing scandal. Located in Theodore Roosevelts' (yes, the 26th president of the United States) autobiography, this author uncovered the following:
It was on the advice of my secretary, William Loeb, Jr., afterward head of the New York Custom-House, that the action was taken which started the uncovering of the frauds perpetrated by the Sugar Trust and other companies in connection with the importing of sugar. Loeb had from time to time told me that he was sure that there was fraud in connection with the importations by the Sugar Trust through the New York Custom-House.
Finally, some time toward the end of 1904, he informed me that Richard Parr, a sampler at the New York Appraisers' Stores (whose duties took him almost continually on the docks in connection with the sampling of merchandise), had called on him, and had stated that in his belief the sugar companies were defrauding the Government in the matter of weights, and had stated that if he could be made an investigating officer of the Treasury Department, he was confident that he could show there was wrongdoing. Parr had been a former school fellow of Loeb in Albany, and Loeb believed him to be loyal, honest, and efficient.
He thereupon laid the matter before me, and advised the appointment of Parr as a special employee of the Treasury Department, for the specific purpose of investigating the alleged sugar frauds. I instructed the Treasury Department accordingly, and was informed that there was no vacancy in the force of special employees, but that Parr would be given the first place that opened up.
Early in the spring of 1905 Parr came to Loeb again, and said that he had received additional information about the sugar frauds, and was anxious to begin the investigation. Loeb again discussed the matter with me; and I notified the Treasury Department to appoint Parr immediately. On June 1, 1905, he received his appointment, and was assigned to the port of Boston for the purpose of gaining some experience as an investigating officer. During the month he was transferred to the Maine District, with headquarters at Portland, where he remained until March, 1907.
During his service in Maine he uncovered extensive wool smuggling frauds. At the conclusion of the wool case, he appealed to Loeb to have him transferred to New York, so that he might undertake the investigation of the sugar under-weighing frauds. I now called the attention of Secretary Cortelyou personally to the matter, so that he would be able to keep a check over any subordinates who might try to interfere with Parr, for the conspiracy was evidently widespread, the wealth of the offenders great, and the corruption in the service far-reachingwhile moreover as always happens with "respectable" offenders, there were many good men who sincerely disbelieved in the possibility of corruption on the part of men of such high financial standing.
Parr was assigned to New
York early in March, 1907, and at once began an active investigation of the
On one occasion there was an attempt made to shunt Parr off the investigation and substitute another agent of the Treasury, who was suspected of having some relations with the sugar companies under investigation; but Parr reported the facts to Loeb, I sent for Secretary Cortelyou, and Secretary Cortelyou promptly took charge of the matter himself, putting Parr back on the investigation.
During the investigation Parr was subjected to all sorts of harassments, including an attempt to bribe him by Spitzer, the dock superintendent of the Havemeyer & Elder Refinery, for which Spitzer was convicted and served a term in prison. Brzezinski, a special agent, who was assisting Parr, was convicted of perjury and also served a term in prison, he having changed his testimony, in the trial of Spitzer for the attempted bribery of Parr, from that which he gave before the Grand Jury. For his extraordinary services in connection with this investigation Parr was granted an award of $100,000 by the Treasury Department.
District-Attorney Stimson, of New York, assisted by Denison, Frankfurter, Wise, and other employees of the Department of Justice, took charge of the case, and carried on both civil and criminal proceedings. The trial in the action against the Sugar Trust, for the recovery of duties on the cargo of sugar, which was being sent over the scales at the time of the discovery of the steel spring by Parr, was begun in 1908; judgment was rendered against the defendants on March 5, 1909, the day after I left office.
Over four million dollars
were recovered and paid back into the United States Treasury by the sugar
companies which had perpetrated the various forms of fraud. These frauds
were unearthed by Parr, Loeb, Stimson, Frankfurter, and the other men mentioned
and their associates, and it was to them that the people owed the refunding
of the huge sum of money mentioned.
The evidence showed that the president of the company, Henry O. Havemeyer, virtually ran the entire company, and was responsible for all the details of the management. He died two weeks after the fraud was discovered, just as proceedings were being begun. Next to him in importance was the secretary and treasurer, Charles R. Heike, who was convicted. Various other officials and employees of the Trust, and various Government employees, were indicted, and most of them convicted. Ernest W. Gerbracht, the superintendent of one of the refineries, was convicted, but his sentence was commuted to a short jail imprisonment, because he became a Government witness and greatly assisted the Government in the suits.
Theodore Roosevelt (18581919). An
To read the complete details and decision of this lawsuit in it's entirety, please click on following link:
(please note: there is no link to return you to this website - use your back/previous arrow on your browser)
East River Terminal Railroad; 1907 - 1915
Upon my initial research for this website many years ago, the name "East River Terminal Railroad" appeared infrequently if hardly at all. The first and only reference to it that I had come across, was in the 1990 Semaphore newsletter by E. M. Koehler, where I learned of it. I would not hear the name again until Tom Hendrickson informed me he found reference to it, as I will explain below. At first perception, it seemed that East River Terminal Railroad was used interchangeably with Palmer's Dock; but as it turns out this is not the case.
The documentation located and submitted by Tom Hendrickson, clarifies the use of the name East River Terminal as its own entity.
Tom located several articles pertaining to the East River Terminal Railroad in the New York Times archives. The first of which relates to it's incorporation and is dated November 20, 1907, and in the principles you will notice that Lowell Palmer is not mentioned.
The name appeared once again upon Tom locating it on page 265 in New York Times Index of 1916, where he was also able to find the digital images seen here.
So, the navigation aspect of the business was incorporated as the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal Company (a navigation corporation) on June 22, 1906; while the East River Terminal Railroad was incorporated in the State of New York as a steam railroad company on November 19, 1907.
For a long time, I often wondered why the East River Terminal Railroad was incorporated at a much later date, and you will learn why later in this chapter.
This next article, states how the Pennsylvania Railroad opposed the expansion of the East River Terminal Railroad, which had now announced it's southward expansion below North 5th Street to North 4th and North 3rd Streets. This article can be seen here to the right.
Is it not ironic how the mighty Pennsylvania Railroad would oppose this two block expansion, of this "little" terminal railroad?
Well the mighty Pennsylvania thought that by the East River Terminal Railroad expanding to south of North 4th Street, it (the PRR) would be encircled by East River Terminal Railroad trackage thereby preventing it from expanding either its trackage or its freighthouse as well as restrict truck / trailer movements on it's property. Granted, some of these concerns held validity.
Evidently, history clearly shows that the Public Service Commission allowed this expansion, as this new trackage would be in place in 1915 for the opening of the Austin Nichols Building between North 3rd and North 4th Streets on Kent Avenue.
| Oddly, in an another New York Times
article, the Havemeyer & Elder principals: Henry O. (the nephew); Theodore
A.; Frederick C.; and Horace Havemeyer are apparently trying to publicize
the "disassociation" of the East River Terminal Railroad (owned by Havemeyer's
& Elder) from the American Sugar Refining Company (of which we already
are aware that the Havemeyer's are / were involved in).
Not only is Henry O. stressing that the East River Terminal Railroad has no connection to American Sugar Refining, but he is also stressing that the East River Terminal Railroad has no interests in the Havemeyer & Elder Sugar Refinery, which is stated here to have been sold to American Sugar.
Notice how Henry O. states that East River Terminal Railroad holds the franchise rights for the tracks in the streets, and handles the cars of the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal, a corporation, all of whose stock is owned by Havemeyer's & Elder.
The reasons for this public disassociation from American Sugar Refining are unclear, but the end result is transparent enough: to establish the East River Terminal Railroad and related railroad properties as a completely separate entity from the American Sugar Refining, which at this time is still embroiled in the under-weighing scandal, and sugar trust investigation.
This disassociation could also have been a tactic to separate the East River Terminal Railroad from the lawsuits that the United States Courts were pursuing against American Sugar for receiving secret railroad rebates from the New York Central & Hudson River Railroad, among other railroads as well.
As a result of this article seen to the right, we are now able to determine that the Havemeyer & Elder group incorporated the Palmer's Dock venture, which they had gained control of, into two separate entities and this took place not long after Lowell Palmer left the Palmer's Dock organization in 1905.
East River Terminal Railroad Property Photos - What It Looked Like!
While the average reader might not comprehend, any images of the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal prior to the late 1950's and likewise, its predecessors; are quite scarce. The reasons for this are unclear, as there appears to be sufficient images of other railroad facilities, equipment and installations of this era. So, it is with unbridled excitement, that I add the following images to this website for all to enjoy.
The top one was located by none other than our very own retired BEDT engineer, Joe Roborecky; who has been contributing more than his fair share of assistance in research. Ironically, he located it on a "Google Book" search, even though I had searched their archives many times before!
The image was taken circa March or April 1914 and actually comes from the April 6, 1914 issue of the weekly publication: "Greater New York - Bulletin of the Merchants Association of New York".
While this photo might not technically be an aerial photo, it is definitely not taken from ground level either. At first, both Joe and I thought the image was taken by hot air balloon. This hot air balloon method had been used to photograph the Bush Terminal railyard, and of which that image may be seen on that particular page.
We also believed we were looking at the North 5th and North 6th Street Yards, with the Austin Nichols building being the background. It was only upon reading the accompanying article that we discovered that the Austin Nichols building was still being planned, and not yet constructed. This threw off our pinpointing the location until we referenced the property maps in the Terminals, Facilities & Yards chapter of this website. It was then we realized that we were looking at the northern portion of the property, (North 7th through North 9th Streets) and not the southern portion (North 4th - North 6th Streets) as originally believed.
By referencing the 1907 / 1908 Bromley Property Map, Joe and I were able to hazard a guess from where this image may have been taken: the top of the grain elevators of the Brooklyn Elevator and Mill! As Palmer's Hay Storage building was only three stories tall (which is believed to have become the North 10th Street freighthouse), it would not have afforded the higher perspective of the wood trestle in the photo, which is at least two stories tall in itself. The only structure that would have been tall enough for one to "look across" at the roof of the Brooklyn Cooperage building (in the background) would be either a similarly tall building, a water tower, or a coal or grain elevator. Of these, we do know there was a grain elevator on North 9th Street and the bulkhead by referencing the 1907 / 1908 Bromley Map.
Anyhow, this fantastic picture shows a
great many interesting details which we may now revel in;
The image, which is looking south from North 9th Street and shows in the background, the multi-story Brooklyn Cooperage building and faintly, the Williamsburg Bridge;
Directly across from the Brooklyn Cooperage building, is the covered piershed of Palmer's Dock;
Several stick lighters about the Palmers Dock pier
The western portion of the North 7th and North 8th Street railyards, and;
A small steam locomotive (left side of the photo, about the horizontal centerline) can be seen in the image. It appears to this author, judging from the proportions of this locomotive; that it is one of the earlier 0-4-0T saddletankers (this locomotive looks remarkably similar to the Harlem Transfer #1 0-4-0T, also of Baldwin manufacture);
Two different types of lighters and a coal barge at the bulkhead of the North 7th Street yard;
In the foreground, is a wood trestle extending out and onto a covered piershed, of which this elevated trackage and trestle was previously undocumented and unknown to us (we now realize the Coal Depot was multistory and served by this very trestle).
If the viewer takes notice, there are no floatbridges visible in the image. This is because the North 9th Street float bridge is out of view below the photographer, which was located practically at the foot of the grain elevator, (from where it is believed this photo was taken from the roof of); and the North 5 and North 6th Street float bridges are out of view just behind the Brooklyn Cooperage building.
One must also keep in mind, according to the 1907 / 1908 Bromley Map, the two yards (North 4th through North 6th and North 7th through North 9th Streets were segregated and not connected, with the Brooklyn Cooperage building dividing the property and railyards. This is apparent in the photo below.
East River Terminal Railroad / Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal
ca. March - April 1914
A link to a subpage containing the complete article accompanying this image is below. It is a multi-page article on the Brooklyn Terminals and is an interesting read on its own accord. Of peculiar note in the article, is that the Terminal is referenced to as the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal, even though technically the East River Terminal Railroad exists, which was not yet merged with but leased to BEDT Navigation at this time. It also details the facilities of the Bush Terminal, New York Dock, Jay Street Terminal and the proposed South Brooklyn Terminal Railroad:
|"Greater New York - Bulletin of the Merchants Association of New York"|
Now every once in a while, Tom Flagg sends
something to whet my appetite. On May 6, 2009; Tom sent me this image. It
is from the book "Brooklyn: A National Center of Commerce and Industry"
published in 1914 by the "Committee on Industrial Advancement of the
Brooklyn League". Tom states the photos might well have been taken the year
before, or even earlier. But, as both this image and the one above are of
approximately the same year, 1914; they provides us with two different views
of the North 9th Street locale. In the image below, (which is facing east)
many interesting structures can be seen:
Multi-story wood construction "Brooklyn Elevator & Milling" feed elevators. Of which by the way are proudly advertising "BROOKLYN ED TERMINAL"! It is from the top of this structure that the photo above was taken.
Behind this feed elevator is the three story brick structure which at the time of this image, was utilized for hay market & storage. This structure would become the North 10th Street Freight House. This was the only structure in this part of the property which survived into the "modern era" of BEDT operations.
Moving right, we have BEDT Carfloat #14 moored to the North 9th Street float bridge and North 9th Street Yard. One must keep in mind, at the time this image was taken, BEDT was the navigation company handling marine transportation, and the East River Terminal Railroad would be the railroad aspect of operations.
Between the float bridge and ramp for the coal trestle, is a two story structure. It was undetermined what purpose this structure served until Tom furnished a copy of the 1905 Sanborn Fire Map. It turns out this structure was one of TWO engine houses(!) that were operated simultaneously. (This one by North 9th Street and the other by North 5th Street.)
To the right of the of this structure, is the brick North 9th Street freight house running up the north side of North 9th Street.
Looking down the coal trestle ramp, we look directly down (east) on North 9th Street.
Slightly to the right we are looking up the trestle ramp, through the "covered bridge" / shed, of which its purpose is unknown. It is possible this was a location for dumping coal in scows underneath the covered trestle.
Following those tracks through the "covered bridge" leads us to Palmer's Coal Pockets in the background.
Under the inclined coal ramp fan (where the tracks spread out before entering the coal shed) an enclosed shed occupied the space.
The white fence is a stock yard, and there was a cattle shed here as well.
To the right of this and ground level is the North
8th Street Yard.
It is highly suggested that viewers reference the 1905 Sanborn Fire Map, for in depth details to the structures in this area.
In case this might be a little confusing, please
click on the image below for an annotated copy of the image.
Use your back arrow to bring you back here!
East River Terminal Railroad / Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal
courtesy of Thomas Flagg
added 06 May 2009
Other than the building on the bulkhead, (which I learned from the Sanborn Fire Map was one of two enginehouses); the purpose of that white fence eluded us as well. As it appears the North 8th Street Yard was not fenced off, why would this section be? This question remained unanswered, until I reviewed a 1905 Property Map, where it was noted it was in fact a cattle yard. Apparently, this was a facility for the holding of livestock until they were "needed" (read: slaughtered) by the many meat packers on the side streets east of the terminal.
While the exact date that the photo was taken is not known; judging from the lack of bustle, I would hazard a guess it was taken early to mid morning on a Sunday.
Another interesting fact that arose during research, is the New York Times archives shows that on November 25, 1912, an explosion and subsequent fire destroyed the plant of the Union Sulphur Company located on North 10th Street (between North 10th and North 11th Streets).
Thirty-four persons were injured with and undetermined number perished. Flying embers set fire to the hay market on the opposite side (south side) of North 10th Street. In a statement issued to the New York Times by H. O. Havemeyer, $245,000 worth of damage was done to the Union Sulphur Works, which was insured for $375,000, as well as undisclosed amounts of damage upon the hay market. The upper two floors of the grain elevator were also heavily damaged.
Therefore, there are now two possibilities
pertaining to the Brooklyn Elevator & Mill structure seen in the
This image was taken prior to the fire and subsequent damage, or
These structures were rebuilt.
By referencing the 1924 Fairchild Aerial Photo and the 1929 Belcher Hyde property maps, we can now also see that the BEDT property was totally redeveloped between the date of this photo and the mid 1920's; as no trestle or the covered piershed can be seen anywhere on BEDT property at these dates, and the Brooklyn Cooperage building is no longer shown on maps.
It may be of unique interest to compare even later images, maps and landmarks with this photo. The circular fenced portion of the property just to the other side of the wood trestle, would become the approximate location of the enginehouse we are now so familiar with. Also the point of which the elevated track upon the wood trestle crosses over the track on the ground (running parallel to the bulkhead) is the approximate location of the "diamond" crossover (behind the enginehouse) leading to the North 9th Street yard trackage in the more modern (post 1924) and recognized track layout.
A 780 Foot Railroad?
The following document was located by Paul Strubeck. It is a report from the Senate of the State of New York, Report of the Public Service Commission, First District and dated 1915 (even though it was released in 1917). At first I was excited by the data, then very confused.
Documents of the Senate of the State of New York,
Report of the Public Service Commission - 1915
If you have not already noticed, there
is some very curious and contradictory details in this document. It states:
(with my comments in parenthesis):
Miles of Track: 0.1475? (That translates into only 778.8 feet!)
Tracks: 60 feet in length? (Seeing as how the blocks from Kent to Wythe Avenue is 400 feet long, how can that be? Sixty feet wouldn't hold two 35' boxcars... But this report clearly states that 7 tracks cross Kent Avenue and four tracks cross Wythe Avenue, but lists them only as 60 feet in length.)
Only one locomotive? (We know from builder records several locomotives were
purchased in the years before this document.)
I commenced in writing a long and lengthy "rebuttal" chapter to this data, after consulting the 1907 / 1908 Bromley and 1929 E. Belcher Hyde maps, which clearly show trackage on North 4th Street much longer than the "60 feet" stated in the report. In the end, I deleted the paragraph until I could decide on how to best confirm or disprove this data. Well, that occurred about two hours later when reviewing the following document, which was also located and sent to me by Paul Strubeck.
This document is a request for Permission to Issue Stock and Acquire and Hold the Stock of the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal (a navigation corporation) and the East River Terminal Railroad (a steam railroad company). It is also a request for permission to exercise its franchise on those two companies. It short, it pertains to the merger of the East River Terminal Railroad (a railroad company) and the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal (a navigation company) into the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal (as a freight terminal company).
|Application for Permission to Issue Stock|
But, upon cautious reading of this document, we can finally learn WHY the East River Terminal Railroad was created and why its trackage was understated.
A Sham Railroad?
Apparently, the Havemeyer's applied for an expansion of their terminal station to North 4th Street (to build and service the upcoming Austin Nichols building), and such expansion required tracks to cross city streets. This required a certificate of convenience from the Public Service Commission and a franchise from the Board of Estimate. When they filed for the franchise, they were informed that such a franchise to operate railroad tracks in city streets could not be granted to a navigation company, but a railroad company would be allowed to do so and hence forth the application was denied.
Upon further review of that application, it was determined that the firm who installed the railroad crossings already in place at North 5th Street and Kent Avenue (that firm being Palmer's Dock) did not have such right to do so because the franchise to cross streets by rail was not clear in it's statement of incorporation. The right to cross the streets had been granted by the Aldermen of Williamsburg, and apparently never formalized through city legislature.
The Havemeyer's was advised to file a new franchise application to the Board of Estimate to clarify that usage. If approved, then the Havemeyer's / East River Terminal were advised to refile for the certificate of convenience. Well, that franchise application was denied, because the certificate of incorporation previously filed in 1907 by the East River Terminal was not amended to reflect the railroads intent to expand it's trackage north of North 4th Street (where BEDT Navigation was already operating).
It was also claimed that such an amendment cannot be issued because of a limitation on a railroads width is not to exceed six rods (a rod being 16.5 feet) or a total of 99 feet. The layout of the operations as per the intent of expansion, was 7 blocks wide (North 3rd to North 10th Streets), and is in automatic violation of the statute. (It is not stated, and if I understand correctly; this rule applies to main lines and trunk lines and is not applicable to Freight Terminals, of which you should remember that neither the ERT or BEDT was incorporated as such as of this date).
So, the East River Terminal Railroad was organized and with it apparently the Havemeyer's incorporated a company comprised of a 700 foot long railroad with only a few short sidings located along North 4th Street, listed to keep in under the "6 rod" rule (section 8 subparagraph 3 of New York State Railroad Law). Furthermore, a locomotive was leased from BEDT navigation. The result? An instant railroad and the right to lawfully cross city streets, even though the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal (incorporated as a navigation company) was the company operating a railroad and executing most of the train movements across the streets.
And don't think for one minute the Public Service Commission did not know what was going on here either, as I think the highlighted text says it best:
excerpt from the Application to Acquire, Merge and Issue Stock -
Reports of the New York State Public Service Commission - First District - 1917
"A sham railroad!" You have to admire the bluntness (and humor) of that statement in such a formal and legal state agency document!
Seriously though, as I had stated at the beginning of this chapter, I had wondered why the East River Terminal Railroad was incorporated at a later date than that of the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal (navigation company). Fortunately, it is stated in this application and the facts are now known. Ironically, at the end of all this legal maneuvering and reviewing in 1915, the Public Service Commission granted the application to consolidate all the Havemeyer operations under one name and reissue stock, and the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal as we know it was born and now incorporated as a Freight Terminal Station, so their tracks and trains could now legally cross city thoroughfares.
In documents pertaining to the corporate history of the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal as furnished to me by Tom Flagg, which in turn had been supplied to him in an interview with Marion McClelland in December 20, 1976; it is stated that in a contract with the City of New York dated December 27, 1909, the City granted the rights to the East River Terminal Railroad to construct and maintain trackage in North 5th Street, North 6th Street, North 7th Street North 8th Street, North 9th Street as well as Kent and Wythe Avenues. This significantly "expands" the actual trackage in use by the East River Terminal.
There is also an interesting coincidence of dates that was brought to my attention by Tom Hendrickson. The Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal was re-incorporated as a freight terminal company on November 4, 1915. Lowell M. Palmer passed away just five weeks prior on September 30, 1915. It is Tom's contention that the Havemeyer's incorporated this new entity to secure full ownership over the properties.
The article seen at right, is the public announcement that the Public Service Commission granted the application for permission of the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal (as a freight terminal company) to issue and hold stock of the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal, a navigation company, and the East River Terminal Railroad. This application has the effect of consolidating those two entities (as described in the application in link above).
As a result of this new information, it is believed and hypothesized that the Havemeyer's initially incorporated BEDT Navigation and ERT Railroad as two separate entities to protect and isolate either company from the other as a result of lawsuits, claims or negative attention from the Sugar Trust scandals among other things. Upon the death of Lowell Palmer and the settlement of the sugar trust problems; perhaps the Havemeyer's decided that those threats were no longer a factor and could consolidate the two entities.
Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal; 1906 - 1983
Overview: Whats In A Name?
The name Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal as we know it, had its true beginnings in 1906 as a Navigation Company, and in the very beginning was incorporated as such under the Transportations Corporations Law of the State of New York on June 20, 1906.
It was not until the November 5, 1915, after all the franchises and certificates of conveniences were finally approved; that all the properties, railroad, marine equipment and other assets were formally consolidated and incorporated under the name by which we know it and as a Freight Terminal operation; with a railroad, tugboats and carfloats. As previously discussed in the chapters above, the name by which we know had its beginnings in 1906 and until 1915, and between those dates; generally referred to the navigation corporation operated by the Havemeyer's, even though it was operating a railroad along Kent Avenue.
Paul Strubeck located some information in the following documents. The following is a summary and pier dimensions as listed in "Ports of the United States, 1916", and it makes a good overview.
"The Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal was probably the first private terminal for public use in the Port of New York. According to well authenticated report, this terminal had it's beginning in 1876.
This organization has three terminals. The main terminal is located on the East River in Brooklyn and includes frontage between North Third and North Tenth Streets. Of the branch terminals on is on the Tidewater Basin in Jersey City and the other known as the Queensboro Terminal, on the East River, between Thirteenth and Fourteenth Streets in Long Island City.
The main terminal of the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal is adjacent to the large refineries of the American Sugar Refining Co. and to other important manufacturing concerns and occupies an area of about 740,000 square feet. This terminal has one large covered pier for steamship freight and six open piers, in addition to four car-float bridges.
The yard capacity of the main terminal is 1,500 cars and the equipment includes 10 locomotives, 13 car floats, 12 lighters, and 5 tugs. An interesting feature is the operation of the car floats on a regular schedule.
The main terminal has a hay-storage warehouse with a floor area of 37,250 square feet and two warehouses for the storage of flour and package freight, one being 450 feel long, 75 feet wide, and three stories high, while the other is 120 feet long, 75 feet wide, and four stories high. This terminal is equipped with coal pockets of 35,000 tons capacity and with three cranes, two of 10 tons and one of 20 tons capacity, for handling heavy freight.
The Queensboro Terminal occupies a river frontage of 419 feet and has a long wharf and wharf shed. This terminal has only recently been established.
The Jersey City Terminal of this company is located at the foot of Warren Street on the Tidewater Basin of the Morris & essex Canal. This terminal has direct connection with the various railroads having terminals on the New Jersey shore of the New York Harbor, and has a freight yard with a capacity of 100 cars, car-float bridges, and warehouses for the storage of freight."
Ports of the Unites States, 1916
Department of Commerce - Bureau of Foreign & Domestic Commerce
Miscellaneous Series - No. 33
Report on Terminal Facilities, Commerce, Port Charges,
and Administration as Sixty-Eight Selected Ports
by Grosvenor M. Jones.
Details as to the dimensions and occupants of the piers of the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal that appear in this book at this point are listed in the Terminals, Facilities & Yards chapter of this website.
Non Erie Beginnings a/k/a True Independent
To this day, many BEDT fans unfortunately still go by the misinformation that the BEDT was originated by, and / or was; an Erie Railroad operation. On Bill Russell's "Pennybridge" website (which is no longer on world wide web), it had been stated that:
"the BEDT was organized by the Erie Railroad".
In Jay Bendersky's book, "Brooklyn's Waterfront Railways" it states,
"In 1906 the railroad, with the leadership of mighty
Erie, would be reorganized into that railroad with the unusual name:
the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal".
Bendersky goes on to infer a BEDT association with the Erie simply by judging from the design of the early BEDT herald / logo style below (diamond with side bars);
"The herald of the BEDT obviously came from its mentor, the Erie".
(It is now understood by this author that the Pennybridge website used the information (albeit erroneous) stated in the Bendersky publication.)
In any case, this "Erie involvement" or "Erie origins" information is, by all historical accountings uncovered and known to date, is simply not true. The similarities between the heralds is perhaps an honor to their (Lowell Palmer & Erie Railroad's) first business dealings, or is simply a coincidence. (Bush Terminal's 80 ton GE locomotives bore a three stripe paint scheme bearing a striking resemblance to the "Five Stripe" scheme as seen on the GG1 electric locomotives of the Pennsylvania Railroad. Should we now infer Bush Terminal to be of Pennsylvania heritage based on this similarity?)
Anyhow, this Erie origin misinformation
is perhaps the most prevalent error in the previously published history of
the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal. Therefore, I am going to disprove
this "Erie ownership / operation" with several points of easy reference through
the following documents and historical facts. My comments appear below each
point in italics.
Congressional Sugar Trust court proceedings and Palmer's own testimony; 1911
Ambrose Armbruster's Williamsburg Brooklyn historical accountings; 1912
Corporate history of the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal furnished (by the BEDT in 1976) to Tom Flagg; dated 1919
Brooklyn Daily Eagle Business Review article of November 4, 1925
While Lowell Palmer established a terminal for and subsequently leased a building to the Erie Railroad in 1874; the property, railyards and operation were under the sole control of Lowell Palmer until 1875. It was at this time Lowell Palmer formed a partnership with the Havemeyer's. Also in 1875 other railroads came to lease property from Palmer as well as discussed in the chapter on the history Palmer's Dock.
1) Lowell Palmer's Testimony in the Congressional Hearings of the Sugar Trusts - 1911
Perhaps the most important supporting evidence to refute this misinformation, would come directly from Lowell Palmer himself. At the Congressional "Sugar Trust" hearings in 1911; Lowell Palmer testified to the following:
"When I commenced, Havemeyer's station was at St. John's Park, N.Y., so they had to cart and have ferriage on every pound of sugar shipped by rail; and that seemed to be an unfair arrangement and I brought in the Erie in 1874; I brought in the New York Central, I guess, in 1875; then the Central brought the West Shore, and that year they brought in the D. L. & W. and the Pennsylvania, and the Pennsylvania came and bought a block of ground adjoining that property."
Quite simply; there you have it. Palmer "brought in" the Erie in 1874 and other railroads in 1875. The Erie did not bring him (or the Havemeyer's for that matter) into an agreement, arrangement or terminal. Palmer's Dock had already been established in 1870 when he brought in the other railroads, five years later.
2) "The Eastern District of Brooklyn", by Ambrose Armbruster - 1912, 1941
As discussed previously in the Palmer Dock history chapter, according to the publication "The Eastern District of Brooklyn" by Ambrose Armbruster; Lowell Palmer would establish a terminus on his property, for the Erie Railroad in Williamsburg in 1874.
Palmer's Dock would have exclusive business dealings with Erie Railroad 1874 through 1875, when Palmer become host to many other railroads. Palmer would sell the North 5th Street freighthouse outright to Erie and this structure is shown below in the 1907 Bromley map still marked for Erie, but was now only accessible by the West Shore Railroad yard at North 5th and North 6th Streets and not by Palmer's Dock tracks north of North 7th Street. In the Belcher Hyde maps of 1929, this same structure is now marked as part of the BEDT.
Furthermore, upon referring the 1907 Bromley map, one will see no less than four trunk line / class 1 railroads now on Kent Avenue around the time of formation of BEDT: Pennsylvania, West Shore, Erie and Central Railroad of New Jersey. Pennsylvania and West Shore would have trackage and yards on Kent Avenue pre-dating BEDT, and the Erie and CRRNJ would have freight depots only.
If the BEDT was truly Erie property or an Erie owned operation, why would they (the Erie RR) allow competing railroads to lease property on their site?
3) Corporate Documents of the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal
Tom Flagg was furnished with several documents in his December 1976 interview with BEDT President Marion M. McClelland, which subsequently have been furnished to this author. One of these documents, is the Corporate History of the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal, dated 1919. This document was prepared by the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal, in accordance with the requirements of Valuation Order #20, issued by the Interstate Commerce Commission on May 13, 1915.
Nowhere in the eight pages of this document, is it mentioned that the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal was organized by or owned in whole or in part by the Erie Railroad.
4) Brooklyn Daily Eagle newspaper article
The following is an excerpt of a lengthy feature article on the success of the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal. This article appeared in Business Review section of the November 4, 1925 issue of the Brooklyn Daily Eagle Newspaper. The article can be read in its entirety here: Success Story.
This article covers the rise of the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal through it's auspicious beginnings under Palmer's Dock:
Take exceptional note of the following two sentences:
"He suggested to the Erie Railroad that he build a tug and float to take care of his own lighterage allowance from the railroad."
"He acquired some real estate, built a float bridge and laid out storage tracks, which he threw open to the public."
Need I say more?
5) Miscellaneous Facts
1875: Other foretelling facts, if one checks their railroad history; Henry O. Havemeyer (the uncle) would serve as president of the Long Island Rail Road beginning in 1875 and hold that position for one year. The LIRR as we have seen; would go on to have an association with the Pennsylvania, and use PRR designed equipment. But again, this involvement apparently did not reflect on Palmer's Dock operations.
1899: There would also be an announcement in the Brooklyn Eagle of a joint Long Island Rail Road / Palmer's Dock development of a freight terminal at the Pidgeon Street property acquired that same year by Lowell Palmer. You can read the article in the Pidgeon Street chapter: Pidgeon Street.
1906: The Rebate Scandal and subsequent court trial involving the New York Central and American Sugar Refining (Havemeyer), shows where the American Sugar Refining Company received unfair rebates from the New York Central Railroad in transporting sugar.
If Palmers Dock or the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal was Erie owned or controlled, why would they enter into agreements with the LIRR (the competition) and why then was the sugar shipped by New York Central (another competitor to the Erie) and why would the Havemeyer's negotiate with the New York Central for illegal rebates when the Erie could have simply transported it for free or reduced cost?
1910's - 1929: At some point, the North 5th Street freighthouse that had been sold to the Erie Railroad, would be repurchased by the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal on an as yet unknown date (but presumably around 1907-1910). This as already mentioned, is reflected by the G. W. Bromley map of 1907 where the freighthouse is seen marked for Erie.
The E. Belcher Hyde maps of 1929 where
the freighthouse is now seen with the label of Brooklyn Eastern District
1950's: Another popular contention that the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal was directly involved with the Erie, would be that the BEDT leased a tugboat from the Erie while their tugs were under servicing.
But if one reflects upon history once again, documents show that the BEDT would contract with the Central Railroad of New Jersey for major locomotive repairs, as evidenced by the firebox explosion incurred by #14 in 1953.
Also the records and testimony in many court proceedings and lawsuits throughout the twentieth century; state that the East River Terminal Railroad, and likewise Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal was owned wholly by the Havemeyer & Elder Co. since 1906; and was formed as the result of the previous merger of Palmer's Dock and Havemeyer & Elder, and the subsequent success of that merger and business interests.
Prior to the formation of Conrail in 1976, Joe Roborecky recalls that one of the BEDT diesel locomotives was sent by carfloat to the Long Island Rail Road facility at Long Island City to have its wheel sets turned to return them to AAR contour specifications.
As history and research have revealed thus far, other than those very early pre-Havemeyer & Elder days and business transactions regarding freight movements; Palmer's Dock and its successors; the East River Terminal Railroad and the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal were not created, controlled, organized or administered to by the Erie Railroad.
In short, the Brooklyn Eastern District
Terminal, apparently (and obviously) remained truly independent
of trunk line / class 1 influences, even though it would rely on many of
those trunk line / class 1's for it's business and intermittent assistance
in heavy maintenance.
What It Did
The Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal, like the Palmer's Dock / East River Terminal Railroad it descended from; was carfloat operation and a terminal railroad with no direct physical connection (interchange) to any other railroad. Yet it was interestingly enough would become a two state shortline (New York & New Jersey), and at various points in its history, would be classified as either a Class 2 or Class 3 railroad by the Interstate Commerce Commission. It was also known as a "contract terminal".
A contract terminal, in a broad scope and layman's terms, is defined as a company that is contracted by larger railroads to perform the final delivery aspects of shipped freight. As such, since the large railroads (Erie, CRRNJ, NYC, etc.) did not have freight terminals in Brooklyn, they would contract with the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal (and likewise, Bush Terminal, New York Dock and Jay Street Terminal) to pick up freight from the trunk line / class 1 railroads facilities in New Jersey, and forward said freight to the respective consignees in Brooklyn.
On 13 March 2010, Joe Roborecky located the following advertisement in the May 20, 1911 edition of the Brooklyn Daily Eagle:
Brooklyn Daily Eagle - May 20, 1911
The BEDT would not be a common carrier for many years, at witnessed by the court document below, but it would achieve common carrier status by 1940. Prior to being named a "common carrier", the BEDT (and Bush Terminal and New York Dock with it) was classified a Contract Terminal. This meant that the company (BEDT in this case) was functioning as an agent of the trunk line / class 1 railroad that was shipping the item via BEDT carfloat.
I have located the following information, in of all places; an old lawsuit in which the BEDT was a respondent in a case for allowing an employee to remain on duty for more than 16 consecutive hours; (in violation of the Hours of Service Act). Conveniently, this lawsuit accurately describes the operations of the BEDT, and it's business arrangements with other railroads. Pertinent excerpts have been included here for informational purposes.
US v. Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal, 249
U.S. 296 (1919)
To read the complete details and decision of this lawsuit in it's entirety, please click on following link:
(please note: there is no link to return you to this website - use your back/previous arrow on your browser)
The Highway Connection (that never was)
On 14 January 2010 while during research for the New York Dock Railway regarding the construction dates for the Brooklyn Queens Expressway (or "BQE" as it is more commonly called among urban New Yorker's); it was learned that the City of New York originally intended to construct a "spur" of the BQE to the Williamsburg waterfront.
In 1940, it was proposed to construct the Brooklyn Queens Expressway and connect it to the already completed sections of the Gowanus Expressway (in the south) and the Meeker Avenue - Queens Boulevard section of the BQE (in the north). It is stated on Steve Anderson's website "NYC Roads" on the Brooklyn Queens Expressway page, that one of the proposals put forth by the New York City Planning Department for extending the BQE south of Meeker Avenue:
"The city plan included a "North 9th Street Connection,"
an elevated highway spur along North 9th Street that was to connect the mainline
highway with Wythe Avenue. It was to provide access to an industrial area
along the Williamsburg waterfront."
As I was on the telephone at that very minute with Joe Roborecky and read him that passage, his immediate comment reflected the conclusion I had already come to while reading:
"industrial area along the Williamsburg waterfront" = BROOKLYN EASTERN DISTRICT TERMINAL!
authors rendering of proposed Brooklyn Queens Expressway North 9th Street spur
added 14 January 2010
It does not even take a great leap of imagination for one to see this BQE spur even points like an arrow at the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal. Had this North 9th Street Spur of the BQE been constructed; the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal would have seen and enjoyed a dramatic increase in freight traffic.
There is no doubt that this elevated highway spur would have made it extremely convenient for tractor trailers to enter and exit the limited access highway system and connecting Brooklyn and Queens along with other major arterial highways and water crossings leading to the other boroughs. All this with minimal interference from vehicular traffic at cross and side streets, as well as pedestrian traffic. Therefore, this spur might have led to the possibility of a successful trailer on flat car (TOFC) operation at BEDT in later years, when that method of transporting trailers by train was perfected and gained popularity.
Logistically, North 9th Street, which is a one way street, would have had to have been widened to accommodate the two way elevated highway. This would not have been an overly difficult feat for the City of New York, as they widened other thoroughfares for identical purposes through condemnation proceedings. Therefore, North 9th Street would have most likely have become two way for the one block remainder of the distance from the end of the expressway spur at Wythe Avenue to Kent Avenue. More than likely than not; North 9th Street would have become two way the entire distance from Meeker Avenue to Wythe Avenue as well, and would have either run under or to the sides of the elevated highway.
Sadly, this Brooklyn Queens Expressway North 9th Street Spur would not become part of the finalized plan, and the current route of the expressway was what would be constructed and as it exists today.
Success of the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal
The success of the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal could be measured by many factors, not the least of which being haulage, gross revenue, expansion and appearance.
For example, in 1912, according to the "Report of the Committee on Terminals and Transportation of the New York State Food Investigating Commission" published 1913, the track capacity of the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal increased from 357 cars to 426 cars.
In 1914: it hauled over 150,990 tons of freight, for 1,200 shippers and 1,400 consigners and operated over 10.33 miles of track in New York & New Jersey. It operated 10 locomotives, 4 tugboats, 19 carfloats and employed 458 employees.
I have been fortunate to locate a Public Service Commission Summary of Annual Returns for First District Operating Steam Railroads for 1920. These reports compare and tabulate the economic figures for the different Freight Terminals & Steam Railroads that operated in Brooklyn & Queens: Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal, Jay Street Connecting, New York Dock, Degnon Terminal and New York Connecting. Oddly, Bush Terminal is not listed. You will note some interesting facts in these reports, such as the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal handling 59,022 cars, over 9.24 miles of a track (a decrease of .63 miles form the previous year) with a gross income of $853,507.01. There were 115 employee injuries and 1 employee fatality listed for the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal for that year.
|Public Service Commission - Summary of Annual Reports - 1920|
On 13 March 2010; Joe Roborecky located a rather interesting feature article concerning the success of the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal in an online archive. This article was originally published in the "Business Review "section of the November 4, 1925 issue of the Brooklyn Daily Eagle newspaper.
What I find most satisfying, is the content of the article bears out most of the conclusions I have reached through independent research some 85 years later! Unfortunately, the author of this feature article is not attributed so I cannot even belatedly thank this person for recording the statistics and great information:
November 4, 1925 - Brooklyn Daily Eagle
In 1954, as reported in the New York Times Article below; the Pennsylvania Railroad applied to the Interstate Commerce Commission to abandon their North 4th Street Freight Station. The Pennsylvania Railroad subsequently sold that property to the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal. I find it ironic how the Pennsylvania Railroad opposed the expansion of the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal back in 1909; and now some 45 years later, the BEDT was acquiring the property.
New York Times - May 8, 1954
The Coverdale & Colpitts Report of 1956 very nicely lists the trends in Revenue & Traffic on page 7. I have recreated a portion of that table here:
|1935 - 1939*||$1,381,000||
|1940 - 1944*||$2,175,000||
|1945 - 1947*||$2,238,000||
|1948 - 1950*||$2,571,000||
* = average for years shown
In 1959; according to the Railroad Magazine article by Melvin Krampf, the BEDT would switch 27,000 carloads, and exceeded a gross income of $2,500,000.
Considering the fact that this railroad would never have more than 11 miles of track, defines this organization as a resounding success. Their equipment was always in good repair and prior to 1935, all of the locomotives, tugboats or carfloats were purchased new.
Another measurement of it's success, would
be in its property expansions and acquisitions:
In 1906, the East River Terminal / Brooklyn Eastern
District Terminal would expand
and build a float bridge and terminal at Pidgeon Street, Long Island City.
In 1910, ERT/BEDT opens the Warren Street Terminal in Jersey City.
In 1914, ERT/BEDT opens the Queensboro / 13th Street facility between Astoria and Long Island City.
In 1915, the Austin Nichols Building (a Havemeyer owned property) opens.
In 1936, BEDT opens its Wallabout Market Terminal just north of the Brooklyn Navy Yard.
In 1940; BEDT assumes operations in the Brooklyn Navy Yard.
In 1954, BEDT acquires the PRR North 4th Street Terminal Property.
In 1964, BEDT opens its Bulk Flour Terminal on Kent Avenue.
Throughout the years, BEDT would expand it's way north of North 10th Street
in short increments,
to eventually reach North 12th Street.
You can read more about the histories of these expansions in the Terminals, Facilities & Yards chapter.
There is one other way to measure the success of the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal, if not in a subtle and roundabout method. That would be in its impact on people. In 1933; John J. Bennett, Attorney General of the State of New York; filed suit in the New York State Supreme Court that the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal did not uphold to it's agreement when it was issued a land use grant some 50 years prior, so the State of New York sought to "evict" the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal from it's Kent Avenue properties. The details can viewed in yet another of the New York Times articles discovered by Tom Hendrickson here:
|State Fails In Court To Seize Terminal - New York Times - May 10, 1933|
What perhaps is most amusing about the article is that Justice Lockwood (the judge presiding over this case), as a teenager, had worked at the lumber company at the East River Terminal! Fortunately, Justice Lockwood recognized (and experienced first hand!) the positive commercial & economic impact that the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal made in Williamsburg.
If the State had been successful in their lawsuit and objective; hundreds of employees would be jobless, the property would be vacant, property taxes no longer collectable, and the State would be stuck with a expanse of land, as even Attorney General Bennett (who was pushing the issue) said the property "would be a white elephant". Perhaps most importantly, if this lawsuit had been successful, my interest in the BEDT would not have occurred and this website would never exist... Oh the horror! :o)
Seriously though, while there were three other terminal railroads in Brooklyn (Bush Terminal, New York Dock and Jay Street Connecting); it is the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal that people seem to remember most. As Jay Wanczyk pointed out to me in general discussion:
"One of my continuing thoughts about BEDT from its earliest
Palmer days to the very end is that the company always seemed to conduct
its business in a first class business way, no slap-dash operation. The employees
seemed to be proud of "their" railroad and the company proud of it's image;
ads in the Official Guide were large and graphic; in the late 1950's paining
up its steam locomotives "almost too well" in their final years for all to
see, and later even spending the money and taking the time to erect a
professionally made large red and white flag sign on the flour terminal.
Reading those new Palmer articles shows that business leadership approach seemed to begin with him and of course the Havemeyer's as well. I think that approach is what set the BEDT apart and above the other small Brooklyn railroads. Of the rest, only Bush Terminal seemed to have had any wide vision, and that came a bit later and still was not as broad in it's approach. At the very end though, it appears that NY Dock had the management that prevailed."
If this astute business sense on the parts
of Palmer and Havemeyer can be recognized over a hundred some odd years after
their involvement, I cannot help but feel this is a testament to their vision
End Of Steam Operations Ceremony
Eventually, diesel-electric locomotives became the standard for all railroads. This was due to their ease of operation, efficiency, ease of maintenance and repair and common availability of parts. Upon the passage of the Kaufman Act in 1925, which in effect eliminated the use of steam locomotives within city limits; those railroads operating with the city confines had to turn to alternate methods of motive power. You can read more about the Kaufman Act on the main page of this website: Kaufman Act.
But as we have seen; BEDT would have nothing to do with diesels until the last possible moment. How the BEDT kept steam power until 1963 still remains to be learned, but it could very well have to be due to the fact that around the early to mid 1930's, the steam locomotives operating on the BEDT were converted from coal fired to oil fired, more specifically Bunker-C oil. As we can see from the many hundred of photos of the steam locomotives operating, they appear to be clean burning, so this may have helped BEDT circumvent the Kaufman Act; but this is unconfirmed.
Eventually, BEDT would have to end steam locomotive operations. This was attributed not to the Kaufman Act, but to the fact that parts for the steam locomotives were becoming scarce, exceedingly expensive to make or in some cases impossible to acquire. Also to be considered is that the boilers of the steam locomotives could only be certified for so much service before having to be rebuilt. As BEDT would have to shop out their heaviest rebuilds, but as the trunk line railroads gave up steam and re-equipped their shop for diesel, and they would not be equipped any longer for a steam locomotive rebuild, leaving BEDT with no one to turn to.
Regardless of the reason, the day that steam operations on the BEDT ended sadly came on October 25, 1963; when BEDT ceased all steam locomotive operations with #14 and #16 both being the last steam locomotives to operate on the BEDT as part of the "end of steam ceremony". Furthermore, the administration of the BEDT recognized this event for what it was, and made it a public event. The event would be well recorded by many railfans, and an article would be published in the New York Times. Due to the growing number of pictures I am receiving from this date, and a lengthy newspaper article received from Tom Hendrickson, inspired me to place these items on their dedicated page:
|BEDT End Of Steam - October 25, 1963|
As a happy footnote to this occasion: all of the H. K. Porter saddletankers would not be scrapped, as the railfan movement was in its heyday. Unfortunately, Baldwin build #10 and #11 were already gone. Several parties sought out and purchased the remaining saddletankers for preservation and use on tourist railroads.
That is all except #16, who would sit somewhat forgotten on Kent Avenue, as a lone testament to the steam operations of BEDT, until her rescue in the mid-1990's, and numbers 10 & 11 that were scrapped prior to cessation of steam operations.
The Diesels Take
The first diesel locomotive to arrive on Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal property was an S1 model built by the American Locomotive Company (ALCo), in Schenectady, NY. This locomotive was formerly employed at the Union Railroad of Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania as their #453, and it arrived at the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal Kent Avenue yard in the fall of 1962. Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal would assign this locomotive as number 21, skipping over unassigned numbers 17 through 20.
Three more ALCo S1's would follow over the few weeks or so, but from another railroad however. BEDT numbers 22, 23 and 24 would come from the New Orleans & Lower Coast Railroad as numbers 9013, 9014 and 9015, which was a subsidiary of the Missouri Pacific Railroad.
The final two locomotives would originally come from the Erie Lackawanna Railroad, numbered 307 and 313, and these would become BEDT #25 and 26 respectively. #25 would arrive in 1968 directly from Erie, and #26 would have a few more prior owners after Erie before winding up at the BEDT as late as 1973.
For detailed histories of the locomotives and their specifications, please visit: Equipment Rosters & Specifications.
There were two events associated with
the beginning of diesel operations for the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal,
and they are discussed in the next two chapters.
(one-man Steam Locomotive operation vs. two-man Diesel Locomotive operation)
The Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal found it necessary to employ "firemen" for diesel operations, whereas the steam locomotives were equipped for one man operation. Stated in Jay Bendersky's book "Brooklyn's Water Railways", that by the combination of the long hood and high control stand in the cab of the S1's, visibility was obscured for the engineer and so firemen were hired to assist. This is not the case as reported by Joseph Roborecky, BEDT engineer (1968-1983).
The reason for hiring the extra crewman, was that New York State had what is known as the "Full Crew Law" on the books regarding locomotive operations, and this law requires firemen to be present on locomotive operations. This law does predate BEDT diesel operations, but it was unknown why BEDT steam operations escaped the use of firemen.
In the April 1961 issue of Railroad Magazine, it is explained how BEDT operated with only one crewman (engineer) in their steam locomotives. It simply states:
"New York State's full crew law permits a road having
less than 25 miles of track
to operate oil burning steam locomotives with only one man in cab; a diesel must have two."
This does however does not explain the reasoning behind New York State allowing oil burning steam locomotives to operate with only one man. I also understand the law to exempt the use of firemen on diesel locomotives weighing less than 45 tons which is why I believe the New York Dock Railway to have utilized GE 44 ton Locomotives (which were ballasted to 50 ton). The Alco S1's employed by BEDT after steam operation weighed more than the 44 ton limit imposed by the regulation, therefore necessitating the hiring of locomotive firemen.
To date I have not been able to find a copy of the law anywhere as of yet to verify or explain this.
Brought to my attention by Joe Roborecky, was another side effect (unforeseen?) resulting from converting to the diesels, and that was the enginehouse had to be extended. The ALCo's were 16 feet longer than the 28 foot long Porters, and even after the diesels had been on BEDT property already one year, the enginehouse was still not extended, and the diesels being stored outside.
By 1967 however (the earliest picture I have, that shows the extension), the enginehouse was expanded to provide more track length inside, so the diesels could now take turns residing inside. This extension was of concrete block and approximately 15 - 20 feet in length, and about two to three feet higher than the brick structure. In the right picture below, you can see the concrete block extension interlaced with the original brick construction on the extreme left of the image.
Concrete block extension on east face
Causes for decline of Marine-Rail Traffic in New York City
Several events hastened the end of marine-rail traffic in the New York area, in addition to the general economic malaise that effected the United States and especially the New York Metropolitan area during the 1970's:
Robert Moses, who starting from the late 1940's;
campaigned and lobbied for (as well as built) more roads and large arterial
highways in and around New York City and Long Island.
The completion of the Verrazano Narrows Bridge, and
related highway connections in 1964.
The Brooklyn Navy Yard closed in 1966, and this probably
was the worse event to occur to BEDT, as Uncle Sam was a major source of
rail traffic and revenue, but the effects of this event would not
be immediately felt.
In 1976; Conrail was created by Congress to reorganize and consolidate the financially troubled Northeast Class 1 railroads (Penn Central, Erie Lackawanna, etc).
Robert Moses was vehemently anti-rapid transit and railroad, and yes; you can blame him and Mayor Fiorello LaGuardia directly for the decline and outright removal of New York City trolleys and streetcars (booo - hisss!) as well as New York's elevateds. Both Moses and LaGuardia had vested monetary interests in Standard Oil, General Motors and other automobile related securities.
Naturally, this proliferation of highways and expressways; while improving the access of truck transportation to the rural and suburban areas of Brooklyn, Queens and Long Island; ultimately led to the decline of waterborne rail/freight traffic and the slow demise of the marine - rail carriers, such as BEDT (and the other marine - rail terminals in New York City area) as freight by rail became redundant (and slower) to increasing tractor-trailer access to Long Island.
Completion of the Verrazano Narrows Bridge, 1964
If you ask me; all NY Metro Area marine - rail traffic really took a nose dive when the Verrazano Narrows Bridge opened in 1964 and the Brooklyn-Queens Expressway connections. (Ironically the Verrazano happens to be one of my favorite suspension bridges). This new bridge and the associated road connections now linking Brooklyn with Staten Island; of which Staten Island was already linked with the mainland United States via New Jersey, via the Goethals, Outerbridge Crossing and Bayonne Bridges.
Now trucks could drive directly from the piers and wharves in New Jersey (or other parts of the United States for that matter), right into the heart of Brooklyn. This meant that without having to travel the Holland or Lincoln Tunnels or the George Washington Bridge in order to cross the Hudson River into Manhattan; then crossing the East River bridges or tunnel to arrive in Brooklyn, truck traffic could now circumnavigate and avoid the growing congestion in Manhattan and arrive directly into Brooklyn.
Closure of the Brooklyn Navy Yard, 1966:
Defense Secretary Robert S. McNamara ordered the Brooklyn Navy Yard and Brooklyn Army Terminal shut down, as a cost cutting move. Even after the efforts of Senator-elect Robert F. Kennedy to prevent the closings, both were to shut down within 18 months. This loss of government freight movement, in addition to the eventual loss of the civilian businesses leasing space in the Navy Yard; took away a substantial proportion of BEDT traffic. History has forgotten the name, but there was a major supplier of coal located in the Brooklyn Navy Yard for the NY Metro area (including segments of the public school system); as well as the Government buildings in the Navy Yard being heating with those black diamonds, and BEDT would bring in countless carfloats of hoppers loaded with coal destined for Brooklyn and Queens.
Formation of Conrail, 1976
For the most part, the economy of the United States was not in the best shape it had been, and the railroads suffered as well. The Class 1 railroads in the Northeastern United States were particularly hard hit:
The government "bailed out" these financially troubled railroads by organizing them in 1976 into a single entity: "Consolidated Rail Corporation" or Conrail for short. While Conrail would now handle most of the Northeast United States' freight service, Conrail was not interested in marine operations, in any way shape or form.
Carfloating for Conrail - 1976
Conrail would take possession of the Greenville, NJ railyard which had been property of Penn Central, but Conrail was not being the least bit interested in carfloating operations. The decision was made by Conrail to contract out the marine and float bridge operations at Greenville to the most qualified bidder.
According to Joe Roborecky, Conrail came to inspect the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal operations at Kent Avenue prior to awarding the carfloating contract. Conrail came away very impressed and as a result, BEDT won the contract over New York Dock, for carfloating operations between Greenville and other surviving Marine-Rail interchanges in New York Harbor.
As part of the contractual agreement between Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal and Conrail, the BEDT would now handle the carfloat traffic for themselves, as well as the New York Dock Railway. According to the contract, the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal would be paid by Conrail to load those carfloats for New York Dock, but would not be for paid for those carfloats loaded for themselves (which was included as part of the contract).
Coming to light in a Brotherhood of Locomotive Engineers / New York Dock / Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal "Arbitration Docket" dated December 15, 1980; is the fact that the BEDT carfloated for the Baltimore & Ohio Railroad, between Greenville, NJ and St. George Terminal, which was located in Staten Island, NY. Prior to BEDT being awarded the Conrail carfloat contract, New York Dock carfloated between Greenville and St. George as well, according to this arbitration docket. (A complete copy of this arbitration docket can be viewed in the Memoirs - Joe Roborecky - Unions chapter).
In the beginning of carfloat operations at Greenville, a BEDT locomotive was sent to Greenville to perform switching duties. However, BEDT locomotives did not have the train brakes operational in the cabs as part of the BEDT Air Brake Policy (see Memoirs - Joe Roborecky - Air Brake Policy). This lack of train brakes made switching operations difficult prior to loading the carfloats.
As a result, BEDT would find the need to lease Conrail locomotives for the loading / unloading of carfloats in Greenville. Several different Conrail diesels would be leased by the BEDT over the years to switch cars in the Greenville yard.
St. George Terminal (B&O), Staten Island
According to the Brotherhood of Locomotive Engineers Union Arbitration Docket dated December 15, 1980; mentions that the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal had a carfloat route from Greenville, NJ to the Baltimore & Ohio Railroad's St. George Terminal, located in Staten Island.
This previously unknown and undocumented carfloat "route" of the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal is significant in the fact that the Baltimore & Ohio Railroad, which in fact was still in business in 1976 (however now as a part of Chessie System), had given up its marine operations.
According to Tom Flagg's book (NY Harbor Railroads in Color, Vol...... 1 p. 16), the B&O gave up their carfloating operations in the mid-1970's. This date could very easily be presumed to be when Conrail was formed in 1976 and the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal won the contract for carfloating operations out of Greenville, NJ.
The St. George Terminal would close in
1980, and thus ending all carfloat traffic to this terminal at such
The Last Years
Combined with the other circumstances mentioned above, BEDT began to hurt financially (as would NYD and Bush Terminal railroads throughout the latter half of the 1960's), but BEDT managed to keep their heads (and their carfloats) above water, and the ink in their ledgers "in the black". Bush Terminal would conclude operations in 1972, with New York Dock leasing the Bush Terminal property from New York City, and Jay Street Connecting was long out of the picture since 1959. BEDT's freight income would continue to diminish, and revenue would continue to diminish throughout the remainder of BEDT's history.
Sometime around 1972, Petro Oil (incorporated as Petroleum Heat & Power Co. of Stamford, CT) purchased the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal from the Havemeyer family holdings. Petro, which is still in business; is a retailer of home heating oil among other petroleum products. Petro would also own the tank farm (formerly Standard Oil) on the East River and the inlet for Bushwick Creek, which is located just north of North 12th Street and the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal Kent Avenue Yard.
To reflect this new ownership, the BEDT tugs "Petro Arrow" (ex-NYNH&H "Cordelia") and Petro Flame (ex-NYNH&H "Bumblebee") would be repainted into the Petro red/white/blue scheme. Oddly though, these tugs would have ports of registry in Philadelphia. There is also picture of a tank truck filling up locomotive #21 on the BEDT #21 photo page and that is almost certainly a Petro truck. (Matter of fact, my family used Petro Oil for many years to heat our former home in Brooklyn). On an as yet unknown date, Burmah Oil & Gas purchased the Petro Oil Company. (By the way, Burmah Oil is the proprietary holder of Castrol Motor Oil since 1966 and Burmah Oil is a British held company.)
In 1977; Reynolds Industries (better known to us as R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Company) purchased the Burmah Oil & Gas Co. and Reynolds merged their Aminoil holdings with the newly purchased Burmah Oil. Aminoil, which did not have U.S. based service stations or refineries, would now wholesale refined petroleum products on the East Coast through Petro Oil.
Sometime after this merger took place,
Reynolds / Burmah / Aminol began to suffer financial difficulties due to
skyrocketing crude oil prices and began to divest itself of it's non-essential
(and non-petroleum) holdings. This apparently included the BEDT properties,
and so the BEDT was put up for sale.
New York Dock Ownership
In July 1975, the United States Railway Association released its "Final System Plan" which in accordance with the Regional Rail Act of 1973, made recommendations for the reorganization of the railroads in the Northeast United States.
Subsequently, the Interstate Commerce Commission recommended that New York Dock and Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal operations be merged to avoid duplication of effort. It was at this time, (currently believed to be 1978) that Dock Properties, the parent company of the New York Dock Railway, purchased the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal.
The following document was issued February 9, 1979 as a revisit to certain points in the original decision of that ICC recommendation:
|NYD Control Of BEDT - ICC Decision|
It is not this authors intent to appear "anti-New York Dock", but several circumstances which appear to be unusual in nature have arisen through research. Other than the direct quotes from legal briefs and document filings, there is little to no documentation supporting these suppositions and in some cases third party "allegations".
According to a Brotherhood of Locomotive Engineers arbitration decision during a meeting held on November 19, 1980, it states:
"The accounts of New York Dock present a dismal financial picture, with a negative working capital position, substantial over-capitalization, a negative net worth, and a 3-year record of deficit operations."
As far as it is known, the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal, while suffering from dwindling revenue and in some cases operating losses as well, still appeared in the black (by whatever margin) at the time of its sale to, and merger with New York Dock. However, it is understood that New York Dock was already filing for bankruptcy reorganization proceedings. Whether the BEDT was either purchased by NYD to help offset losses, or whether NYD purchased BEDT for other reasons, remain unknown. The other substantial question that arises, is how a failing company (i.e. NYD), could have the wherewithal to purchase a financially sound company (BEDT).
According to the excerpt from paragraph 3 of the Abandonment Appeal (which can be read in it's entirety through the link several paragraphs below), we can better understand the dismal financial picture:
"BEDT's annual carloadings had dropped 91% in the period 1973-82. Business in the first three months of 1983 had dropped by 62% from the corresponding period in 1982 and by 88% from the corresponding period in 1981. BEDT had been unsuccessful in its efforts to improve productivity by getting the unions' agreement to change outdated and costly work rules and practices. BEDT's facilities on land required considerable modernization and rehabilitation and its marine equipment required extensive renewal, the total cost of which, it was estimated, would exceed $3 million. Operations for 1982 had resulted in a loss of $120,251. Cash and cash equivalents as of December 31, 1982, had declined to $8,636; current assets, excluding amounts due from affiliated companies, were only $381,873, as against current liabilities, excluding amounts due to NYD Properties, Inc., and affiliated companies, of $418,933. BEDT had, in recent years, been forced to sell corporate assets to meet current obligations.
Compare the information above to paragraph 7 of the same document:
"For reasons similar to those alleged by BEDT, NYD's carloadings had dropped 77% in the ten year period 1973-82. Its business for the final three months of 1983 was 36% less than in the corresponding period of 1982 and 56% less than in the corresponding period of 1981. Like BEDT, NYD alleged that it had endeavored unsuccessfully to get the agreement of labor unions to change outdated and costly work rules and practices; that its physical facilities required modernization, rehabilitation and renewal at a cost of nearly $12 million, which greatly exceeded its earning or borrowing potential; and that in recent years it had been forced to sell corporate assets to meet current obligations. It had a loss of $244,511 in 1982, with an aggregate retained deficit of $3,209,777. Its balance sheet as of December 31, 1982, showed current assets, exclusive of amounts due from NYD Properties and affiliated companies, of $877,574, as against current liabilities, exclusive of amounts due to affiliates, of $2,422,538."
Regardless of these questions and financial statistics, New York Dock purchased and merged with the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal. Below are photographs of the contract signing, between NYD administration and BEDT employees, represented by J. Roborecky, ca. May 1979 or May 1980.
all photos: courtesy of J. Roborecky
The administration and personnel of both NYD Rwy. and BEDT organizations would be merged, and not without some difficulties in seniority standings, but eventually the two operations would merge. Strangely, the two railroads would keep their own separate identities and heralds until the end of operations in 1983. But, throughout this time period, equipment would be pooled and shared, with BEDT locomotives showing their presence at Bush Terminal and New York Dock properties, and New York Dock locomotives showing up on Kent Avenue as well (albeit very infrequently and this author has never seen photographs of this occurrence).
The Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal, regardless of who owned it; and not to mention the City of New of New York and the rest of the United States as well; were facing severe fiscal crises. These economic downturns would effect the BEDT, and they would eventually close it's Pidgeon Street yard sometime in 1977 (perhaps early 1978). The BEDT, after being purchased by the New York Dock would not fare as hoped.
Whatever the reasons, the end result was the one and the same, and the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal would not survive. The following image, taken on an overcast October 1982 day, clearly shows the lack of freight traffic in the yard and a solitary bulkhead car of lumber, with #16 guarding the subway airshaft can be seen. A gloomy photo for a gloomy end to one of Brooklyn finest offline terminal operations.
October 1982 - Bulkhead at foot of North 8th Street looking south
added 03 February 2010
Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal filed the required ICC "Notice of Intent to Abandon Service" on April 8, 1983; and on August 12, 1983, operations at Kent Avenue Yard ceased altogether with the switching of a few covered hoppers at the Bulk Flour Terminal. The operations of New York Dock at Bush Terminal would not fare any better during this same time frame, and after several previous attempts at downsizing; it ceased operations on August 17, 1983.
Joe Roborecky was courteous enough to send me the following image. It is his time book, showing location, assigned locomotive(s), hours of duty and wages. Take particular note of 8/12 (last day of operations at Kent Avenue on locomotive 21) and of the entry for 8/17, with locomotives 22 and 25, and where in the last column is says: "LAST DAY AT NYD".
courtesy of J. Roborecky
According to this Abandonment Appeal (link below), when this decision was made by New York Dock to cease operations, it was decided upon to abandon the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal properties located at Kent Avenue, but the New York Dock properties located at Bush Terminal would be sold to New York Cross Harbor Railroad, even though both properties were owned by New York Dock. This is not so difficult to understand now, as we know from post 1983 operations, only Bush Terminal would continue to operate under New York Cross Harbor ownership, with the Fulton Terminal of New York Dock being abandoned as well.
This is not to say the employee's went down with a fight. The following link will take to a copy of the Abandonment Appeal filed in 1984. While there is a lot of legalese and lawyer jargon, there is some pretty interesting information embedded in the chapters:
|Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal / New York Dock Abandonment Appeal|
Eventually the New York Cross Harbor RR, would be organized a week later in August 1983 and would consolidate and NYD & BEDT assets, including several BEDT diesels as well as two tugboats. Some of the locomotives would be put back in service, and would be re-lettered NYCH. The remaining BEDT / NYD locomotives & equipment would be sold off, cannibalized for parts or were outright scrapped.
The structures of the main office, the engine house and Bulk Flour Terminal would sit abandoned for many years. They would serve as silent sentinels for an era of marine terminal railroad interchange that has never been rivaled since. Sadly, they too would eventually be demolished.
Meanwhile, BEDT #16 sat forlornly on Kent Avenue, with her brass and bronze parts being scavenged. #16 would sit there; first on a siding towards the water, then eventually placed on a concrete pad on Kent Avenue. It would be over 10 years later, before she was finally rescued. She would be brought to the New York Cross Harbor enginehouse on First Avenue (Brooklyn), worked on and cosmetically restored. A few years later, #16 was donated to the Railroad Museum of Long Island in Riverhead, NY; where she remains today, currently undergoing cosmetic restoration.
And what has become of the Kent Avenue yards? Through the late 1980's, the rails were taken up and the crossties resold, and for over 15 years the land remained vacant.
In July 2006, I had the opportunity to visit the BEDT stomping grounds. Sadly, nothing remains now; save for two sets of track about 100 feet long set in concrete on North 9th Street and Kent Avenue (site of the Bulk Flour Terminal), and a paved over spur to a building. Even Kent Avenue has been torn up, right down to sub-roadbed, and is being repaved, so all street crossing tracks have been torn out.
Signs posted along Kent Avenue state the
property is a park under construction and is heavily fenced off.
The Austin Nichols building was listed as a landmark,
but recently had that landmark status removed, but the structure has
been preserved and the windows appear to have been replaced; and the Domino
sugar refinery is no longer making the sweet stuff for coffee.
East River State
Present tense: There is a great land boom developing in the Williamsburg neighborhood, and the land that once was an industrial area and railyard is now home to a residential building boom. Not a bad idea considering the gorgeous views of the East River and Manhattan skyline! A portion of the site of the former BEDT yards Between North 8th and North 9th Streets is now the "East River State Park", and the remainder of the property south of this location is a housing complex. Its name? Palmer's Docks! (Dear Lowell: we've come full circle...)
I have been fortunate to have assisted with the development of this park at the request of Ms. Audrey Nieson of the New York State Office of Parks Recreation & Historical Preservation, Bureau of Historic Sites; in helping create, proof & correct historical information on the interpretative displays located in the park, as well as coordinating usage permission from those current owners of the images chosen to be incorporated in those displays.
The following is an excerpt from the New York State Office of Parks Recreation & Historical Preservation website:
[The] East River State Park is a seven-acre waterfront park located along the East River in the Williamsburg neighborhood of Brooklyn. It offers visitors a stunning view of the Manhattan skyline, a delightful play area, and the green space provides many opportunities for recreation and relaxation. As the site of a 19th century shipping dock, visitors to East River may also discover unique historical remnants like old cobblestone streets and railroad tracks embedded in concrete. Historic interpretive signs are provided for your convenience. The park preserves and protects the many natural and historical resources along this beautiful city waterfront. The park is free and open to the public.
In addition to the great views of the East River and Manhattan, the park offers native meadow plantings among the historic rail yard remnants; passive recreation; picnicking and barbecues.
As time marches on, I am seeing more and
more residents from the ongoing "renaissance" of the Williamsburg neighborhood
making their way to this site. Most are just people who have moved to the
area and wish to learn more about the history of the area they now live in,
and leave comments in the Guestbook. On 13 December 2011, I had the pleasure
of posting a "new" image taken of the former BEDT property from a very unique
vantage point. This image was generously submitted by Nate Able, a resident
of the residential complex that now overlooks the
East River State
Park (former BEDT 8A Yard).
East River State Park (former BEDT 8A Yard) - 12 November 2011
N. Able photo
(Click on image above for annotated version)
Customer & Commodities List
Palmer's Docks, and likewise the East River Terminal and Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal that followed was in the business of transporting freight to and from it various customers. It is impossible to list every single type of freight that the BEDT transported over it's history. What I have been able to do is recreate a "customer list" from the various newspaper articles, lawsuits, documents, receipts and photographs that I have encountered over the years.
By 1940, the BEDT would become a common carrier, and through the years until it's cessation of operations; the BEDT served many large local businesses. The table below lists the customers (where known) of Palmer's Dock, East River Terminal and Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal; 1870-1983. If you happen to be aware of a business that I missed, please feel free to submit it with it's commodity and location for listing.
One thing readers should take note of is, according to the Coverdale & Colpitts Report, carfloated freight car traffic did not go directly from the trunk line / class 1 mainline railroads to Pidgeon Street, Brooklyn Navy Yard team tracks or the "Direct from Carfloat" merchants. Instead, all freight cars were first carfloated to Kent Avenue, where they would be sorted, then placed aboard another carfloat destined specifically for that location.
It seems odd that BEDT would want to handle the freight cars more times than necessary, but according to this report, this was the method used. Matter of fact, the Coverdale & Colpitts Report suggests revising this method to direct placement to both save the finances involved in the double move and to ease congestion in the Kent Avenue Yards.
Railroad Connections & Traffic Proportions
The Coverdale & Colpitts Report gives a precise breakdown of the trunk line / class 1 railroads and the respective proportion of freight traffic the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal received from those railroads.
% of traffic
% of traffic
Central RR of New Jersey
Delaware, Lackawanna & Western
New York Central
Baltimore & Ohio
New York, New Haven & Hartford
New York, Ontario & Western
Sugar & Flour
One of the original reasons behind the creation of Palmer's Dock, would be to transport the raw sugar into Brooklyn for the sugar refineries, as well as ship the finished product out. The East River Terminal and likewise the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal would follow suit as well in this assignment. American Sugar Refiners was located at Kent Avenue and the other refiner being New York Sugar Refiners at Pidgeon Street. The Pidgeon Street refinery would become Jack Frost brand in the later years.
The Havemeyer's constructed their main refinery in 1859 on South 4th Street. Eventually the property south would be purchased, and added. By reviewing the 1886 E. Belcher Hyde map, one can see the Williamsburg area in the vicinity of Palmer's Dock also still held quite a few sugar refineries. One would be located between North 3rd and North 4th, another between North 6th and North 7th Streets. Many more independent refineries would exist prior to this.
Upon the consolidation of those refiners by the Havemeyer's, the main refinery Havemeyer & Elder sugar refinery located by South 3rd Street, would become the sole refinery in the area. However, this refinery did suffer at least two catastrophic fires, one on January 9,1882 and another on June 12, 1887. This refinery at South 3rd would be completely rebuilt and expanded to South 1st Street in 1926.
Both images below, were taken by the author on July 12, 2008 from onboard the Lehigh Valley Railroad tugboat "Cornell".
Havemeyer & Elder / American Sugar Refinery (brick / left - ca. 1887?)
Amstar (Domino) Sugar addition (concrete / right - ca. 1926)
July 12, 2008 - South 3rd Street, Brooklyn, NY
photo by author
added 30 May 2009
Havemeyer & Elder / American Sugar Refinery (1887?) - July 12, 2008 - South 3rd Street, Brooklyn, NY
photo by author
added 30 May 2009
Not only was the sugar brought into Brooklyn via Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal, but flour was also transported and stored as well. The Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal once maintained 10 flour terminals with a combined capacity of 450 carloads.
Commercial bread bakers of the time, such as Pechter's and others; as well as macaroni manufacturers in the area would draw off the flour from these terminals in truck loads on an as need basis.
Eventually Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal would construct the Bulk Flour Terminal for consolidating the specific storage of flour and semolina. The Bulk Flour Terminal would open on March 24, 1964, and cost $300,000 to construct.
The Bulk Flour Terminal was constructed by the John Post Construction Corp, of Christopher Street, and the internal flour handling equipment was installed by the General Contract & Shick-Tube Veyor Co of Kansas City, MO.
Flour would be pumped out of the hopper means of a removable cart that was placed under the hopper chutes. An image of this cart can be seen in the Joe Roborecky chapter on the Memoirs Page.
east (Kent Avenue) wall of Bulk Flour Terminal - October 1982
Appears to be a fan trip.
added 13 June 2010
Covered hoppers inside the Bulk Flour Terminal- October 1982
(looking southwest with Kent Avenue behind photographer)
added 13 June 2010
Breweries, Beverages & Distributors
Other commodities being received, were carloads of hops for the Liebmann brewery (located in Brooklyn) and the Pabst brewery (located in Long Island), and these arrived via Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal. It was off loaded at the terminal then hauled by truck to their respective destinations.
The Schaefer Brewery however, which having been serviced by the Lehigh Valley Railroad until 1975, would become a Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal customer that year. The Schaefer Brewery was located directly on the East River immediately north of the Brooklyn Navy Yard and Wallabout Canal. Schaefer was also a unique customer in the fact that it was a "direct from carfloat" customer. Specially modified carfloats, known as "centerpipe" carfloats, were utilized with pneumatics in offloading the bulk material (hops, barley) held in covered hoppers onboard the carfloat.
Schaefer Brewery & Lehigh Valley "centerpipe" carfloat - September 1972
courtesy of T. Flagg
added 19 February 2010
At some point in its history, Schaefer Brewery became a direct from carfloat customer of the Lehigh Valley Railroad. Sometime during this, the Lehigh Valley Railroad modified a carfloat into a centerpipe type. (More about this later.) In 1971, Schaefer decided to build a new brewery just outside of Allentown, Pa. The following excerpt is from "Breweries of Brooklyn", by Will Anderson; 1976:
Schaefer's most dramatic move with respect to plants was the decision, in 1971, to build a brand new, ultra-modern brewery just outside of Allentown, Pa. Realizing that all three of its plants at the time, Brooklyn, Albany, and Baltimore, were old and inefficient, Schaefer management decided it had to go the route being taken by Pabst, Schlitz, Anheuser-Busch and Miller - build a brand new and thoroughly modernized brewery rather than continue to try to upgrade old facilities. To construct a new brewery is extremely expensive, of course, but when it was opened in 1972 Schaefer could be justifiably proud - their Lehigh Valley plant was one of the most modern and efficient breweries in the world!
What does a company do, however, when
it has one ultra-modern plant and three that appear very dated by comparison?
The question is really rhetorical, of course; strive to add to the modern
plant while phasing out the less efficient facilities. And that's exactly
what Schaefer did. The Albany plant was shut down almost immediately, on
December 31st of 1972. In 1974 the Lehigh Valley plant was expanded from
its original 1,100,000 barrels-per-year capacity to 2,500,000 and then, in
1975, it was decided to expand again - to 5,000,000 barrels plus. By 1975,
therefore, it was obvious that one of the two less efficient plants should
and would be closed, the only questions remaining was which plant, Brooklyn
or Baltimore, and when. Both questions were answered on January 22, 1976
when Robert W. Lear, Chairman and Chief Executive Officer of The F. &
M. Schaefer Corp., announced the closing of the Brooklyn plant.
Apparently, when the Lehigh Valley Railroad learned of Schaefers' impending closing of the Brooklyn plant, Lehigh Valley dropped Schaefer as a customer before Schaefer actually closed, leaving the Schaefer Brewery without service. Exactly why Lehigh Valley chose to do this, is currently unknown. The Lehigh Valley RR constructed at least one special type of carfloat for this direct from carfloat service provided to Schaefer and of which for lack of a better term, has come to be called a "centerpipe" carfloat.
As a result, the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal stepped in and continued direct carfloat service for Schaefer's remaining tenure in Brooklyn. Improving upon Lehigh Valley's lead, the BEDT converted one of their platform/station type carfloats into a "centerpipe" carfloat as well, to be used for Schaefer Brewery unloading. Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal carfloat #26 would be selected for this conversion. As it also happened, BEDT #26 was longer than the Lehigh Valley centerpipe carfloat and allowed for a greater car capacity. This would allow the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal to reduce the number of times the centerpipe carfloat would need to be transported to and from Schaefer and the BEDT float bridges, and thereby reducing the number of times in having the freight cars swapped out on those centerpipe carfloats.
Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal also purchased a surplussed platform/station carfloat from the Pennsylvania RR (carfloat #588), and converted that carfloat to a centerpipe as well. Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal numbered this carfloat to #32. Images of both the #26 and #32 carfloats can be seen on the Marine Equipment page.
It should be noted that the platforms removed from the carfloats would not go to waste either, and would be placed parallel to trackage so that trucks could backup to the platform and freight transferred from boxcars directly into the trucks. The platform from BEDT carfloat #26 was placed at North 9th Street, and the platform from Pennsylvania RR carfloat #588 was placed at Pidgeon Street.
Stern of carfloat to right of image.
T. Flagg photo
Many industries utilize pneumatic unloading, but this method allowed the covered hoppers to be unloaded pneumatically while still on the carfloat. At the Schaefer Brewery, an A frame held a pair of hinged rigid wall suction pipes, which hung over the bulkhead. When the carfloat needed to be moved, the pipes would swing up and out of the way.
On the carfloat itself, the horizontal deck pipes made a 90 degree turn upward at the elevated platform, with the vertical pipe terminating just above the top of that platform. There were two deck pipes, one for each track. When the carfloat arrived and was moored, these hinged pipes would be lowered to and connected from the brewery to the vertical pipe on the carfloat.
At deckpipe level, the deckpipe had capped couplings every 10 feet or so. Short sections of rigid wall hose would connect the individual hoppers to the coupling on the deckpipe, and after a vent hatch was opened, the materials within the covered hopper would be siphoned off. According to Joe Roborecky, not all cars were hooked up to the deckpipe at same time.
When all the hopper cars on the carfloat were empty, that carfloat would be exchanged for one carrying full covered hoppers. In the image above and to the right, the Lehigh Valley carfloat is shown at Schaefer bulkhead. The graphic below denotes the distinguishing characteristics of the three carfloats.
In all actuality, the BEDT centerpipe carfloats
were not in use long, seeing how BEDT picked up Schaefer as a customer in
1975 and Schaefer closed its Brooklyn plant towards the end of 1976 or early
It leaves one to wonder even why BEDT would go through the expense of converting those carfloats for such a short duration, knowing Schaefer was closing the plant and leaving the New York area. Unless of course BEDT was hedging a bet on a last minute reprieve of Schaefers' decision to close the plant, and it would stay open. But, as we all know now, Schaefer closed the plant.
In November 2011, and once again due to
the keen eyes of Paul Strubeck; we have determined that there were in fact
at least three centerpipe carfloats: BEDT #26, BEDT #32 and one built
by the Lehigh Valley. (I originally concluded, erroneously I might add, that
BEDT 32 was the Lehigh Valley carfloat). These three carfloats can be easily
distinguished from each other:
BEDT #26 and #32 were longer (six 50'+ car capacity as having been modified from a station type carfloat) than that of the shorter Lehigh Valley carfloat.
BEDT #26 had Hayes style track bumpers, #32 had box style track bumpers painted yellow. The Lehigh Valley centerpipe carfloat had brown box style track bumpers.
BEDT #26 had mooring cleats, BEDT #32 had mooring cleats along the sides with button bitts on bow & stern, and the Lehigh Valley had double bitts along the sides.
On BEDT #26 and #32, the deckpipe platform was offset
from the end with a segment of deckpipe to the rear of the platform, while
the Lehigh Valley with the deckpipe
platform at the extreme rear end of the carfloat and at the end of the deckpipe.
The sides of the Lehigh Valley carfloat also incorporate three rub rails which take on the appearance of corrugation while the BEDT carfloats did not.
BEDT #26 & #32 had mooring cleats along the top edges of the carfloat deck, and the Lehigh Valley carfloat had double bitts.
What eventually happened to BEDT #26, we do not know. BEDT #32 was seen in several images from 1976 through 1983. The Lehigh Valley centerpipe carfloat also disappeared without a trace.
Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal also serviced a large beer distributor in Long Island City via the Pidgeon Street yard. According to Joe Roborecky, it was not a brewery as originally thought, but a distributor that would primarily receive Miller Beer products via boxcar. It is unknown at this time if it received other brands as well. Boxcars of already manufactured and filled containers would be delivered to this location.
In this arrangement, Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal would switch and spot the boxcar(s) containing the appropriate size containers by the various receiving docks. As there were many types and sizes of beverages being delivered at that time, the boxcar they needed might have been several cars up track and not near the receiving dock. So Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal would have to rearrange the cars to place the appropriate boxcar by the appropriate receiving dock.
Also located at the Pidgeon Street Yard was a Pepsi Cola bottling plant. According to the Pepsi Cola Bottling website, this Long Island City location was the original Pepsi bottling site until 1934, when other Pepsi bottling plants would open around the United States. I particularly recall seeing the huge neon "Pepsi-Cola" sign which could be seen from most East Side locations in Manhattan, especially from the FDR Drive. I believe this sign still exists as a landmark.
Exact details of the Pepsi plant and the interaction with the BEDT are unfortunately not known at this time, but it is understood from the Coverdale & Colpitts Report, that the Pepsi Cola Bottling Plant was a "Direct From Carfloat" customer and yet it is understood from Tom Hendrickson that there was indeed some sort of rail traffic with the Pepsi plant.
It can only be hypothesized that this Pepsi bottling plant received tank cars of corn syrup, cola syrup, and possibly carbon dioxide for carbonation; as well as bottles, cans and cardboard for boxing and packaging. It is unknown at this time if the Pepsi plant utilized team tracks or sidings in addition to the direct from carfloat traffic.
Grain & Hay
Another of the original commodities received via Palmer's Dock and subsequently East River Terminal Railroad / Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal, was grain.
Grain is a rather generic term, as listed in the 1920 Joint Report with Comprehensive Plan & Recommendations, issued by the New York, New Jersey Port & Harbor Development Commission) "grain" pertains to Wheat, Corn, Oats, Rye, Barley, Buckwheat & Flaxseed. Which of, or what combination of those grains was actually stored by Brooklyn Elevator & Milling, is not clear at this time, but this "grain" would be held in the multi-story elevator (similar in principal to a silo) of Brooklyn Elevator and Milling located on the East River bulkhead between at North 9th and 10th Streets.
While it is clearly known that Lowell Palmer created the "Palmer's Dock Hay & Produce Board", it is unknown if Palmer was actually involved in the early stages of the Brooklyn Elevator & Milling. The 1893 Brooklyn Daily Eagle Almanac, states:
"the Brooklyn Elevator Hay & Produce Exchange occupies a new and commodious building at the foot of North Tenth st. [sic] It is the principal market of the kind in the city, and is largely patronized by merchants in N. Y. City"
Later documents (post 1900) reflect that the Havemeyer family were the principals of the Brooklyn Elevator & Milling, with Henry, Theodore, Frederick, Horace all holding various positions on the board of directors.
The exact circumstances regarding the receipt and handling of this "grain" by Brooklyn Elevator & Milling is uncertain. Almost every grain type on the list above could have been used by one merchant or another in Brooklyn (Wheat, Corn, Rye for bread & baking, Oats for feed, Barley for brewing, etc).
Various documents located via Google
book search show various grains could be found at Brooklyn Elevator &
1906: Sample of ground feed taken from Brooklyn Elevator & Milling for chemical analysis.
1922: Lawsuit filed in January against Brooklyn Elevator & Milling states
18,000 ducks were lost by the quality of bran sold.
As horse drawn wagons were still the primary mode of transportation when the elevator was constructed, and taking into consideration that oats were used for livestock / horse feed; and that the North 10th Street Hay Storage Building (the low three story brick structure with the arched windows seen behind the silos in the image below) abutted directly against the Elevator & Mill structure, leads to the possibility that the storage of feed in the Brooklyn Elevator & Mill took place for the many stables in the Williamsburg area. As this structure would disappear from view and aerial maps by 1924. Oddly, this coincides with the advent and expansion of the internal combustion driven trucks.
New York Times archives show that on November 25, 1912, an explosion and subsequent fire destroyed the plant of the Union Sulphur Company. Thirty-four persons were injured. Flying embers set fire to the hay market on the opposite side (south side) of North 10th Street. In a statement issued to the New York Times by H. O. Havemeyer, $245,000 worth of damage was done to the Union Sulphur Works, which was insured for $375,000, as well as undisclosed amounts of damage upon the hay market. The upper two floors of the grain elevator were also heavily damaged.
Therefore, two possibilities exist pertaining
to the Brooklyn Elevator & Mill structure seen in the below image:
This image was taken prior to the fire and subsequent damage, or
These structures were rebuilt.
In any event, whatever "grain" this elevator would have been used for, this elevator had a listed capacity of 500,000 bushels and can be seen in the 1914 image below, contributed by Tom Flagg. If one looks carefully, the faded remains of the painted "Brooklyn Elevator & Milling Co." can be seen on the side wall of elevators (to the right of the smokestack).
There is a service track internal to the structure, and boxcar can be seen partially inside the structure (next to the double row of windows on the ground floor).
As mentioned above, this structure would be razed by 1924, (as the elevators are no longer seen in the Fairchild Aerial Photo taken that year) and when significant portions of the property was reconstructed.
Brooklyn Elevator & Milling
courtesy of Thomas Flagg
added 29 May 2009
Coal & Coke
As previously mentioned in the Palmer's Dock History, Palmer consolidated the coal sheds in Williamsburg and opened his own wholesale coal depot: Palmer's Coal Depot.
In the later years of Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal operations; a set of yard tracks would dedicated to the receiving and off loading of coal when this coal depot was removed from service. This set of yard tracks was located in the North 7th Street yard and hopper cars loaded with coal would be brought in by BEDT and placed in the yard. Portable wheeled conveyors would then be placed under the unloading chutes of the hopper car. The coal was offloaded out of the hopper, onto the conveyors, and directly up and into the retailers trucks using this method. A picture of the hoppers and the conveyors, with a coal dealers truck can be viewed on the BEDT Properties Page. So in all essence, the hopper cars itself (and not the typical coal silo) were the storage as well as shipping methods.
Coal was a primary commodity of the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal until the use of coal declined as a fuel in the early to mid 1950's, where it was dropped in favor of fuel oil and natural gas. Some of coal dealers receiving coal via the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal was the Berry Coal Company< Bacon Coal Company and the Scranton & Lehigh Coal Company.
The Scranton & Lehigh Coal Company, would have rather large concrete coal silos located on North 5th Street, between Wythe Avenue & Berry Street.
NYSPL / NYS Archives Digital Collection
Note the address of the main offices in the newspaper advertisement below: 84-86-88 Kent Avenue - the same as Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal! However, the president of Scranton - Lehigh Coal Company; Thomas Patterson; has not been encountered before as an employee of the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal. Therefore did BEDT lease space to Scranton & Lehigh or was it a wholly owned subsidiary?
Bacon Coal (as seen from an advertising card shown below), had a location that was specifically serviced by the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal: "Newtown Creek / Wallabout Canal". Notice the date on the card: 192_.
This date raises an interesting question as all information to date reflects that the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal did not take up occupancy in the Wallabout Canal area until circa 1933. So, was the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal providing service to this area earlier than believed, or was this a bulkhead delivery only facility?
Meat Packers & Distributors
Throughout the decades when they would be located in Williamsburg, Brooklyn; the Armour, Cudahy, Morrell and Wilson meat packing companies would receive countless tons of beef daily via Palmer's Dock, East River Terminal and subsequently the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal. There was also the firm of Moore Trucking, which was a meat distributor throughout western Long Island.
At peak times, it was not uncommon for 50 carloads (that's fifty boxcars of 40 ton capacity equalling 4,000,000 pounds of meat); to be received by the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal for dispatch on a single Monday. Those 50 cars were roughly the occupancy equivalent of two and a half carfloats.
These meat packers were located on the south side of North 6th Street, and stretched almost the entire length of the block between Wythe Avenue and Berry Street. While the "store fronts" of these meat packers faced north on North 6th Street, a track was located along the back (south side) of the buildings which opened up on the North 5th Street "C Yard" for the unloading of meat into the respective packing houses.
Generally speaking, the multi-track yard at this location occupied the almost the entire length and half the width of the block bounded by North 5 and North 6th Streets, Wythe Avenue and Berry Street. The inset below, taken and modified from the Belcher & Hyde map of 1929; shows the relative arrangement of the "C Yard" trackage for that era. It is unclear if the trackage ever extended to Greenberg Brothers. Iron & Steel, and it is not known how extensively the track arrangement would change when the coal bunker was torn down many years later.
As these Brooklyn based meat packers would relocate out of Brooklyn throughout the 1960's and 1970's, this commodity would diminish and eventually cease at the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal.
Cement / Lime
Another significant commodity of the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal which was ascertained from the Coverdale & Colpitts Report, was cement and lime. Most, if not all of the cement product was delivered via a team track at the Pidgeon Street Yard in Long Island City. Unloading of this product at that location was expedited under contract by an independent contractor.
Lime on the other hand was offloaded (at the date of this report) at the Kent Avenue Yard by Charles Pfizer & Co.
Seen in photos dated April 12, 1963 and September 23, 1963 of #14 in the North 9th Street Yard, shows a rather new and clean "six pack" group of tall steel silos. These silos were used for cement storage. Unfortunately, these silos are not reflected in any aerial photos of 1954, 1966 or 1980 on historicaerials.com; or in any of the track maps of 1953 or 1965.
However, Tom Flagg furnished a track map of BEDT dated 1969, and these silos are shown so we at least now know the silos stood from at least 1963 through 1969. The actual dates of construction through removal remain unknown.
April 12, 1963
September 23, 1963
September 23, 1963
Unfortunately, this is all that is known about these commodities at this time and further research is both pending and welcomed.
(Finished Products & Scrap)
The Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal received its fair share of finished iron & steel products. A substantial portion of this steel was destined for the Navy Yard for military ship construction, but there were quite a few regular civilian customers receiving structural steel at the various BEDT Yards for building and possibly highway construction. The BEDT was well equipped to handle even the largest loads, and mentioned in the Coverdale & Colpitts Report as a special "enticement" to draw customers, BEDT offered to provide free crane service on pieces weighing more than 1,000 pounds.
While finished steel held a significant proportion of inbound traffic; scrap iron and steel as well as other metals was a significant outbound commodity. There were a few scrap yards in the industrialized sections of Williamsburg, as well as other parts of Brooklyn. It is understood from images that the BEDT would set aside a few team tracks to facilitate the loading of scrap metal into gondolas.
In several images, an electro-magnet mounted on a crane can be seen. In the 1952 Railroad Magazine article by Melvin Krampf, it states that 35 to 40% of scrap metal originating in Brooklyn is shipped through the BEDT, with 79% of the outbound scrap destined for either Buffalo, NY or Bethlehem, PA. Images accompanying this article shows the yard area assigned for the loading of scrap metal was between North 8th and North 9th Streets by Kent Avenue, to include use of the overhead gantry at this location. According to Joe Roborecky, BEDT also employed the used of tracked "crawler" cranes with electro-magnets to assist in the loading of this scrap metal.
Independent Scrap which began operations at North 11th Street, would eventually move to the former Pennsylvania Railroad North 4 St Terminal property about 1966. The former PRR property had been purchased by the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal and on an as yet undetermined date, subsequently leased to Independent Scrap. A few dedicated sidings would be constructed on this property and connected to thee BEDT trackage for the receipt of empty gondolas for loading of scrap metal.
Independent Scrap by the way, would receive several contracts to scrap New York City Transit Authority subway cars.
In the image the locomotive and gondola is on track 4A7 coming out of Independent Scrap (ex-PRR North 4th Street Freight Station and is crossing the Intersection of North 5th Street and Kent Avenue. Track 5A1 can be seen to right of loco front step and the crossing shanty is on right edge of image.
January 21, 1968
R. O. Adams photo
added 08 February 2011
Ben Schaefer passed on information that following the demise of Baltimore & Ohio Railroad, several pieces of floating equipment were acquired by New York Dock, and by nature of the 1977 merger with same, were stored at Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal.
Along with numerous platform / station carfloats, the floating machine shop "James H. Clark" and the tugboat "Roy B. White"; two scows numbered 345 and 350 were also acquired from Baltimore & Ohio.
As it would turn out, these scows would be used by the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal in the transport of copper to the Phelps - Dodge Refining Corporation located on Newtown Creek. The copper was used for for the making of copper sulfate based pesticides.
For unknown reasons there was a long involved, labor intensive process for the transfer of copper ingots arriving via the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal to Phelps - Dodge:
High cube boxcars loaded up to their haulage capacity with 750 pound copper ingots, would arrive at Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal on a three track interchange carfloat. These boxcars were hauled off the three track interchange carfloats, and transferred onto a modified station / platform carfloat. Joe Roborecky recalls that this station carfloat was so modified, in that the roof of the platform was raised to accommodate the opening of the plug doors on high cube boxcars.
Also, one empty boxcar with a fork lift inside was also loaded onto the station carfloat, with the boxcars loaded with copper. This carfloat was then moved slightly upriver from the float bridge at North 9th Street to north side of "9 Pier" (slightly north of the float bridge) and moored to the pier. Then, one of the former B & O scows would be moored against the station carfloat.
Then the fork lift would exit the empty boxcar, and begin removing the copper ingots out of the loaded boxcars and set them down on the carfloat platform. Now another fork lift (or the same fork lift later in the day) would stack the ingots on the scow.
When all the boxcars were unloaded and all the ingots on the scow, the scow would be brought to Phelps - Dodge. Fortunately, this operation did not occur every day, (and I certainly hope not considering the labor involved!)
And exactly why this procedure was needed is unclear. I can only hazard a guess that perhaps there was bulkhead crane at Phelps Dodge used to remove the stacks of ingots from the deck of the scow in bulk, but if the ingots were loaded inside boxcars, they could not be accessed by the crane and hence the transfer onto an open scow.
Waste Paper & Cardboard
According to Joe Roborecky's recollection, the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal was engaged in the transport of baled waste paper and cardboard to an unknown location or locations. Joe cannot recall whether the baled waste paper was inbound or outbound, but does recall the bales being on stake bed trucks being transloaded to or from the railroad car.
It is plausible however, before widespread recycling became the choice of todays "ecologically friendly" disposal methods, this baled cardboard and paper products were sent to incinerators for burning.
Please note this is the authors hypothesis based on the prevalant method of the disposal of waste paper in the era of BEDT operations.
The Austin Nichols Company, was the purveyor of Sunbeam Foods label, and was the largest grocery wholesaler of its time. Austin Nichols would receive many different foods and edibles through the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal, such as: dried fruits, coffee, cheese, olives and peanut butter. In 1934, Austin Nichols entered the liquor business as well. This building had its own pier trackage and had three sidings designed and built into it's ground floor at the northwest corner, where the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal would directly place inside the building whatever cars were destined for Austin.
These tracks would enter the building at the foot of the pier and ran inside the entire length of the building (paralleling North 4th Street). The indoor tracks had an elaborate system of trackside conveyors to move freight throughout the building The tracks then exited the east face of the structure to cross Kent Avenue, where they would continue east to Wythe Avenue and join back up with another track, forming a runaround.
In the late 1950's, when Federal Business Machine took over the structure, the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal would continue to service the new tenant, but the float bridge was removed from service shortly after. The Austin Nichols building did receive landmark status, but was recently taken off the list. The structure was designed by Cass Gilbert (of Woolworth building and Brooklyn Army Terminal fame), financed by Havemeyer & Elder, and was constructed from 1913 to 1915.
As of July 2008, portions of the roof of the Austin Nichols building were removed, leaving the four walls. It is under going restoration, with the intent of being converted into luxury apartments. In the image below, you can see the remains of the three track entrance in the bottom left of the structure (immediately to the right of where the yellow loader is parked). A new concrete pier was built almost but not quite in the same location original track pier (as you can see, the right track bay would open onto the water now.
P. F. Strubeck photo - July 2008
Direct Carfloat Service
The Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal also provided a special service to a few customers. It would place carfloats loaded with cars at specific locations for the direct offloading of the customers product at their facility without the need to offload the cars themselves. The carfloats would be moored directly to the bulkhead of the customers property. Employees of the company would then remove the cargo directly from freight cars aboard the carfloat.
Several customers throughout the history
of the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal would take advantage of this
special service. Since only a few customers were occupying bulkhead properties,
there were not many who could exercise this option. So far, these are the
customers known to have received direct from carfloat
hops, barley, yeast
While this direct carfloat service eliminated the need for the construction of a float bridge, team yard trackage and the maintenance of same; this service would require the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal to occupy and logistically take out of service one or more of its car floats for a duration of time.
New York "Brooklyn" Navy Yard
One can just imagine what freight and military supplies moved through the Brooklyn Navy Yard facility. The Brooklyn Navy Yard would have its own steam locomotives during WW1 and in later years "fireless" steam powered and diesel electrics until the conclusion of WWII.
The following image shows a ships propeller arriving at the Brooklyn Navy Yard in 1942. This shipment would have been transported to the Brooklyn Navy Yard by the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal at this point in time.
George Strock photo
Life Magazine archives (also South Street Seaport Museum)
added 20 Nov 2008
Throughout the years, one of the largest commodities being shipped to the Navy Yard were hoppers loaded with coal for the powerplant there. According to Joe Roborecky, BEDT locomotive engineer (1968 -1983), if there was a carfloat with hoppers and a locomotive on it, it was going to or coming from the Navy Yard. Loaded coal hoppers would be brought to the Powerhouse and unloaded almost immediately. Then the empties would be brought back to the carfloat and loaded. When necessary, hopper cars would be stored on lead tracks running up to the Powerhouse within the Navy Yard and BEDT would handle the movements. The hoppers would be spotted with the chutes over an unloading pit, and the coal dumped. Portable vibrators would be inserted into channels built into the side of the hopper carbody and would break coal loose when stuck or frozen. In the wintertime, long metal pipes with multiple holes which were gas jets, would be ignited and used to thaw out the bottom of the hopper cars when the coal load was frozen solid.
After the Navy Yard was sold to civilian control in 1966, BEDT would continue to carfloat directly to the Navy Yard from Kent Avenue with a locomotive onboard the carfloat. Operation of float bridge would be handled by a employee of the corporation currently owning the Brooklyn Navy Yard property who would operate the electric overhead float bridge, but now BEDT personnel and locomotives would spot the cars at respective locations within the Navy Yard.
In the later years, one of the main customers was SeaTrain Shipbuilding, who would receive gondolas and flat cars loaded with structural steel and gondolas full of ship anchor chain. Other customers located at the Brooklyn Navy Yard after 1966 would be: Crippen Pipe (steel pipe), Coastal Drydock (ship repair), and US Customs (assorted freight).
Normally, Navy Yard operations required only a short "several hour" BEDT presence. Upon conclusion of freight movements, the BEDT tug, carfloat and locomotive would return to Kent Avenue. However, on more than one occasion, BEDT would store a locomotive in the Navy Yard Powerhouse on an as need basis when multiple day operations in the Navy Yard were required. The Powerhouse had a lead track into it with a roll up door, and this would be where the locomotive would be stored. Upon locomotive start up the next morning, Navy Yard Powerhouse employees would get rather ornery about the exhaust smoke from the diesel.
Less Than Carload "LCL" Freighthouses
One should also note, the list below does not include the "less than carload lot" freighthouses at North 5, North 7, North 9 and North 10th Streets or the pier station at Queensboro Terminal at 13th Street, in Long Island City. These freighthouses were used for the storage of those items awaiting pick up by their recipients.
These items, when they were not of sufficient size or quantity to occupy an entire freight car, were known as "Less Than Car Load" or "LCL". This could be anything from a single carton of bars of soap, a few containers of pesticide, a few bags of fertilizer or a large as a reel of pipe or wire. Neither of these items in such small size or quantity would warrant the consignment of an entire freight car, so several items belonging to different consignors destined for different customers in the same relative geographical area would be placed aboard a single freight car and sent to a freight house that served the area the customers was located in.
Once arriving at their relative destination, (in this case the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal, serving north Brooklyn and parts of Queens), these various items would be offloaded into a freight house, where the recipient would be notified of its arrival and was awaiting pick up. In the early days, these freighthouses and freight depots were originally leased by the mainland railroads within Palmer's Docks, and that eventually the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal would take over.
The North 5th Street and North 10th Street freighthouses, were part of the original operation dating back to the days of Palmer's Dock, with North 7 and North 9 being constructed on later dates. According to the blueprints of the North 5th Street submitted by Joe Roborecky, the North 5th Street Freighthouse was for inbound freight. This would leave the North 9th Street freighthouse was for outbound freight. Several of the original freighthouses would be reconfigured over the years, and in later years (around 1915) when it replaced the North 9th Street freighthouse, the North 10th Street freighthouse would hold the outbound freight.
The Warren Street Terminal located on the Morris Canal in New Jersey, opened in 1910. There would be at this location an "L" shaped freighthouse on the bulkhead. Resources have it that this structure was owned prior to Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal tenancy by Lowell Palmer who had a cooper shop at this location to serve the American Sugar Refinery on the next block. This terminal closed in the mid 1920's (believed to be 1924, but this date is not confirmed).
The Queensboro or 13st Street Terminal was built a few years later in 1914 and was located in Long Island City. It too was constructed directly on the bulkhead of the East River. This terminal would handle both inbound and outbound freight, and freight was loaded / unloaded directly to and from the freight cars on the carfloats, making the need to unload the freight cars unnecessary. The Queensboro Terminal only lasted until about 1930.
Trailer On Flat Car Service / TOFC Ramp
The Coverdale & Colpitts Report, in the chapter on "Proposals for Possible Improvements" on page 38; recommends for the BEDT to investigate the feasibility on instituting a Trailer on Flat Car (TOFC) service; but recognizes the fact that instituting such TOFC service might be both expensive for the BEDT to accomplish, and not render a sufficient revenue to offset that cost in instituting such TOFC services.
According to E. M. Koehler, he states in the 1990 issue of Semaphore, that the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal had such a Trailer On Flatcar Ramp in the Kent Avenue Yards. I believe this to be the two recessed tracks along the south wall of the Bulk Flour Terminal. As the tracks were "below grade" and the street was level with the deck of flatcars, this would make sense for this application.
I have denoted these recessed tracks in the revised Port Series map of 1968, and the Terminal Engineer Maps of 1962 and 1969 shows this as well. Joe Roborecky adds the only track he was aware of that something could be driven off a flatcar was track 8A4, but he does not recall any TOFC operation at Kent Avenue.
There is another factor that should be taken into consideration. When the segment of the Brooklyn Queens Expressway running through Williamsburg was being planned:
"The city plan included a "North 9th Street Connection," an elevated highway spur along North 9th Street that was to connect the mainline highway with Wythe Avenue. It was to provide access to an industrial area along the Williamsburg waterfront."
Had the Brooklyn Queens Expressway North 9th Street Spur been constructed, TOFC traffic would have increased dramatically. More about this highway spur along with a diagram can be read in the The Highway Connection chapter.
Other than these two references, I have come across no other mention of this TOFC operation. The following is an illustration of the track arrangement at that location:
The Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal also did not have any outsize or height limits on it's freight handling, and one of the crowning achievements of Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal freight handling (and a record setter) was the transport of a naval rifle weighing 300,175 pounds destined for the Brooklyn Navy Yard! It could handle anything the carfloats could carry that the locomotives could pull.
Interestingly enough, the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal was once considered to have the best crane facilities in the East, with cranes that ranged in capacity from 5 to 40 tons. Below are photos of two of the overhead gantries that operated on BEDT property. Three of the images are of the gantry located in the North 8th Street yard and this is believed to be the first of several gantries installed by the BEDT sometime after 1924, as it does not appear in Fairchild Aerial photo of that year. The top two images, are from a circa 1930's BEDT advertising brochure. The left middle is from the authors collection. They show the Chesapeake Crane 5/25 ton capacity gantry in use.
Note the solid tire, chain drive trucks waiting to receive the loads. In the top left photo, the small sheave and pulley system (rated for 5 ton and not in use in this photo) is idle, while the larger set up (in use) was rated for 25 ton. In the top right photo, the 25 ton system is idle and an electro-magnet is now attached to the 5 ton hook and sheave, and lifting what appears to be scrap railroad car wheels (they are flanged) and placing them in the wood sided gondola.
North 8th Street Yard Gantry (looking east)- ca. 1930
North 8th Street Yard Gantry (looking west) - ca. 1930
| Dave Keller had these two
images in his archives of the North 8th Street Gantry in use with a
drop end gondolas, and are shown here:
|This bottom photos however, are the North 6th Street Yard Gantry (which in fact was closer to North 7th Street). This gantry was a Niles Electric Crane with a 20 ton lifting capacity.|
Several more gantries would be purchased and constructed for a total of five gantries as stated in the 1952 June Railroad Magazine article by Melvin Krampf. It appears that at least one gantry was located in each yard as we have seen gantries in the photos of locomotives working in the North 5th, North 7th and North 8th Street yards.
The BEDT also employed the use of both tracked and wheeled self propelled cranes (cranes on truck bodies) which by their nature were more mobile and could be placed anywhere they were needed. These cranes appear in many photos of the locomotives, so if you wish to view them, please reference the locomotive roster pages.
In the later years, heavier loads became increasingly common and a little more mundane, and some of these loads were electrical transformers. According to Joe Roborecky, Consolidated Edison a/k/a ConEd (the utility company in the New York Metro area) would receive very large transformers via the BEDT, for their power plants and electrical switching stations located along the East River shorelines.
When these transformers arrived by rail, they were loaded with the other railcars onto a carfloat in Greenville and floated to Kent Avenue. Once the carfloat arrived at Kent Avenue, the carfloat would be "drilled" (freight cars removed) and the freight cars classified and placed in their respective BEDT yard locations. On the scheduled date, the transformer would be reloaded by itself onto the carfloat and floated directly to the ConEd site. Once at the ConEd location, a large capacity crane (either ConEd owned or outside subcontractor) would lift the transformer directly from the carfloat to the ConEd property.
S. Goldstein photo
Inbound Freight Cargo
(Arriving in Brooklyn)
wood barrels & casks
grains & feeds
lime & cement
firebrick & cements
semolina & flour
Kent Ave. & S 3 St. §
Kent Ave. & N 3 St.
Wythe Ave. & N 5 St.
Kent Ave. & N 3 St.
Wallabout Canal / Newtown Creek
N 5 St.
Kent Ave. & N 6 St. & N 4 St.
N. 10 St. & Bulkhead
Kent Ave. & N 8 St.
Brooklyn Navy Yard
Wythe Ave. & N 5 St.
Kent Ave. & N 7 St.
Kent Ave. & S 3 St. §
Kent Ave. & N 8 St.
Kent Ave. & N 3 St.
N 5 St.
Kent Ave. & N 11 / N 4 St.
N 5 St.
N 5 St.
Wythe Ave. & N 3 St.
unknown (possibly N 5th St.)
N 5 St.
N 5 St.
Metropolitan Avenue (team trk dlv'y)
Newtown Creek (Bridgewater St.)? §
Pidgeon St. §
Newtown Creek §
Kent Ave & N 5 St.
Kent Ave. & S 9 St. §
Wythe Ave. & N 3 St.
Berry St. bet N 4 & N 5 Sts
Brooklyn Navy Yard
N 9th St.
Bushwick Inlet (N14 St.)§
Wythe Ave. & N 5 St.
Pidgeon St. §
Wythe Ave. & N 5 St.
Berry St bet Grand & N 1 St
N 10 St. & East River bulkhead
Brooklyn Navy Yard
Brooklyn Navy Yard
Wythe Ave. & N 5 St.
Kent Ave. & N 10 St.
Pidgeon Street as well as N 9 St
Kent Ave. & N 9 St
§ = direct from carfloat offloading
Outbound Freight Cargo
(Departing from Brooklyn)
By no means, after receiving these loaded cars; were they returned to the mainland empty. While some would be, some cars would be loaded with finished products such as refined sugar, wire, tubing, and agricultural supplies, some of which were shipped in "less than car load" lots, were sent off to various parts of the country. Some of these shippers were:
Several shipping receipts and arrival notices (NYCS Form AR40-6) dated 1944, that I have accumulated, show:
A farm in Davenport Center, NY received
400 pounds (in 50 lb. bags) of agricultural "Bordeaux Mix" pesticide being
shipped monthly from Brooklyn through BEDT; cost of shipping: 87
Several different receipts showing various
amounts of reels of lead pipe (503 lbs. each), cost of shipping:
1 coil of burlapped rope a week apart
(271 lbs. each); cost of shipping: $1.60
2 cartons of paint (160 lbs.); cost of shipping: 77 cents.
Perhaps what is most amusing; is that
3 reels of lead pipe, weighing 1776 lbs., were shipped from Charles Millar
& Son in Brooklyn, NY; to C. B. Hubbard of Davenport Center, NY and the
freight charges cost "only" $7.64.
Also originating at the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal, are an untold number of shipments of scrap metal received from the hundreds of metal and auto scrap yards throughout Brooklyn and Queens. The Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal operated a scrap metal handling facility, with gantry equipped electro-magnets, and depressed or below grade rail tracks for quick bulk loading of gondolas.
These recyclers sent countless thousands of tons of scrap metal back to the steel mills in Pennsylvania by rail gondola to be recycled, by way of the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal.
Terminals, Facilities & Yards - 1870 - 1983
Terminals, Yards & Trackage - Overview
The map below shows BEDT yards and locations and respective water routes to and from the other terminals in 1952, that it exchanged carfloats service from in the New York Metropolitan area. By 1952, the Warren Street Terminal had already closed, and the Wallabout Terminal was incorporated into Navy Yard operations, so they are not listed.
Railroad Magazine, BEDT Route Map - June 1952
Included in this property, are the piers of which either track were laid upon or piersheds and / or buildings were built for the storage of freight, hay and such.
Listed on page 108 in the book: "Ports of the United States" by Grosvenor M. Jones, 1916; are the dimensions of the piers under the ownership of the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal at their Kent Avenue facilities. I have reproduced them here:
|North 3rd Street||319' x 73'|
|North 4th Street||150' x 60'|
|North 4th Street||221' x 15'|
|North 4th Street||255' x 32'|
|North 5th / 6th Street...||375' x 39'||West Shore RR|
|North 6th Street||365' x 60'||West Shore RR|
|North 7th Street||378' x 70'|
|North 8th Street||440' x 30'|
|North 9th Street||411' x 35'|
|North 10th Street||393' x 20'|
Ports of the Unites States, 1916
Department of Commerce - Bureau of Foreign & Domestic Commerce
Miscellaneous Series - No. 33
Report on Terminal Facilities, Commerce, Port Charges,
and Administration as Sixty-Eight Selected Ports
by Grosvenor M. Jones
The Terminals & Railyards
There were several railyards under the control of the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal or that the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal had access to throughout its history. Some would last the duration from 1870 through 1983, while others may have only lasted a few years. Below is a table containing the dates of service of the Palmer's Dock / East River Terminal / Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal yards, with geographical location and car capacities (where known).
Below, you will find the histories behind
each terminal, facility and yard. Some are quite detailed while others are
still being researched. If you desire specific information on a particular
location, please click on it.
Location, Dates of Service & Car Capacity List
dates of service
|Kent Avenue North 3 - North 12 St...||Williamsburg, Bklyn||1870 - 1983||800 cars|
|Kent Avenue South 3||Williamsburg, Bklyn||ca. 1952||100 cars 1|
|Wallabout Market Terminal||Williamsburg, Bklyn||1937 - 1941||90|
|Brooklyn Navy Yard||Williamsburg, Bklyn||1941 - 1983||unknown but vast|
|Pidgeon Street||Long Island City, Qns||1906 - 1976||100 cars|
|13th Street (Queensboro Terminal)||Long Island City, Qns||1914 - 1930?||unknown - probably none|
|Warren Street||Jersey City, NJ||1910 - 1927 >||100 cars 2|
|Greenville Yard||Jersey City, NJ||1976 - 1983||1000 + cars|
¥ = capacity shown is for standard 40' boxcars and peak year of traffic: 1952.
1 = capacity shown is for direct from carfloat service, approximately 4 to 5 carfloats
2 = capacity shown is for 35' cars
Kent Avenue - North 3 through North 12 Streets
Map / Photo Index:
The maps below are a compilation of Sanborn Fire, maps, property / tax maps of E. Robinson, G. W. Bromley and E. Belcher Hyde Atlases, and Corp of Engineer Port Series maps. Also included here are Aerial Photos and Subway Contract Photos.
The Sanborn and Port Series maps are more accurate in terms of track structure, but the old property maps show the customers and property owners.
All are important in showing the history
regarding Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal trackage.
1886 - E. Robinson Map
1886 E. Robinson Atlas
NYPL Digital Archives
(north is straight up)
As of February 2008 (I found them in May), the New York Public Library scanned these 1886 and 1898 E. Belcher Hyde maps (which were not available when I added the 1907 and 1929 maps to this chapter). These maps contain a great deal more detail as to the trackwork for those years, than opposed to the simple Geological Survey Maps listed above. Yet another desirable aspect of these E. Belcher Hyde and G. W. Bromley maps, is that they list principle businesses and industries in the area, property and street dimensions.
As can be seen in this map on this very early date, one float bridge at the foot of North 5th Street has been built. This confirms for us that the first float bridge to be located in Brooklyn (much less that of Palmer's Dock / Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal) was at North 5th Street. There is also one set of pier tracks shown (block 9), and the trackage is centered around North 5th Street.
This map also shows what little yard trackage existed this time, but that the majority of this trackage is situated north of the float bridge. Note how two tracks cross Kent Avenue, enter the west face of, and run through the entire length of New York, Lake Erie and Western RR Freight Depot (block 25), and then exit the east face to cross Wythe Avenue to the block east (block 28).
Of those two tracks exiting the New York, Lake Erie & Western RR Depot; note how the northern track splits up to a four track yard, with the southern track of that yard appearing to serve the north wall of the New York Central & Hudson River RR Depot. The southern track that exits the New York Lake Erie & Western Depot appears to enter the west face of New York Central & Hudson River RR Depot as it did for the New York, Lake Erie and Western RR Depot one block west.
This arrangement would give two competing railroads indoor freight handling service in Brooklyn. At least there is a track running around the south face of the New York, Lake Erie & Western Depot along North 5th Street, so car movements for the New York Central & Hudson River would not be hampered by those cars on the southern run through track of the New York Lake Erie & Western Depot.
On the south side of North 5th Street, we see the street trackage for the New York Central & Hudson River Depot and the Cooperage (block 24), which appear to be of loading dock variety along the north wall, as there are no turnouts or stubs.
1888 Sanborn Fire Map
During a research "get together" on 10 June 2009; between Tom Flagg, Joe Roborecky and myself , Tom "bestowed" upon me high resolution copies (albeit in black & white) of 1888 and 1905 Sanborn Fire Maps showing the Palmer's Dock facilities.
The following image, is a 1888 Sanborn Fire Map. These "Sanborn Maps" are much more accurate in regards to track layout and structure design than the Belcher Hyde and Bromley property maps. Both types of maps however serve their purposes well: Sanborn Fire Maps were used by insurance underwriters in assessing the risks of fire based on the structure construction, fire prevention measures (hoses, water plugs, sprinklers, etc) and the vicinity of the structure to water mains, fire hydrants, etc. Property maps show the dimensions of the properties, structures and lots.
This 1888 Sanborn map is perhaps the most accurate map we will encounter showing the original trackwork as Lowell Palmer had constructed in 1873 - 1876. Oddly, this map shows the New York, Lake Erie & Western Freight House under construction, while the Robinson map above (dated two years earlier), reflects a finished structure. I believe the Robinson Property Map to have been revised, even though the NYPL description does not reflect this.
Also, for those of you that notice, some of the structure are marked for storage of "hogsheads". A hogshead was a large barrel used for sugar and did not have any connection with the meat industry in the area. As Palmer's Cooperage / Brooklyn Cooperage made the wooden barrels ("hogsheads") for the sugar refiners, one can now understand why the structures are marked for hogshead storage.
Please click on the image below to view a high resolution large scale image of the 1888 Sanborn Fire Map. Use your back arrow to return you here, as there is no return link.
1888 Sanborn Fire Map - Palmer's Docks & Pennsylvania RR Freight Station (North 4th through North 10th Streets)
courtesy of T. Flagg
(reoriented for north, and image clean up by author)
1898 - E. Belcher Hyde Map
(north is top left)
The small disconnected map at top was formerly insetted on another plate in this E. Belcher Hyde atlas and I added to this map for continuity. Unfortunately, the larger map ( on another page) was oriented facing right (west equaling up), and upon rotating it to reflect north equaling up, the lettering is now upside down.
A growing expansion of Palmer's Docks has taken place in the ten year span between this map and the one from above. We can now see a turnout had been installed and a spur track extended into the north / south alley of the Brooklyn Cooperage Plant (block #2341) bounded by Kent and Wythe Avenues and North 4 and 5th Streets and a fifth track added in the yard by the New York Central & Hudson River Depot (block #2334). This northernmost track now serves the meat packers located there.
The Pennsylvania RR has constructed their North 4th Street Terminal with a float bridge, south of the Palmer's Docks operations, and no physical connection between the Pennsylvania RR and Palmer's operation shows at this time. (To the best of my research, there never would be a physical track interchange between these two operations.)
It appears from the map, the North 5th Street float bridge has been moved north a few yards (the 1886 map above show it located directly at the foot of North 5th Street), and the North 5th Street yard expanded (block #2332). The map reflects another float bridge has been built just south of North 6th Street as well as a narrow freighthouse and that is occupied by the New York Central & Hudson River RR.
However, the greatest trackage / property expansions took place north of North 6th Street. From the map, we can see Brooklyn Cooperage has constructed a large building occupying almost the entire block (block #2324) located between North 6 & North 7th Streets. While most of the yard tracks constructed by Palmer would be oriented east / west, there had been constructed six or so tracks along the bulkhead oriented north / south at this location. This yard was in essence two blocks long (North 6th to North 8th Streets) and appear to have served the west face of new Cooperage structure. There was also service along the south face (North 6th Street) as well as north face of (North 8th Street) of this new Cooperage structure.
Also seen, several railyards have been constructed west of Kent Avenue in the blocks of North 7th to North 8th (block #2316) and North 8th to North 9th Streets (block #2308) and North 9th to North 10th Street (block #2301). The disconnected map section at top shows "Palmer's Coal Pockets" (block #2308) located by North 9th Street and Kent Avenue. This is the "famous" coal depot as built by Lowell Palmer, that can be read about in the Brooklyn Eagle article of October 12, 1892. See Palmer's Dock Coal Depot for that article.
We also see, the North 9th Street float bridge is in service at this time, as well as a nice sized yard to service both Brooklyn Elevator & Milling (grain mill) and North 9th Street Hay Storage building, both of which has also been constructed as of this year.
1905 Sanborn Fire Map
During a research "get together" on 10 June 2009; between Tom Flagg, Joe Roborecky and myself , Tom "bestowed" upon me high resolution copies (albeit in black & white) of 1888 and 1905 Sanborn Fire Maps showing the Palmer's Dock facilities.
The following image, is a 1905 Sanborn Fire Map. These "Sanborn Maps" are much more accurate in regards to track layout and structure design than the Belcher Hyde and Bromley property maps. Both types of maps however serve their purposes well: Sanborn Fire Maps were used by insurance underwriters in assessing the risks of fire based on the structure construction, fire prevention measures (hoses, water plugs, sprinklers, etc) and the vicinity of the structure to water mains, fire hydrants, etc. Property maps show the dimensions of the properties, structures and lots.
This Sanborn Fire Map, like its 1888 version
above; is very informative to the use of many of the Palmer's Docks structures
located on the property. Of special importance was the fact:
There are TWO engine houses located on the property in 1905: one located by the North 5th Street float bridge, and the second was constructed by the North 9th Street float bridge. It is logical to conclude that the North 5th Street engine house was constructed first, as this was the location of Palmers initial operation and location of the first float bridge.
It appears the the Brooklyn Fire Department's "David A. Boody" fire boat was stationed at the North 8th Street Pier.
The Baltimore & Ohio Railroad (along with Central Railroad of New Jersey and the Philadelphia & Reading Railroad) is shown to be occupying the North 7th Street Freight Shed. This is significant because the Baltimore & Ohio RR had opened their own offline terminal located at North 1st Street around 1890. This location was subsequently occupied by the New York ,New Haven & Hartford Railroad around the time of this Sanborn issue.
Finally, we obtain the name of the rubber works, Eugene
Please click on the image below to view a high resolution large scale image of the 1905 Sanborn Fire Map. Use your back arrow to return you here, as there is no return link.
1905 Sanborn Fire Map - Palmer's Docks & Pennsylvania RR Freight Station (North 4th through North 10th Streets)
courtesy of T. Flagg
(reoriented for north, and image clean up by author)
1907 / 1908 - G. W. Bromley & Co. Atlas
(north is straight up)
In August 2007, Jay Wanczyk emailed me a map from the 1907-1908 G. W. Bromley & Co Atlas. The Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal is not mentioned, which is odd in itself as the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal was organized in 1906. I can only hazard a guess the maps were drawn and compiled prior to the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal being organized in 1906, but the actual atlas that the maps were contained in was released in 1907-1908.
Oddly, this map shows a connection between the Pennsylvania RR yard between North 4th and North 5th Streets, and the track lead running on the south side of North 5th Street and running one block east to Wythe Avenue, to service the Brooklyn Cooperage (block #2341) which was located on the south side of North 5th Street. As far as we know, the Pennsylvania and Palmer never had a physical track interchange. Also, as far as history dictates; it was Palmer's operation that serviced the Cooperage, but this map shows Pennsylvania RR trackage at the north wall of the Brooklyn Cooperage.
There are a few discrepancies worth mentioning in this map: There is no apparent connection to the tracks on the west end of the Erie Freight Depot, but we can conclude from referencing either the 1898 or the 1929 E. Belcher Hyde maps, that this trackage did indeed connect to the West Shore yard on North 5th Street and "ran through" the Erie Freight Depot from Kent Avenue just north of North 5th Street. This apparently is an error.
What has not been determined to be an error, is that we can see the trackage in the "West Shore Freight Yard" is not connected to the remainder of the trackage of "Palmer's Dock Yards" along the bulkhead north of North 6th Street. Did this break truly exist?
Another most interesting discovery, shows the Central Rail Road of New Jersey (yup, they were there too apparently!) had a freight depot on the north side of North 7th Street, between the bulkhead and Kent Avenue.
On the southwest corner of Kent Avenue & North 8th Street was a Rubber Factory that apparently had rail service from Palmer's Dock. It appears this structure is built upon the former location of the coal pockets.
As for float bridges, the Pennsylvania had theirs, in it's expected location between North 4th and North 5th Streets. the West Shore used the North 5th Street and North 6th Street float bridges (that would become Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal), and Palmer's Dock had another float bridge now located at North 9th Street, which would also become the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal.
Thanks to Jay and this map, we learn that not only the Pennsylvania and Erie railroads, but now the West Shore and Central Railroad of New Jersey had a presence in Williamsburg prior to the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal organization.
1920 - Subway Tunnel Contract Survey Photo
This photo was taken in May 17, 1920 as part of the surveying for the tunneling contract for the BMT 14th Street - Canarsie Line (currently the "L" line) and for the apparent location of the ventilation shaft so commonly seen in later photos of the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal. While this photo is also included in the Property Page, it is also included in this chapter because of its historical significance.
This photo which was taken looking east and I believe was taken from roof or at least a second story window of the front of Palmer's Dock Pier Shed at the foot of North 7th Street.
The structure along the right (southern) edge of the image is the north wall of the Brooklyn Cooperage. Note how a single track runs along the inside of the south curb line of North 7 Street. This track was in fact connected (below the photographer and out of view) to the North 7th Street "A" Yard seen to the left (north) of North 7th Street.
Along the north curbline of North 7th Street from the bottom left corner of the photo and to the end of the freight cars along that track, was the site of the Central RR of New Jersey freighthouse that was leased to them by Palmer / Havemeyer. This freight depot is also shown to be inhabited by Baltimore & Ohio & Philadelphia & Reading Railroads. This freight depot is not shown on the 1898 E. Belcher Hyde Property Map, but is shown in the 1905 Sanborn Fire and 1907 / 1908 G. W. Bromley Property Maps, and apparently gone by 1920. This freight shed only held that single track running through its center, from east to west.
Behind the rows of freight cars in this yard and along Kent Avenue, construction debris can be seen along with a ramshackle construction shed visible as well. There were several structures here as shown on the 1905 Sanborn Fire Map, and they appear to have been demolished about the time of this photo. The smokestack and three story brick structure seen on the left edge of the photo is the Eugene Doherty Rubber Works.
While the following is not related to Palmer's Dock / BEDT, it is interesting enough to mention. Across Kent Avenue on the northeast corner is what appears to be a bar / tavern. Joe Roborecky has identified a set of swinging doors like those typically seen in saloons in the old west. The sign over this store front / tavern appears to read: Obermeyer & Liebmanns.
The third lot north from the corner (the building with the peaked roof and dark windows: 111-113 Kent Avenue) is the establishment of Henry Lonse, who was the proprietor of a wagon shop. Apparently, (by reading the signage on the front of the building), he has now expanded to the repair of auto bodies & trucks as well as wagons.
City of New York, Bureau of Engineering - 1924 Aerial Photo
Here comes Tom Hendrickson again, this time with a doozey! He located in the NYPL Digital Archives, an aerial photo of Brooklyn and Manhattan, which including the Williamsburg neighborhood. Fortunately, this map was "zoomable", albeit in quadrants. I enlarged the North 3rd through North 12th areas and stitched the quadrants together in MS Paint.
This map is rather large but quite detailed, so I didn't want to compress it and lose the detail and place here. So, I gave it it's own page. Click on the small map below, if you wish to view the large version. By the way, this is one of the first aerial photos of New York City, and is part of the Fairchild Aerial Survey series.
Fairchild Aerial Survey Photo - 1929 Aerial Photo
Joe Roborecky located and submitted the following image, which is a Fairchild Aerial Survey photo from 1929. This photo is an oblique view, compared to the direct overhead 1924 Aerial Photo in above chapter. He located this image in the NYPL Digital Archives and I enlarged the appropriate area and stitched the sections together in MS Paint.
In this 1929 photo, we can see a steam locomotive peaking out of the Austin Nichols building, and blocking the sidewalk up by North 4th Street. There is another steam locomotive in the PRR North 4th Street Yard (but this is in all likelihood, not a BEDT loco.)
We see that the Brooklyn Cooperage building has been razed (which was still standing five years earlier) and the railyard that took its place is already in service. The NYC Subway airshaft for the BMT 14th Street - Canarsie Line has been built at the foot of North 7th Street, but the bulkhead trackage that we have come to know in later years is not yet built. It appears one of the original Palmers Dock piersheds is still in the process of being razed to the right of this airshaft.
Oddly, I would have expected to see more locomotives in this photo, but there are not. Also, the enginehouse has not yet been built at the foot of North 8th Street, but we can see a locomotive stored at this part of the property. I believe this to be #8, as it appears the saddletank is off (saddletank locomotives have tall domes on top of their boilers to accommodate the height of the saddletank). These domes are visible on top of this object, and as we have seen in a photo, this locomotive was out of service around this time and not scrapped until ca. 1933.
Also, on North 9th Street at Kent Avenue, a wood fence (left of the boxcars) is erected around a building foundation under construction. I believe this to be the "new" BEDT office building under construction.
There is a significant amount of flat cars with some sort of commodity both at the North 7th Street gantry, as well as at the North 9th Street Pier Yard and on a carfloat at the North 9th Street float bridge.
This photo is rather large and quite detailed, so I did not want to compress it and lose the detail and place here. So, I gave it its own page. I highly suggest you compare both the 1924 and 1929 images to see the progress. Take note, they are both large files and take a few moments to load.
1929 - E. Belcher Hyde Maps
(north is top left)
While the lower map accurately denotes the locations and track leads to the float bridges, the upper map does not. Both are from the same volume and date.
From these maps we can now compare the expansion of trackage that took place under the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal. The Austin Nichols building is now shown between North 3rd and North 4th Streets (having been completed in 1915). This "new" trackage is now in place south of North 4th Street as well as a float bridge just south of the foot of North 4th Street. As it was just south of the end of the street, it was referred to as the North 3rd Street float bridge and so as not to be confused with Pennsylvania RR's North 4th Street facility.
The Austin Nichols construction appears to have dramatically increased trackage between North 3rd and North 4th Streets as far east as Berry Street. To gain access to the North 3rd Street / Austin Nichols trackage from the original yards and without "touching" Pennsylvania trackage, we can now see the North 3rd Street trackage and yards is accessed through the mid-block transverse alley between North 4th and North 5th Streets and between Kent and Wythe Avenues (tax block #2341). This alley was called "the tunnel" by locomotive engineers.
The Austin Nichols building has both an outside three track yard (3A Yard) on the north face of the building, and indoor "run through tracks" that enter on the west end of the building on the bulkhead and off the pier tracks built for Austin Nichols (3P yard). Two of the three outside tracks cross Kent Avenue, with a spur splitting off of the north track and turning north to go through the transverse alley mentioned above, for access to North 5th Street trackage and the northern Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal yards. The two outside tracks continue east on the north edge of tax block #2349 for car storage (north part of 3B Yard), but do not cross Wythe Avenue.
The indoor tracks had an elaborate system of trackside conveyors to move freight throughout the building. Upon exiting the east end of the Austin Nichols building, the tracks cross Kent Avenue and proceed east through the center of tax block #2349 (south part of 3B Yard) as well and do not cross Wythe Avenue either. However, a spur off that northern track splits off and proceeds to cross Wythe Avenue at which this spur gives service to Schrier Brothers Paper and Lehigh Bernstein bed manufacturing, located between North 3rd and North 4th Streets, and Wythe Avenue and Berry Street (tax block 2350). This is now the eastern most end of North 3rd Street trackage.
Pennsylvania RR trackage along the south side of North 5th Street no longer appears and the Erie Freighthouse on North 5th Street between Kent and Wythe Avenues appears to have been demolished. Some trackage from the central north portion of the former West Shore yards between North 5 and North 6th Street (6A Yard), between the bulkhead and Kent Avenue, (tax block #2332) has been removed for the construction of the North 5th Street Freighthouse.
Proceeding east along North 5th Street, three tracks cross Kent Avenue, with the southern most track turning south to meet the track at the transverse alley. The two remaining tracks would continue to run east along the south side of tax block 2333 and along North 5th Street to cross Wythe Avenue. The northern track would serve the meat packers and the southern most track would go on to split in a four track stub yard with service to a new coal dock, perhaps to replace one the one that stood at North 9th and Kent Avenue.
The Brooklyn Cooperage building between North 6th and North 7th Streets and the bulkhead and Kent Avenue has been demolished, and the land used for an extensive railyard (6A Yard), and it appears a couple of tracks in the North 7th Street yard (7A yard) between the rubber factory and the bulkhead were removed as well. There are also changes in track configuration in the North 8th and North 9th Street (8A and 9A) yards.
Port Series Track Maps
More accurate track layout diagrams can be seen below, which are from the Corp of Engineers "Port Series" maps. The first one (directly below) is the 1934 edition, with other subsequent editions following in chronological order. These are the 1934, 1942, 1953, 1965 editions, and the J. Roborecky revision to the 1965 edition (bringing it to reflect trackage changes from 1968 to 1983). The only Port Series map I lack at this time, is the 1924 edition. We must thank Tom Flagg for making the 1942 and 1953 editions available from his archives. Float bridge locations are denoted as solid black triangles above the numbers on the maps.
1934 edition - Port Series Map
(north is right)
In the 1934 edition map immediately above; the enginehouse was located at the end of the four tracks under the word TERM under key #228 in the top map. Key #235 is the PRR float bridge and yard, and note there is no physical trackage connection between the BEDT and PRR trackage in the North 4th Street Yard.
There are five active float bridges on this map: BEDT North 3rd Street (#237); PRR North 4th Street (#235); BEDT North 5th Street (#233); BEDT North 6th Street (#231) and BEDT North 9th Street (#226). Furthermore, there is no trackage north of North 10th Street. Take exceptional note of the extensive yard trackage within the North 6th through North 9th Street area west of Kent Avenue (6A, 7A and 8A yards), and this map reflects the largest amount of yard trackage that would exist on the BEDT.
There are three tracks that run down the center of the North 9 and North 10th Street block (long axis) from the bulkhead (between the North 9th Street floatbridge and the North 9th Pier Yard), to Kent Avenue. The middle track (the lead track) now crosses Kent Avenue toward Wythe Avenue. The northern track were used to service the North 10th Street freighthouse respectively and ended before crossing Kent Avenue (and splitting into two tracks again) The southern track was for yard service and did not cross Kent Avenue either.
Notice there are no tracks that extend north of the North 10th Street freighthouse, and the basin at the foot of North 10th Street (northeast of #225).
1942 edition - Port Series Map
(north is right)
In the 1942 edition of the Port Series maps seen above, you can begin to see the gradual decline of yard trackage taking effect.
In this map, take notice that the North 3rd Street float bridge is not listed. This will become an unusual occurrence, as it is listed in the 1929 Bromley map and the 1934 Port Series Map, disappears from this map and is shown again in the 1953 edition Port Map. Was the North 3rd Street float bridge out of service for a period of time, or did an Corp of Engineer forget to list it?
The subway airshaft for the BMT 14th Street - Canarsie subway line is shown in this map (which opened for service in 1924), but oddly this airshaft is not shown in the future editions of the Port Series maps. On the North 7th / North 8th Street block bounded by the bulkhead and Kent Avenue, much of the yard trackage has been removed and several new structures and in place, with trackage abutting the west faces of those structures, while two tracks run down in between those structures, which were part of the original yard trackage. There are new structures as well on the north edge of North 9th Street with trackage abutting the west face of the building.
Notice the reduction of trackage in the North 7th "A" yard (west of Kent Avenue). Several structures now exist at this location with a two track siding running down an open air "alley" with structures on either side.
There are also some changes to track layout in the North 9th "A" yard (west of Kent Avenue); as the several block long sidings were removed, and buildings erected in their place, and there is now a short two track siding butting up to the west face of the building.
There were some trackage additions. You can also note that trackage now crosses and extends north of North 10th Street, but ends at North 11 before actually crossing that street. Also, the basin at the foot of North 10th Street is now filled in, and North 10th Street is now a little longer. There is a discrepancy in this map as that northernmost track (running east-west) on the North 10th Street Pier (#240) does not connect to the tracks south of it, and as it comes off the pier, it turn north to head towards North 11th Street and between the two buildings.
Fairchild Aerial Survey Photo - 1949 Aerial Photo
Paul Strubeck located and submitted the following image in the Digital Collections of the New York State Archives, Museum & Library.
Even though Paul, Joe Roborecky and myself have visited this website many times in the past, we failed to come across this image, which is a Fairchild Aerial Survey Photo from 1949. This photo is an oblique view, similar to the 1929 issue above but looking north instead of south. The resolution is remarkable and I enlarged the appropriate areas and stitched the sections together in MS Paint.
In this 1949 photo, we can see (from
foreground to background):
The North 4th Street BEDT float bridge ("3 Bridge"), Pennsylvania RR North 4th Street float bridge, and the North 5th, North 6th Street and North 9th Street float bridges;
Many carfloats of both interchange and station type;
The complete structure of the Pennsylvania North 4th Street Freight Station;
The "tunnel" track leading from North 4th to North 5th Streets;
Not one but two steam locomotives working the North 6th Street float bridge leads (definitely #16 and either #15 or #14),
A oversize load (long bright object) just to the right of the North 6th Street float bridge
By the enginehouse, we see a locomotive sitting on the "garden track", most likely #11.
A locomotive (difficult to see) on the enginehouse service track,
Barely seen above and behind the roof of a brightly colored boxcar on the North 9th Street float bridge lead, are the domes and smokestack of another locomotive. (Look for the left (west) building corner of the North 10th Street Freight House).
This photo, like the other aerial photos, is rather large but quite detailed, and I didn't want to resize and compress it and lose the detail and place on this page. So, I gave it its own page where it can be viewed in great detail. I highly suggest you compare this 1949 images with both the 1924 and 1929 images to see the progress. Take note, they are all large files and take a few moments to load.
1953 edition - Port Series Map
(north is right)
In this 1953 edition of the Port Series Maps, we see that all four BEDT float bridges: North 3rd Street (#186), North 5th Street (#183), North 6th Street (#181) and North 9th Street (#177), and the PRR float bridge at North 4th Street (#185) as well, are still in service.
It appears that some of the PRR yard trackage is beginning to thin out, as well the removal of the thin "finger" pier jutting out west from the actual terminal building (#250 in the 1942 map).
Track additions consist of a two track siding almost directly below the North 7th Street subway airshaft and a stub track with one car capacity leading to the back of the building on the south side of North 8th Street.
Extensive trackage is now in place north of North 10th Streets with many spurs and small yard between North 10th and North 11th Street almost by the bulkhead, while another track transverses midblock and splits to into two tracks, one of which turns east to continue to Kent Avenue (after splitting again into parallel tracks) and the other track remaining north to cross North 11th Street and continue to North 12th Street, with that track splitting in three spurs.
1965 edition - Port Series Map
Port Series Track Map: Kent Ave, Brooklyn, NY; 1965 edition
(north is right).
On the left side of this 1965 edition of the Port Map as seen above, you can see Nepco Oil (key #141) has replaced American Sugar Refining between North 2nd and 3rd Streets.
The North 3rd Street float bridge next to the former Austin Nichols building (key #140), which now houses Federal Business Machine (not reflected in map); has been removed from service (no black triangle), but the pier trackage remains.
The Pennsylvania RR float bridge at the North 4th Street Terminal has also been removed from service, as well as the trackage having been removed from the yard, yet the pier shed remains and is marked for PRR. However, according to a New York Times articles submitted by Tom Hendrickson, states that the Pennsylvania Railroad sold the North 4th Street Terminal property to the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal on May 7, 1954.
The Bulk Flour Terminal has been constructed (in 1964) on the southwest corner of North 9th Street and Kent Avenue and some of the tracks in the North 8th Street Yard west of Kent Avenues have been lengthened to accommodate it.
The North 10th Street freighthouse appears
to have shortened in length to half a block (southside of North 10th Street,
west of Kent Avenue).
1966 - 1983 - revised from Port Series Map
(north is right)
In this map as seen above, the 1965 edition of the Port Series Map has been revised by the author as directed by J. Roborecky, to reflect changes in the trackage after the last edition of Port Series Maps were released. The map above reflects most changes over the period from 1966 through 1983. The revisions are numbered in red on the map and noted below. Important structures and landmarks have also been noted and / or drawn in on this map, even though most of those structures predate this revision.
The pier with trackage (1) and the float bridge "3 Bridge" behind the Austin Nichols building now occupied Federal Business Machine has been removed.
Track additions: Independent Scrap has relocated from North 11 Street to the property of the former PRR North 4th Street Terminal yard, ca. 1966. A diagonal track "4A7" (2) and siding "4A8" (3) being installed so BEDT could bring in gondolas for loading. Independent Scrap by the way, would receive several contracts to scrap New York City Transit Authority subway cars.
Also evident is the elimination of trackage on North 5th Street between Kent & Wythe Avenues, and the "zig zag" (4) siding running through the middle of the block ("the tunnel") bounded by Kent & Wythe Avenues and North 4th and 5th Streets. (former site of Brooklyn Cooperage).
On an unknown date, the North 5th Street float bridge was removed from active service, yet remains abandoned in place (5). This leaves only two float bridges in active service at the BEDT Kent Avenue facility: North 6th Street (key #135) and North 9th Street (key #131).
The "below grade tracks" (for Trailer On Flat Car "TOFC" unloading / loading?) in the North 8th Street Yard are noted. These sub-grade tracks existed prior to this date and are not a change. Also noted is the travelling gantry. This gantry has been in place for many decades as well and survived to this date, and therefore its location is noted in this map.
There were also several changes in the North 9th Street Yard by this date. 9A1 track, was reconfigured to tie in to the lead track with the turnout being located between the crossing diamond and the 8P tracks (6). This reconfiguration however is believed to have existed well before this revision date; when a new structure (7) adjoining the North 9th Street freighthouse, was built for the purpose of storing rolls of paper for newsprint.
Joe Roborecky maintains the turnout location on the Port maps are erroneous (until this revision), and this turnout location is actually accurate back to at least 1954 and possibly prior to this date; as this turnout location is reflected in the1954 historicaerials.com aerial photo. (If you wish to view this aerial photo, you must type in zip code 11211 to access the Kent Avenue area, then pan left (west) towards the East River, and then set your date accordingly.)
At the western end of the North 10th Street freighthouse, a covered steel platform (8) from a station carfloat was placed here and parallel to 9A5 track. This platform was used by Semolina Haulage Co. to transfer 80 to 100 pound bags of semolina directly from boxcars into truck trailers. It is believed that this station carfloat platform was salvaged from the conversion of Carfloat 26 when that carfloat was converted to the centerpipe arrangement for use at the Schaefer Brewery.
It should be noted that this carfloat platform now occupies the location where a "six pack" of cement silos stood. It is believed these concrete silos did not exist long, as no aerial photos in historicaerials.com (1954, 1966 or 1980 versions) show these silos from the air nor are these silos reflected on either the 1965 or 1953 Port Maps. Yet we know for fact from viewing an R. Taylor photograph of locomotive #14 dated April 12, 1963, that these towers were located here.
Also around this era, the eastern portion of the North 10th Street freighthouse (fronting on Kent Avenue) (9) was reconstructed.
It is unknown on what date service had terminated for the North 10th, 11th and 12th Street trackage or whether it was open until the end of operations in 1983. It remains shown on this map until that date is ascertained.
Office of Terminal Engineer (BEDT) - 1962
Tom Flagg furnished several maps to me upon a research get together we had on 10 June 2009. The maps received pertaining to the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal were especially important, as they were issued by the Office of the Terminal Engineer of the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal.
What this means is, these are maps of the railroad and property issued and revised by the railroad; and not an independant source as would be the Army Corp of Engineer Port Terminal Series issues or Property Maps.
When a track or structure revision took place, it was noted on these maps. Therefore, these maps are considered to be of the highest accuracy out of any of the other map issues on the website.
This last revison date for the issue here April 1962. Please click on the image below to view a large scale high resolution version. This large scale version is quite big, so please be patient while it opens. Use the back arrow on your browser to return you here, as there is no link to return you to this page.
Office of Terminal Engineer (BEDT) - 1962
courtesy of T. Flagg
added 13 June 2009
Office of Terminal Engineer (BEDT) - 1969
As with the 1962 version above, Tom Flagg furnished this beauty (among others) to me upon a research get together we had on 10 June 2009. The maps for the BEDT were especially important, as they were issues by the Office of the Terminal Engineer of the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal.
What this means is, these are maps of the railroad and property issued and revised by the railroad; and not an independent source as would be the Army Corp of Engineer Port Terminal Series issues or Property Maps. When a track or structure revision took place, it was noted on these maps. Therefore, these maps are considered to be of the highest accuracy out of any of the other map issues on the website.
This last revision date for this issue is December 1969. For the time being, this is the most recent (latest) revision date we know of, even though BEDT still operated until 1983.
This map is probably the most useful out of all the maps, as the track designations (5A2, 8P1, etc.) are mostly legible as are the structure dimensions. I intend to work with Joe Roborecky to make those designations that are currently illegible, readable once again. So if that is what you desire, a "cleaned" version of this map is available and viewable in the next chapter below.
Please click on the image below to view a large scale high resolution version. This large scale version is quite large, so please be patient while it opens. Use the back arrow on your browser to return you here, as there is no link to return you to this page.
Office of Terminal Engineer (BEDT) - 1969
courtesy of T. Flagg
added 13 June 2009
Office of Terminal Engineer (BEDT) - 1969 (cleaned)
This map, is a cleaned up and slightly larger (150%) version of the original above for better legibility and this version better shows the track designators, construction materials, dimensions and usage of the structures. Some of the track designators, where illegible on the 1969 map, were referenced from the 1962 version; so in actuality this "cleaned" version is the combination of both 1962 and 1969 maps.
Operational notes from Joe Roborecky (retired BEDT engineer) are included. Locations and markings for city sewers, drainage culverts and other underground items were removed.
Please click on the link below to view this map. Like the others above, this version is a large file size, so please be patient while it opens. Use the back arrow on your browser to return you here, as there is no link to return you to this page.
Office of Terminal Engineer (BEDT) - 1969
courtesy of T. Flagg
added 13 June 2009
Track Map North 5th Street Vicinity - ca. 1980
Below is a track map of the North 5th Street vicinity, provided by Joe Roborecky.
This map is essentially a close up of the North 5th Street "A" Yard (#135, #136 and #137 in the Port Series map of 1965), and appears to be copy of the 1969 Terminal Engineer Map shown above.
The origin of this map is and interesting backstory. Independent Scrap was seen moving gondolas in their yard with a payloader. This was not supposed to occur as it prevents engineers from earning their wages. Therefore, a grievence was filed to BEDT management by a BEDT engineer. This initial claim was subsequently denied by BEDT management.
Upon that, the Brotherhood of Locomotive Engineer appealed the denial to the highest designated officer on BEDT, and this was denied. Then BLE took this matter to the National Railroad Adjustment Board to establish a Public Law Board on the BEDT Property. The carrier and union then select a neutral member from a provided list and a three person board is established. This board consists of one carrier member (i.e.: BEDT officer, in this case Mr. Van Grace who was director of employee relations BEDT/NYD); a union member (i.e.: an employee or union representative: Mr. Joe Crawford int'l vp of BLE), and the neutral member (Mr. T. H. O'Brien).
The carrier and union make submissions to the Public Law Board neutral member containing their reasons why decisions should prevail in their favor. Upon that, the neutral member issues a decision. This map was part of the BEDT Officer's submission showing the location of Independent Scrap and their property, and had to be furnished to the neutral member and likewise the union board members, of which Joe was one. Just for closure purposes, the Public Law Board neutral member found in favor of the engineers.
This map, which appears almost identical to the 1969 BEDT Terminal Engineer Map seen above and even appears to be a copy of same, yet contains some minor but significant differences in track designations: track 5 A 11 (1969) vs. track 5 A 10 (1980).
Why this is, is not known, but if we were to hazard a guess, there might be subsequent revision issues after the 1969 Terminal Engineer Map, which have not yet surfaced.
Track Map: North 5th Street and bulkhead, Brooklyn, NY; ca.
(north is top)
If one takes note, you can see a segment of the diagonal track "4-A-7" at the bottom of the map, which was the track for Independent Scrap on the former site of the Pennsylvania Railroad's North 4th Street Terminal.
Kent Avenue - South 3rd Street
Very little is known about this yard. After referencing several maps, both E. Belcher Hyde (property) and Port Terminal (trackage), no trackage is shown in either. However, it is very clearly stated in the June 1952 issue of the Railroad Magazine article "Railroad Across the River", written by Melvin Krampf; in where it says:
"There is a smaller yard at Pidgeon Street, Long Island City, car capacity 100; another at South Third Street, capacity 100, ..."
Also located in the February 1964 edition of International Thomson Transport Press, (the publisher of the "Official Railway Guide") is an advertisement of the "Union Freight Terminals (BEDT) In New York Harbor" and it lists South 3rd Street Terminal. (see below - circled)
Coincidentally, the Domino Sugar Refinery is located at this specific location as well. Therefore it is the hypothesis of this author that it is entirely plausible for a yard and possibly a float bridge to once have existed at this location. As to the service dates for this particular yard location, they are unknown but according to the article, it was in service in 1952 and listed in the 1964 advertisement.
Later Domino Sugar freight interchange would consist of platform floats being moored directly to the bulkhead and loaded / unloaded in the empty boxcar / bridge method as described below in BEDT Memoirs - Domino.
Thanks to Tom Flagg, in furnishing a "Report on Present Operations and Future Prospects of the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal, dated May 11, 1956; clarifies the use of the "South 3rd Street Yard":
"At South 3rd Street, Brooklyn, the plant of the American Sugar Refinery is served by a dock-to-float loading operation and is classified as a yard for tariff purposes."
Therefore, as it is now understood that the so called "yard" at South 3rd Street was not a railyard, but a dockside mooring location of carfloats with a capacity of 100 cars (i.e.: average 5 car floats x 20 cars each = 100 cars).
|| Palmer's Dock also
constructed a railyard located at Pidgeon Street in the Long Island City
section of Queens. However "small" this yard actually was, (and not accurately
represented in the 1929 Belcher Hyde map below), this yard would see a great
deal of traffic from the customers located here (see list below).
The Pidgeon Street property consisted of 160 acres on the north side of Newtown Creek. By the way: Pidgeon spelled in this particular case (with the 'd') is the correct spelling for this thoroughfare and not spelled conventionally, i.e.: "pigeon".
Both the Brooklyn Eagle and the New York Times carried an article, (see images left and right) announcing the purchase of the Pidgeon Street property in June of 1899.
Apparently, when Lowell Palmer purchased the property, there was a partnership deal between the Long Island Railroad and himself.
| Not only that, but there apparently
was a joint LIRR / Palmer's Dock plan to develop the freight depot that
was to be built at that location.
Nothing more is ever mentioned of the Long Island Rail Road / Palmer association in later years however and as it being well documented, the Long Island Rail Road would transfer freight through their own Long Island City / 21st Street Street float bridge facility & yards.
What is particularly interesting in the
New York Times Deed Transfer announcement (seen to the right), is the mention
of "warfare" between the Pennsylvania Railroad and Palmer's Dock.
|| The railyard itself would open in
1906, one year after Lowell Palmer left the operation to the Havemeyer's,
and the same year the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal name was
The primary customer in the beginning would be the New York Sugar Refinery, which would in time become National Sugar, the manufacturer of the "Jack Frost" brand of sugar. National Sugar was part of the Havemeyer sugar holdings.
In later years, the Brooklyn Eastern District
Terminal and this yard would go on to service a Daily News newspaper printing
plant, a beverage distributor, and other smaller industries.
Here is a 1919 E. Belcher Hyde property map of the Pidgeon Street area. This is the earliest property map I have been able to locate online of the area thus far.
E. Belcher Hyde Map, 1919
(north is up)
The following image is a Fairchild Aerial Survey Photo dated 1924. While the shadow of the National Sugar Refinery building hides the trackage running down the portion of Pidgeon Street west of Front Street, it does show that trackage did not yet extend east of West Avenue. The float bridge and finger pier can be see to the left of the building shadow.
1924 - Fairchild Aerial Survey Photo
NYPL Digital Archives
added 31 May 2009
The following map of the Pidgeon Street yard track layout can be seen below. It is from the 1942 issue of the Army Corp of Engineers Port Series Maps, and shows the track arrangement after the trackage was expanded east. (Front Street has been renamed 2nd Avenue and while unmarked, West Avenue has been renamed 5th Street likewise Dock Street is now 56th Avenue. Pidgeon Street has become 55th Avenue and Flushing Avenue would become 54th Avenue yet retain both names on later street atlases).
Two blocks inland (east) from the East River, the Pidgeon Street Yard was located directly across the street (54th Avenue / Flushing Avenue) from the Long Island Rail Road yard. As close (approximately 80 - 100 feet) as these two yards would be located to each other, (and like the PRR North 4th Street yard located on Kent Avenue), the BEDT and LIRR never were nor ever would be physically connected.
Port Series Track Map: Pidgeon Street, Long Island City, Queens, NY; 1942 edition
(north is up)
Pidgeon Street Yard - October 11, 1943
(click on image above for enlargement)
W. J. Madden photo
added 22 February 2011
Without a doubt, one of the two finest photos of the Pidgeon Street Yard of the BEDT! Obviously taken from one of the upper story windows of the Jack Frost Sugar Refinery, looking east. Several interesting facets of this photo include:
Acquired several months later, is the companion photo to the image above. Taken the same day, this image is zoomed in on the yard, and shows some slight differences: Another gondola has been placed by the coal co, another truck is unloading from a freight car, and the Vernon Avenue drawbridge is raised to permit a tugboat to transit.
Pidgeon Street Yard - October 11, 1943
W. J. Madden photo
added 22 February 2011
The following image; dated 1951, looking west and while rather grainy; shows the the BEDT Pidgeon Street Yard, which still closely conforms with the 1943 photo above. Note the lack of the covered unloading shelter.
1951 - Pidgeon Street (Newtown Creek)
Fairchild Aerial Survey Map
NYSPL Digital Collections
added 31 May 2009
According to the Coverdale & Colpitts Report, freight traffic destined for Pidgeon Street customers was not directly received from other carriers and terminals at the Pidgeon Street float bridge, but in fact had to go through the Kent Avenue Yard first. It was here that inbound cars destined for Pidgeon Street were pulled from inbound carfloat, sorted, classified, re-assembled and reloaded upon a carfloat for Pidgeon Street.
One of recommendations that the Coverdale & Colpitts Report makes to the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal administration, is for them revise this policy and eliminate handling the inbound freight twice and ship it directly from the mainland Class 1 terminals to Pidgeon Street. From what this author has been able to gather, this recommendation was not heeded, and the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal continued "doing things their way".
In discussing this policy with Joe Roborecky, he makes a valid point: no matter where the Pidgeon Street traffic was sorted, either at Pidgeon Street or Kent Avenue, BEDT would would have to handle the freight cars twice. As the Class 1 railroad's simply forwarded all freight cars destined for the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal, it was not the Class 1 railroads' responsibility to sort the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal's cars according to BEDT's individual terminals, in those respective Class 1 yards in New Jersey (unless of course the BEDT was willing to pay the Class 1 railroads to do this).
As not all freight cars for BEDT were destined for Pidgeon Street, and as Pidgeon Street traffic would be coming from a multitude of Class 1's (CRRNJ, WS, NYC, PRR, etc), it would not be economically feasible to load only those one or two cars from that particular Class 1 railroad onto a carfloat specific for Pidgeon Street, then transfer that carfloat to the next Class 1, load their two or three cars, so on and so forth.. So, it was simpler, cost effective and less labor intensive to send everything to Kent Avenue (which had the room to classify the cars whereas Pidgeon Street did not) and let BEDT crews sort out the traffic according to desitnation (Pidgeon Street, Wallabout Market Terminal, Brooklyn Navy Yard, etc).
According to both the New York Central Railroad Terminal Facilities in the Port of New York Map of 1943 and the 1965 Port of New York Authority Harbor Terminals Map, the Pidgeon Street Yard was "Car Load Delivery" only.
All things considered, the Pidgeon Street location would have the second longest lifespan (next to the original Kent Avenue, North 5th through North 9th Street yards) and the Pidgeon Street Terminal would close permanently in 1977 (possibly 1978). As of July 2008, the Pidgeon Street float bridge is the only surviving float bridge of the BEDT. Please refer to Surviving Float Bridges section in the Float Bridges chapter, to view images.
The "second" Pidgeon Street Float Bridge
In September 2009, Dave Keller sent over a photo from a recently acquired collection. It is a unique photo of the Pidgeon Street float bridge to say the least. The reason for this being, the Pidgeon Street float bridge was not photographed as often as the float bridges at Kent Avenue would be. A few days later; Joe Roborecky, in his usual pursuit of detail; noticed that the float bridge in the 1958 photo is not the same float bridge as the float bridge in the photos I took in July 2008!
Compare for yourself:
Based on this new photographic evidence; it is now apparent that the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal found it necessary to replace the Pidgeon Street float bridge. This replacement obviously took place between 1958 and 1976, when that location was taken out of service.
Both Joe and myself have compared photos of the float bridges located at Kent Avenue to determine if any of those float bridges were relocated to Pidgeon Street. Of the other Kent Avenue float bridges that were "surplussed" due to downsizing of operations, i.e.: North 5th Street - (a pony plate girder) and North 3th Street - (pony truss with tapered ends and small diagonal brace gusset plates), neither matches the design of the second Pidgeon Street float bridge seen above. As North 9th and North 6th Street float bridges remained in service until 1983, they therefore could not have been relocated to Pidgeon Street.
Therefore, it currently remains undetermined from whom or where this "second" Pidgeon Street float bridge was obtained from or whether it was constructed new, as well as the reason for the replacement. It is a safe (but not confirmed) conclusion that if the float bridge in the 1958 photo is in fact the original float bridge installed at Pidgeon Street when the yard opened in 1906, it was definitely nearing the end of its service life by 1958, as research of other facilities shows most steel float bridges in the New York Harbor area were changed out around the fifty year mark.
Pidgeon Street would be renamed 55th Avenue, and the thoroughfare cease to exist all together when the area was reconstructed circa 1980's.
Wallabout Market Terminal
On the inside cover of the BEDT matchbook I own, the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal lists a facility a "Market Terminal" Wallabout, Brooklyn NY. The phone number listed is the same for Kent Avenue. Quite honestly, until "reading" this matchbook, I forgot about this terminal. The BEDT would be the last and shortest lived terminal to occupy the Wallabout Market area.
In December 2008, Joe Roborecky located the following Port of New York Authority New York Harbor Terminals Map from 1940. This map shows us the locations of the various terminals and stations in the Wallabout Basin with a great degree of clarity, including the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal's Wallabout Market Terminal.
Port of New York Authority - NY Harbor Terminals Map, 1940
(north is up) .
On 13 March 2010, Joe Roborecky found this gem online:
Brooklyn Daily Eagle - July 11, 1935 .
This is a very interesting article as it not only contains the arrangements of Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal with the City of New York, as well as the cost of the float bridge installation.
On 21 March 2011, I received another "care package" from Jon Franz. Over the past several years, Jon has been generously sending to me various images, documents and "what have you" pertaining to many of the offline terminals covered in this website. Jon has always sent great material and this package was no exception.
In this envelope was an original printed and bound Contract between the City of New York and the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal dated November 16, 1935. This Contract (bound in a page booklet form with attached fold out map). This contract specifies the details of the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal Wallabout Market, including such information as: length of contract, preferred operating times, who shall furnish lighting, responsibility and maintenance of the trackage, float bridge construction, etc.
Also included was a copy of the Sunday, May 3, 1936 New York Times. The opening ceremony of the Railway Terminal at Wallabout Market garnered front page, including images. One image shows the opening ceremonies and the other image (which is more dramatic to our interests) is of Mayor Fiorello LaGuardia at the controls of BEDT #15! As Johnny Carson use to say, "you just can't make this stuff up!"
I urge you to click on the following map, which will take you to scans of the contract booklet where you will be able to read the details of that contract, as well as a large scale version of the included map. Scans of the New York Times newspaper front page article of May 3, 1936 covering the dedication ceremony can be seen as well. A link at the bottom of the page will return you here.
As seen in the map below,which is a fold out adhered to the back cover of the contract, we can now understand that the City of New York razed the market stalls / structures bounded by Apple, Clinton, Flushing & Metz Avenues. Following this demolition, it is now apparent the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal installed team tracks at this location, so that vendors could sell their applicable produce directly from the boxcar doors.
This makes sense, because as stated in the Contract, the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal was to make all effort to perform switching while the Market was idle, which was between the hours 4 p.m and 4 a.m. (winter) and 4 p.m. to midnight (summer). This no doubt required the BEDT to schedule a "night trick" to switch the Wallabout Market Terminal, of which we already know the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal was already equipped to do so as it operated around the clock.
Also of particular interest, is the fact that some of the trackage is shown as "deferred" (shown in blue). At this time it is not known why construction of this trackage was put off or whether it was even constructed. The alignment of this deferred trackage shows it to be laid on the west side of Fleeman Avenue, and thereby closer to the market stalls / structures (than to the piers on the east side of Fleeman Avenue). Therefore the trackage appears to have been intended to provide service for those market stalls bounded by Fleeman Avenue, D Street, Washington and Metz Avenues.
It should be taken into consideration that this track shown along Fleeman Avenue would have passed in front of most of the bulkhead and piers occupied by the Class 1 railroads which composed the Wallabout Union Freight Terminal (Erie, Baltimore & Ohio, Lehigh Valley and New York Central Railroads). It is left to postulate whether the competitive Class 1 railroads mentioned, might have opposed this deferred trackage as it undoubtedly would have given the BEDT an advantage in that it would be able to deliver the freight car right to the door of market stalls.
Jon Franz took the time to put together a timeline
of the Wallabout Market which I include
|October 1884||Wallabout Market established by the City of Brooklyn, on land leased
from the Federal Government
adjacent to the New York Naval Shipyard (a/k/a Brooklyn Navy Yard)
|November 1891||Wallabout Market property sold by the U.S. Government to the City of Brooklyn.|
|1894-1896||Permanent structures for Wallabout Market incorporating a Dutch look designed by William Tubby, are erected.|
|ca. 1900||Wallabout Market recognized as the largest wholesale produce & processed food market in the United States.|
|18 January 1935||New York Department of Docks authorizes establishment of a freight terminal to directly serve Wallabout Market.|
|16 November 1935||Agreement signed between the City of New York and the Brooklyn Eastern
whereby the BEDT will construct and operate a float yard and team tracks to serve the Wallabout Market.
|02 May 1936||BEDT freight terminal "Wallabout Terminal Market" opens.|
|01 April 1941||U. S. Government files "notice of condemnation and declaration of taking"
the Wallabout Market property for expansion of Brooklyn Navy Yard.
|14 June 1941||Wallabout Market closed for expansion of Brooklyn Navy Yard.|
|10 September 1941||A photograph taken by R. Wingard on September 10,
1941, shows BEDT #15 operating at Wallabout Market Terminal.
The reason for this discrepancy in dates has not been discovered as yet.
The first railroad terminal to take up residence in the Wallabout Basin vicinity was the Delaware, Lackawanna & Western Railroad's Wallabout Terminal (I have a separate page on that operation which may be read here: Wallabout Terminal (DLW). A floatbridge was installed and small railyard constructed at this Delaware Lackawanna & Western RR location. Neighboring piers to the south would come to be the "Wallabout Union Freight Station", with Baltimore & Ohio, Pennsylvania, Lehigh Valley and New York Central Railroads occupying several piers. These would be pier stations only with no trackage or float bridge. South of that and at the very head of the basin, resided both an Erie freighthouse / pier station.
The "Wallabout Market Terminal" of the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal. This map shows that the Wallabout Market Terminal of the BEDT was Car Load Delivery Only (partially filled red circle) with float bridge. All the other terminals were Car Load and Less than Car Load (red triangle) and were actually pier station service, with no trackage (except for the D. L. & W. facility).
Tom Hendrickson, informed me on August 27, 2007 that he located mention of a 18 page souvenir program for the Official Opening of the BEDT Wallabout Market Freight Terminal on Saturday, May 2nd, 1936 at 10:00 a.m. We are trying to secure an image of the program.
While we knew the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal now had presence at the Wallabout Market, where exactly the float bridge at the Wallabout Terminal was actually located remained unknown. After engaging is some lengthy dialog on 06 May 2009 with Joe Roborecky and Tom Flagg, we narrowed down some possibilities as to the location of the BEDT Wallabout float bridge, but still had not been able to determine for fact where it was located exactly.
The very next day, in searching his vast collection of documents, Tom located the following image. It is an inspection report map for the Brooklyn Navy Yard and it is dated July 15, 1940. This map shows the exact location of the BEDT Wallabout Market Terminal float bridge. This report illustration also shows, very nicely, the arrangement of interchange for the BEDT float bridge and trackage in the Navy Yard. Note the connection was through the "terminal gate", as marked. This was a tall wood fence, which can be seen in photos on the Wallabout Union Freight Station webpage.
The presence of this fence makes sense, as it secures the Navy Yard property from Clinton Avenue, which was a public thoroughfare albeit a dead ended one! When this gate was closed, the Navy Yard perimeter would be secure, and allow both pedestrian and vehicle traffic to use the Clinton Avenue bulkhead without compromising the security of the Navy Yard. When opened, it allowed the BEDT to access Navy Yard trackage. It should be noted that this gate entrance and the ability of the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal to provide service if need be to the Brooklyn Navy Yard was a stipulation of the Contract.
This report also shows that the Brooklyn Navy Yard float bridge was still in place and Tom believes possibly still in use (since there are no notations to reflect otherwise). The only modification I made to this map, was to highlight the fence (in red) separating the Navy Yard from Clinton Avenue & the BEDT trackage.
Inspection Report Map for the Brooklyn Navy Yard - July 15, 1940
National Archives, New York City branch
courtesy of T. Flagg
added 07 May 2009
The map below, which is affixed to back cover of the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal / City of New York Contract, show in great detail the track layout for the Wallabout Terminal Market. You can click on the map below to review a large scale version. Please use the back arrow on your browser to return you here.
(East is up, North is left.)
J. Franz archives
added 22 March 2011
Before the addition of the aforementioned contract to this website, I had contacted and held a conversation with Mr. Ron Ziel in October 2008. He mentioned a photograph of a BEDT locomotive at the Wallabout Market Terminal taken September 10, 1941 in the archives of Frank Zahn. At the time of our conversation, neither of us knew that Mr. Zahn had passed away several weeks prior. Fortunately, his wife Lillian allowed me to procure the negative in question, as well as the remainder of Mr. Zahn offline terminal images.
From the date written on the negative envelope, we must conclude that the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal did not relinquish its presence at Wallabout Terminal until sometime after that date.
Wallabout Market Terminal - September 10, 1941
(intersection of Clinton Avenue and Metz Street, looking north)
R. Wingard photo
F. Zahn archives
added 13 Apr 2009
| I strongly believe this image above
to have been taken at the intersection of Clinton Avenue and Metz Street.
The reasons for this are based on the following:
In the enlargement see to left (taken from the 1941 photo above), a small sign under the awning of the building can be made out, just to the left of locomotive smokebox.
This sign (without any room for doubt), but partially blocked by the locomotive, says "Erie R".
This is in all probability the sign for the Erie Railroad Freight Station which was located on the corner of Clinton Avenue and Metz Street.
The structure housing the Erie Railroad Freight Depot / Freight House fronted on the eastern bulkhead of the Wallabout Basin as seen in the modified E. Belcher Hyde Property Map as tax block 8598 (in pink and magenta). The modifications to this map consist of sewer & water mains removed for clarity. The structures that have been faded out (tax blocks 2024 on the property map), were razed circa 1935 according to photographs in various digital images of New York Area libraries. The property was left open, yet paved for the open air market. Just six years later, even this newly improved market area was completely upsurped in the expansion of the Brooklyn Navy Yard.
In my opinion, this 1941 Wingard photograph is one of the most historically important images pertaining to the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal. It is, as far as it is known, the only photographic record of a Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal locomotive operating in the Wallabout Market Terminal. As Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal rail service was not long in duration at this location (1935 through 1941), one can understand why this photograph is important.
The photo below, courtesy of the Brian Merliss archives (brooklynpix.com); shows a Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal tugboat heading out the Wallabout Basin with a loaded carfloat. While the tugboats name cannot be seen, the sideboards on the carfloat are marked Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal. It appears this photo was taken from atop of a boxcar loaded aboard a station carfloat at the very head of the Wallabout Basin where the Erie Railroad Freight Station was located.
Wallabout Basin - February 1941
B. Merliss archives
added 24 Dec 2008
The BEDT Wallabout Market Terminal operated until very late in 1941 (sometime between September through November), at which time the remainder Wallabout Terminal property was taken over by the United States Government. The United States Government had declared on April 1, 1941 (in preparation for World War II?) that it was in the process of expanding the Brooklyn Navy Yard and that the properties of the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal, along with other tenants in the Wallabout Market; were apparently "bought out" by the United States Government. One by one as the tenants moved, their property would be seized and the structures razed.
It is understood by reading some of these lawsuits, that the Wallabout Terminal property was "annexed" (read: commandeered) by the United States Government and that there was little choice the individual tenants (including the BEDT) had about it, other than taking the Government money and moving on. When the Wallabout Property was annexed, the Navy Yard property boundaries were expanded to absorb this new addition of acreage. Several lawsuits were brought pertaining to payments, interest and and other assorted legal quibbling and some of these lawsuits extended into the 1950's.
There is currently a discrepancy between the dates of closure of Wallabout Terminal and the R. Wingard photo. By all accounts known, the Wallabout Terminal closed in June 14, 1941. Yet the Wingard photo is dated September 10, 1941. There are two hypotheses:
We know for fact that the United States Government
filed its "notice of condemnation and declaration of taking" on April 1,
1941. What we do not know is how long the tenants of the Wallabout Market
were given to vacate the property. It seems entirely appropriate under the
circumstances that they (the tenants) would be given a reasonable amount
of time to pack up their property and relocate it to a new
If these tenants were given 180 days (6 months), this could explain why BEDT #15 is seen switching Wallabout Market in the September 10, 1941 Wingard photo. As October 1 would have been 180 days from April 1, and this would allow BEDT to be still performing switching on September 10.
If this is the case, and as most of the produce vendors of the Wallabout Market relocated to the soon to be opened Brooklyn Terminal Market, which was located in Canarsie and opened in 1942 as the replacement venue for Wallabout Market. This new market was served by the Long Island Rail Road's Bay Ridge Branch, so it is then quite plausible that the boxcar (which may have contained furniture, supplies, refrigeration equipment, etc; from one or more of the tenants of the Wallabout Market) to be loaded onto a carfloat, floated to the Bay Ridge Yard, and where the LIRR could then take it to Brooklyn Terminal Market where it could be unloaded.
After the expansion of the Brooklyn Navy Yard, we know
& Colpitts Report, that the Brooklyn Eastern
District Terminal served the Brooklyn Navy Yard under exclusive contract,
renewable on a yearly basis; to provide carfloat service to and from the
Brooklyn Navy Yard and the Kent Avenue property (never directly from any
other carfloat terminal however). Also according to the Coverdale & Colpitts
Report, the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal received this exclusive contract
as a result of the BEDT Terminal formerly located at Wallabout
Despite the fact that in 1941, the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal did not have a yard or facility located in New Jersey; and the fact that none of the railroads that did have freight yards on the New Jersey side of the Hudson River (and of which could have transported freight directly from those yards to the Navy Yard), and of which these railroads (Pennsylvania, New York Central, Baltimore & Ohio, Lehigh Valley or Erie) had operated a pier station in the Wallabout Union Terminal, received this contract.
Therefore it appears the contract to carfloat cars to the Navy Yard was given to the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal in deference to the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminals' having to give up their Wallabout Market Terminal operation.
So, even after the other tenants and railroad's had to vacate Wallabout Market, the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal still had ongoing operations as part of the Government contract to provide service for the Navy Yard. With this possibility recognized, it is therefore likely that the Wingard image above can very well be of inbound construction supplies for the upcoming expansion for the Navy Yard, and not necessarily produce for vendors at the Wallabout Market.
New York "Brooklyn" Navy Yard
BEDT 16 on carfloat 21 at Brooklyn Navy Yard floatbridge - June 24, 1963
Beginning on an unknown date, but stated by Tom Flagg to have been learned in an interview he conducted with BEDT President M. McClelland in 1976, BEDT operations began at the Brooklyn Navy Yard in 1940/1941. Until the cessation of BEDT operations in 1983, the BEDT would carfloat to and from and operated in the Brooklyn Navy Yard.
According to the Coverdale & Colpitts Report, the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal served the Brooklyn Navy Yard under exclusive contract, renewable on a yearly basis. It is understood that this contract was awarded to the BEDT as the result of that prior to World War II, the BEDT had maintained a railyard on Wallabout Creek adjacent to the Navy Yard. Ascertained through other documents, that just prior to the onset of World War II, the Government annexed all adjoining properties to expand the Navy Yard, with the BEDT Wallabout property included. In lieu of "losing" their Wallabout property to this annex, the US Government awarded the carfloat service contract to BEDT.
This carfloat service contract consists of floating cars to the Navy Yard from the Kent Avenue Yard, and never direct from any other carfloating facility or terminal. Freight cars destined for the Brooklyn Navy Yard would be received from the various Class 1 Railroads at their respective New Jersey terminals. These cars would all be carfloated to the Kent Avenue yard, "pulled" from the various carfloats and set aside in a portion of the BEDT railyard. On a scheduled day, the BEDT would load a carfloat with all the freight cars and one locomotive, and a tug would transport this carfloat to the Brooklyn Navy Yard.
Upon arrival at the Brooklyn Navy Yard, BEDT locomotives and personnel would unload or "pull" the cars off the BEDT carfloats to a railyard off the float bridge lead, and Navy personnel would take over and switch the cars to appropriate destinations within the Brooklyn Navy Yard property with Brooklyn Navy Yard locomotives. Outgoing freight cars would be reloaded on the carfloat with the BEDT locomotive, and the carfloat would return to Kent Avenue.
Starting in or around 1960, the Navy Yard diesels began to be sold off or transferred to the USN Storage / Supply Depot in Bayonne, NJ. It is believed that it was at this time that the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal assumed all rail operations: offloading the carfloats and switching cars within the Navy Yard properties. This arrangement continued even after the Navy Yard properties were released from government control to civilian ownership in 1966.
When the New York Economic Development Corp took over the Brooklyn Navy Yard property in 1967, new civilian customers took up residence within the Navy Yard and rail traffic actually increased somewhat, with BEDT providing rail services. But, this boom would not last long and evaporate when New York City entered its financial crisis in the early 1970's.
For a detailed listing of the freight / cargo arriving at the Brooklyn Navy Yard, please refer to the Brooklyn Navy Yard section of the Customers / Commodities chapter of this website.
Upon the cessation of BEDT operations in 1983, it's successor; the NY Cross Harbor RR, would operate in the Brooklyn Navy Yard. For more information regarding NY Cross Harbor RR operations at the Brooklyn Navy Yard, please visit:
Paul Strubeck's New York Cross Harbor Railroad Website.
The BEDT also had, for a limited time; what was believed to be a non-rail interfaced truck terminal and pier / wharf station, the "Queensboro Terminal". This was located in Long Island City at the East River and 14th Street (now 44th Drive). This terminal is also commonly recognized at the 13th Street Terminal. Dates of service are from 1914 through about 1930. Until now, it was said that no float bridge seemed to exist at this location, and this location was a wharf station only.
Tom Hendrickson located a New York Times article dated 1914, announcing the opening of the Queensboro Terminal, which can be viewed here:
|Queensboro Terminal - New York Times - May 24, 1914|
If you reference the New York Times article above, you can read how there was every intention of a railyard to be built at this location and according to that New York Times article, there were supposed to be multiple piers constructed at this site as well.
The Belcher Hyde map of 1918 (below) does not show any trackage, but does show a significant amount of vacant land adjacent to the terminal:
E. Belcher Hyde Map, 1918
(north is right)
In a conversation with Tom Flagg, he informed me of a 1920 "Joint Report" where it is stated that the QBT was reduced to a pier station only with no transfer bridge.
However, according to the 1927 ICC Valuation Report, there was indeed trackage at this location with it's cumulative length included in the 7.890 miles leased from Havemeyer's & Elder, so perhaps the float bridge and railyard was built and did briefly exist at this location once again. You can reference the Valuation Report for yourself here: 1927 BEDT / ICC Valuation Report.
Below is an advertisement for the Queensboro Terminal. Seen in the bottom left corner of the image can be seen the letters ROOKL with the left half of R and right half of L cut off, and judging from the shed like structure on the top, this is a Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal station carfloat located behind the building.
In the previously mentioned 1927 ICC Valuation Report, a BEDT yard located at Warren Street in Jersey City, NJ; was mentioned. I'm sorry to say, I had not known about it until reading this report, so it was rather a shock to learn of it. The property at this location was both owned by Havemeyer's & Elder, and consisted of property that was exclusively leased to the BEDT. This 1927 Valuation Report shows 1.129 miles of track at this location, and mentions this location having a float bridge. It states:
"The New Jersey properties are on similar land on the north shore of Tidewater Basin in the southern section of Jersey City."
Tom Hendrickson; son of Francis, a BEDT conductor; was kind enough to send the following item that he located. It is a residence/business prospectus/advertisement dated 1911 for attracting residents and industry to Jersey City. In it, it goes on to state:
"3. Its latest dock and float bridge, at the foot of Warren Street...." [and on the next panel, states] "this new enterprise, engineered by the New York and New Jersey Realty Co. and Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal."
It should be noted, that Henry O. Havemeyer (the nephew) was President, Secretary & Director of the New Jersey & New York Realty & Improvement Company (as listed in the Directory of Directors, 1914). I have uploaded the brochure as scanned and highlighted the appropriate text, and it was tweaked thanks to Paul Strubeck to make the file size more manageable. Also scanned is the map on the reverse side, but does not show any marker for the BEDT. I placed a pointer showing the relative location for reference. You can view both the prospectus and the map on the reverse side of the prospectus at:
|Jersey City 1911 Prospectus|
After reading that prospectus, not only do we have confirmation that the BEDT had presence in Jersey City and confirms the Warren Street float bridge but it gives us a rather accurate date as to the beginning of BEDT operations at Warren Street, being circa 1910-1911.
Shortly following this discovery, Paul also located two pictures that he found on the web in which you can see a curved freight platform and a single wood boxcar. These pictures are from the New Jersey Department of State Archives and the top photograph is titled: "From the canal, looking West at Jersey City". The bottom photo is titled "The Basin of 1867 and the Inner Basin and Morris Canal, at Jersey City [looking west]". The map insert (to left of picture) is from the prospectus map and I have turned the image to look west.
Note how the curve, canal and view line up between the prospectus map and the photos. Furthermore, the bridge crossing the canal in mid-foreground has tracks running in street to right of it, and this would correspond very well with the top most track which is the Pennsylvania RR Hudson Street Branch (running south/north) in map inset.
I have to admit, I was somewhat hesitant to consider these pictures of the BEDT Warren Street Terminal but made the statement here, that it was. I was in error as Tom Hendrickson pointed out these pictures are from a 1903 report to investigate the abandonment of the Morris Canal, which predates the 1911 prospectus mentioned above.
Tom hypothesized that even though we knew
there was a BEDT Warren Street Terminal, but there may have also been a Lehigh
Valley Warren Street Terminal as well (and not as a predecessor or successor
to the BEDT terminal, and was a completely separate facility) and that these
photographs are most likely of the Lehigh Valley Terminal.
A few days later (after finding the above pictures), I get a late night phone call from Paul, who upon browsing a book, discovers a Port Authority map (shown below) showing a Warren Street Terminal under Lehigh Valley ownership. The inner basin, and canal are filled in and unfortunately the map is not dated, but does show the track lead and the PRR trackage east of it, which aligns itself nicely with the photos above. Ok, so now we know the platform in the pictures is Lehigh Valley, but where was the BEDT Terminal in relation to this platform?
(north is up)
Well naturally, I'm back to square one and getting frustrated! Paul suggests to me, why not just email Tom Flagg? He's the best there is when is comes to Marine / Rail Terminals, not to mention it being stated on Sam Berliner's site that Tom Flagg reported seeing a track map of the Warren Street Terminal. So, I compose and send an email to Mr. Flagg, who was prompt, enthusiastic and quite helpful in his reply:
"Your BEDT website is certainly a mine of information about the subject! I will be glad to help with a map of that terminal. I just checked through my already-digitized stuff and was surprised to find I don't have it there. But this evening I will check into my collection for you.
I have some information from a report by Benjamin Squires "New York Harbor Employees", in the Monthly Labor Review, July 1918, (at South St. Seaport Museum Library), p. 3:
"The Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal has a small terminal at the foot of Warren Street, Jersey City, adjacent to a refinery of the American Sugar Refining Co., but that terminal is not connected with any of the trunk lines and is not generally used by Jersey City shippers."
The Refinery burned down in 1924, which may have been a factor in the terminal's abandonment." Tom (Flagg)
Two days later, I receive the map and caption below from Tom :
"This map is a portion of Pl. 1 from the Hopkins Hudson County
Atlas, of 1919, showing the Warren St. Terminal of BEDT. "Transfer Bridge"
is the technical term for what what is popularly called a "Float Bridge".
As is typical of Insurance / Real Estate Atlases, do not expect complete accuracy in the track plan.
It is mostly correct schematically (i.e., the number of tracks and switches and their relation to each other), but not in exact location of the track. Also, on the original map the lead track from the float bridge (the horizontal track at top) connected to PRR's track in Warren St., and not to its own trackage! A pencil stroke has been added here to correct this mistake, as it is known from other sources that the BEDT trackage formed a complete loop at this terminal.
It did not connect with the track in the center of Warren St., which was part of the Hudson City Branch of the Pennsylvania RR that transversed the streets of Jersey City, worked at this time by horses! A major fire in 1924 destroyed most of the neighboring sugar refinery (which was a branch of the American Sugar Refining Co.) and probably did damage to the BEDT's property.
The terminal had not been used much by local industry, and the BEDT probably figured it wasn't worth restoring the terminal at that point. Interestingly, even though the BEDT was directly across the driveway from the Lehigh Valley Warren St Terminal platform, it appears from the map that the BEDT did not share the platform."
G. M. Hopkins Map, 1919
There you have it BEDT fans. Thanks to Tom, we now know what the BEDT Warren Street Terminal track layout looked like and where is was situated in relation to the photographs above. As Tom knows a great a deal more about this Warren Street Terminal than I have learned so far, I'm going to defer to his email to give the history of the Terminal:
"Yes, the American Sugar refinery of Jersey City was there, and served by the BEDT in its brief residence in J.C. The "Sugar House" condo was converted in 2001 from the last remaining building of the refinery, which had been a storehouse for some time.
That part of J.C. is quite interesting. The site was next to the Morris Canal Basin, so was a prime industrial site. It had been the Jersey City Glass Co. before, a major glass maker from about 1824 to 1856. The site was then sold, and F. O. Matthiesen and Wiechers acquired the property in 1862 and began to erect a sugar refinery. By about 1870 it was a big place, and processed Cuban molasses (and later raw sugar) brought in by ship to the Morris Canal Basin. In late 19th century views of Jersey City, its stacks and tall buildings were some of the most prominent features of Jersey City. By 1884 it was employing about 1500 workers and covered 5 city blocks (east of Warren St.). In 1890 it was taken over by American Sugar Refining and became their Jersey plant.
A 1908 real estate map shows that the Morris Canal Basin waterfront west of Warren St. had a piershed on it labeled "Palmer's Dock", so apparently Palmer was there serving Amer. Sugar even before the BEDT arrived. In fact, that piershed is the exact same L-shaped building shown on the 1919 map, so it preceded the tracks by a little bit. Almost a small-scale reprise of the history of the Kent Ave. BEDT site!
At some earlier point the Pennsylvania RR had extended its Hudson City branch (that had been serving the Jersey City piers on the waterfront) up Essex St. to the refinery; I haven't yet found the date. This line was worked by horses, due to being in the streets of Jersey City.
A big fire in 1924 burned down most of the refinery, and apparently there was never an effort to rebuild it. The Sugar Storage building survived, and on a 1928 property map is labeled "K. Hamilton Inc. Barrels". The Hudson City branch remained in service, to serve a chemical plant on Sussex St. and also the remaining refinery building.
A 1928 Hopkins map shows a short extension of that Warren St. track onto the former BEDT site to serve a "Builders Material Corp." building on the east half of the site. An old shipyard in the Basin extended itself to the west half.
The track above the BEDT, along the Morris Canal, is a branch of the Lehigh Valley RR, serving a large milk platform along the canal."
Anyhow, we can see from the map, the BEDT Warren St Terminal had it's own platform in the center of the innermost "loop" track and did indeed have a single float bridge west of the platform. This leaves one vital unanswered question: did the PRR (and not BEDT as expected) service the American Sugar Refining building at the foot of Washington St on the canal?
As per Tom Flagg, the BEDT did not interchange with PRR Hudson Street Branch on Warren Street (and naturally I would not have expected it to, as from precedent, the BEDT never had physical track connections to either PRR at North 4 Street or Long Island Rail Road at Pidgeon Street, even though the tracks for those railroads would be literally with in a few feet from BEDT trackage).
But to get to the American Sugar building on Washington Street you must follow the PRR trackage on Warren Street (left track down center of street) and travel two blocks north and then curve eastward onto Essex Street and proceed one block to Washington Street, where reversing direction and transversing through the turnout, which thereby takes you south onto the Washington Street spur and back to the foot of Morris Canal Basin next to the American Sugar building.
If BEDT did not use the PRR Trackage, then PRR would have had to pick up drop off / at this facility, shove the cars onto Warren Street and somehow transload the items onto cars on BEDT tracks. Were freight cars parked side by side on Warren Street for this transfer / transloading of freight?
Then several months later, Paul Strubeck sends me various .pdf files from documents and books pertaining to the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal and other Port of New York Terminals he located during "Google" searches. One of these books is titled:
"Ports of the United States, Department of Commerce
Bureau of Foreign & Domestic Commerce;
Miscellaneous Series - No. 33;
Report on Terminal Facilities, Commerce, Port Charges, and Administration as Sixty-Eight Selected Ports",
by Grosvenor M. Jones, 1916.
On page 113 of this book, in the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal chapter it states:
"The Jersey City Terminal of this company is located at the foot of Warren Street on the Tidewater Basin of the Morris & Essex Canal. This terminal has direct connection with the various railroads having terminals on the New Jersey shore of the New York Harbor, and has a freight yard with a capacity of 100 cars, car-float bridges, and warehouses for the storage of freight."
If some of you have failed to recognize any significance in that passage, please take particular note of the second sentence:"This terminal has direct connection..."
This new information unfortunately contradicts the previous information as supplied by Tom Flagg, listed above and of which I regard as gospel. I immediately emailed Tom and both Tom and I agree that further proof is required to substantiate this claim of direct connection of BEDT to other railroads, but according to all other documents, there was no interchange. Also as a result of this new information, I found it pertinent to now show the unaltered version of the Warren Street Terminal map for comparison:
Left map courtesy of Tom Flagg. Right map courtesy of Ralph Heiss.
My thanks to both.
The red circled area in the left map shows the penciled in "crossover" (diamond) over the left and connecting to the right track (and partially obliterating the bottom left leg of the letter "R").
The red circled area in the right map shows no such
revision with no turnout on the right track and no crossover on the left
(and this being the original map).
Both maps appear to be identical to each other in every other aspect, save for black and white and color formats.
If one studies the track layouts, one can realize that with the track layout in the right or original map, a locomotive cannot "run around" a car or cut of cars, and therefore once a string of cars has been pulled from the carfloat, the locomotive is "trapped" at that end of the train.
However, with the revised map, that crossover now allows a locomotive to pull a string of cars off a car float, uncouple from the cars on Warren Street, and continue to run around the loop and ending up in on the opposite side of the cut of cars, allowing the locomotive to pull a car or cut of cars in the other direction, as well as from either direction.
With this latest thorn in our side, Tom sent an actual advertisement released by the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal, with a copy of the track arrangement. While not clear enough in this image, the track map appears to be taken directly from a blueprint and dimensions and track numbers are listed. In any event, this map clearly shows the cross over in the middle of Warren Street.
(north is left - advertisement courtesy of Tom Flagg)
So, if my opinion matters for anything, I have to side with Tom on this "interchange / direct connection" question, in that the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal did NOT directly interchange with the Pennsylvania Railroad at this location. I also took note of something else on the advertisement. In the column on the right, it fails to mention the Pennsylvania Railroad as a point to receive or ship freight from this Warren Street Terminal, which is odd as Pennsylvania is right on the street!
A United States Geological Survey
aerial photo of the area taken in 1931 shows the float bridge and yard
to have been removed, and it appears the neighboring shipyard has taken over
the property as several floating drydocks can be seen at the bulkhead.
Presently, this same area has witnessed a conversion to upscale residential
condominums, and a marina is now located at the bulkhead where the float
bridge was formerly located.
Greenville Yard could be considered the largest yard operated by BEDT (after 1976). While not technically Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal property (it was leased from Conrail after 1976 to continue carfloating operations in New York Harbor), it was a vital part of BEDT operations after 1976.
Greenville Yard is located in Jersey City, NJ; and was originally built in 1904 by the Pennsylvania Railroad upon swamp land. Greenville in its heyday was a monstrous yard, featuring a series of float bridges, a hump yard, car repair shops, and even a yard to stage steel structural components for the then booming Manhattan Island "skyscraper" construction period. The original float bridges were of wood construction and of Howe Truss design, and the gantries were of wood construction as well.
The Pennsylvania Railroad upgraded the float bridges and gantries following a massive fire in 1931, with six all new steel plate girder bridges, numbered from north to south: 9 1/2, 10, 11, 12, 13 and 14. The reason for 9 1/2 being numbered in the "half", was to avoid confusion with a #9 float bridge that was already in service for the Pennsylvania Railroad in their Harsimus Cove railyard which was 2 miles north of Greenville. These new float bridges used a main bridge as well as a separate apron. These "double apron" types, which help relieve stress put on the toggle bars during loading/unloading, have a pair of parallel gantries or machinery houses.
Currently, Greenville is a shadow of its former self, with less than one quarter of the original trackage remaining in place. Only float bridges 9 1/2, 10, 11 and 12 remain, as 13 & 14 collapsed in 1992 they were subsequently torn down. Only 11 is in operation today. BEDT would operate the Greenville Yards following the 1976 formation of Conrail. The reason for this is Conrail did not want any sort of involvement in rail-marine operations, and thus the yard and floating rights were leased to Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal. Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal would also lease several different Conrail locomotives over the years. (See Diesel Locomotive overview for more information).
After the 1979 merger of New York Dock & Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal, the yard became under the operative control of New York Dock, who also handled marine operations for the Baltimore & Ohio RR at that time. When New York Dock & Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal both ceased operations during the first week of August 1983, the New York Cross Harbor RR was formed two weeks later, and the Greenville lease carried on to them, and now has been transferred to their successor: New York New Jersey Rail, and remains in use today.
Many thanks to Paul Strubeck, for the history on Greenville Yard.
Float Bridges / Transfer Bridges of the B.E.D.T.
BEDT float bridge list
. There were three distinct types of float bridges inherent to Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal operations and which are shown side by side for comparison, and discussed in detail below. Lengths and cosmetic appearance of the float bridges varied by builder and need.
float bridge location
|neighborhood||float bridge type||style|
Brooklyn Navy Yard...
North 3 Street
North 5 Street
North 6 Street
North 9 Street
Wallabout Basin, Brooklyn.....
Long Island City, Queens
Jersey City, NJ
|pony plate girders
pony plate girder.....
pony plate girder
French / Contained Apron 2
1 = facility leased from Conrail, 1976
2 = Converted to pontoon style, see below
3 = relocated to Brooklyn Navy Yard ca. August 1983
Separate Apron Type
The six float bridges in Greenville, NJ; that were used by the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal, did not actually float on the water, but are suspended by flat steel "eye bars" and cables. Each main float bridge (not the apron) is suspended by eight 2 1/2 inch diameter multiple stand steel cables, four of which are attached to the center girder and two each to the outside girders by eyelets. These are in turn are attached to four 53,000 lb counterweights through a series of sheaves. These counterweights carry 90% of the float bridge's dead weight. These float bridges were raised and lowered through electrical motors and gearing.
The actual attachments for raising and lowering the float bridge were called "eye bars" (which are steel flat bar stock with "eyes" at each end, and interconnected to one another with steel pins). These are connected to the bridge girders as well, and are forward of the cable attachment points. The center "eye bar" (mounted to the center girder) was equipped with a self leveler. The self leveler looks like an inverted triangle (point down) and had one "eye bar" enter at the bottom and two "eye bars" emerging from the top two points. These in turn were connected to the bottoms of the two center worm drives. The outer girder "eye bars" were connected directly from bridge to the outer two worm drives. These four worm drives are what actually moved to raise or lower the float bridge and were powered by electricity and were located in the Main Gantry.
The aprons, which are hinged to the outer edge of the bridge, are supported by cables and counterweights as well, with a friction brake dampening system. These were not powered by electricity and was simply a type of shock absorber. These were located in the Apron Gantry. All the gantry mechanics and motors themselves were stationary except for the worm drive. The float bridges in Greenville are of the Separate Apron type, as opposed to the Contained "French" type.
The current bridges at Greenville were manufactured by two different companies; those being American Bridge Co, and McClintic Marsh Co. For build dates and specifications and of the Greenville bridges, I recommend you visit this website's page on float bridges:
|Comprehensive List of Float Bridges in New York Harbor|
. Also, Greenville float bridges had both electrically powered and hand powered winches for the hawser lines to draw the carfloat tight against the float bridge. Quite simply, a double apron type float bridge can be determined by the double parallel overhead gantries, while a French type only has a single overhead gantry. In the case of the Greenville float bridges, both the Main and Apron gantries are continuous over all six float bridges.
The gantries at Greenville are unique in the fact that steel legs for the gantries are set inside concrete footings, which are mounted on top of cut stone blocks, which are stacked in an interlocking pattern. These cut stone blocks are placed on a platform of heavy wood bridge timbers which form a sort of platform in the water. It is unknown if these timbers sit on pilings which were pile driven into the riverbed. Why this method of construction is used, I am not certain. But if I were to hazard a guess, this is done to prevent the steel from corroding away prematurely, and perhaps to insulate the gantry from electrical charges and electrolysis from the alkaline sea water.
I have learned, as of late July 2007, Greenville float bridge numbers 9 1/2 and 10 are slated to be demolished. Apparently, the gantry support legs are underscored due to the washing action of the tides, and as a result, are placing strain on the support legs of #11, which is currently in service. Float bridge #12 is slated to replaced with a new bridge and returned to service after many years of inactivity.
The in depth history of the Greenville transfer bridges can be read on this websites associated page:
The Development of Carfloat Transfer Bridges of New York Harbor
Contained Apron or "French" Type
The float bridge located at the Brooklyn Navy Yard which was used by Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal; was originally of the French type, being named so for having been designed by James B. French in 1911. The motors for adjusting the height of the float bridge decks were also powered by electricity, but the French type float bridge consisted of a single overhead gantry covering two parallel but independently suspended and operated bridge decks. The two bridge decks would be connected to the bulkhead on one end, with the carfloat being moored to the other end. The Contained / French type had two separate hoisting mechanisms in the gantry, one for each deck, which allowed the two bridge decks to be adjusted independently.
The other significant difference between Contained Apron (French) and Separate Apron types, is that the French utilized self contained aprons (which were not counterbalanced or friction braked) and were built and recessed into the outer (water) end of the float bridge deck, and were permitted to rise or fall with the twist of the carfloat (as it listed when cars were placed or removed onboard the carfloat). However innovative this design may have been, some railroads such as the Pennsylvania preferred the separate apron type.
The Brooklyn Navy Yard float bridge was converted from the French type to a pontoon type, but the overhead gantry was left standing, even though it would no longer be attached to the float bridge. It remains standing to this day. However, there is at this time, some "cloudiness" regarding the replacement float bridge(s):
The current pony truss / pontoon style float bridge at the Navy Yard was brought there in 1983, and is the float bridge from North 9th Street. However, there is a second float bridge, a pony plate girder; laying in the water in a mostly sunken state (not connected to anything) and to the east of the float bridge gantry.
From research by Paul Strubeck and Benjamin W. Schaffer, it appears this derelict float bridge was originally from Delaware, Lackawanna & Western Hoboken Terminal (and not Central Railroad of New Jersey as originally stated here). This float bridge was brought there first to replace the original French Type span.
It is seen in an 1980 aerial photo sitting near the gantry, with a pontoon under its land side (making it totally bouyant, and moveable by towing). For some as yet undetermined reason, this pony plate girder was defective or incompatible in some way, and was not able to to be installed at this location.
After BEDT closed in 1983, New York Cross Harbor then replaced that pony plate girder with the second replacement float bridge, this being the pony truss in place now. This float bridge having come from the BEDT North 9th Street location (according to Fred Breimann, retired Bush Terminal and New York Dock locomotive engineer). Then, the pony truss (currently in place) replaced it shortly after August 1983. We do not know what became of the original French bridge span, but must presume it was scrapped.
The reason we know for fact that the pontoon pony truss float bridge arrived after August 1983, is that in reviewing extensive photos on this website, and those taken by John McCluskey at the Brooklyn Navy Yard in 2006, I have matched the float bridges right down to location of dents and placement of electrical conduit. As the North 9th Street float bridge was used to load the locomotives onto a carfloat at the end of operations at Kent Avenue in August 1983, this float bridge would have needed to have been moved after this date.
Pontoon Type Bridge
Deck: wood timber
Pony Plate Girder
Deck: wood timber on steel girders
Deck: wood timbers on
joints reinforced with riveted plates
Please note: for clarity, I have omitted wood pilings, winch mechanisms, carfloat jack, etc.
The Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal float bridges located along Kent Avenue and at Pidgeon Street were of Pontoon type, meaning they were supported by a huge steel tank affixed to the underside of the bridge span for flotation, and were equipped with hand winches only for the hawser lines to keep the carfloat drawn tight against the float bridge. These float bridges were adjusted for height by slowly advancing the locomotive to bear it's weight down on the bridge, thereby pushing it down into the water, eventually to match the height of the float bridge to the deck of the carfloat.
If for some reason, the carfloat was riding high in the water (i.e. empty or light load, or a leaky pontoon causing the float bridge to sit low in the water), there was a manually operated hydraulic jack that hung over the water end of the float bridge and that a leg could be pumped down. This in turn contacted and pushed down on the carfloat deck, thereby raising the float bridge. (As the carfloat was larger and had more buoyancy than that of the float bridge, which was the lighter weight of the two objects, it would be the float bridge that raised up and not the carfloat that would be pushed down into the water).
Some designs of pontoon supported float bridges has a small steel gantry over the water end of the float bridge. This gantry contained sheaves and cables connected to hand winches for raising the float bridge in case of a mismatched float bridge / carfloat height or for float bridge maintenance. As far as it is known, BEDT did not employ these overhead gantries on any of their pontoon type float bridges.
The Howe Truss style is now shown, because it is believed that the original float bridges along the Williamsburg waterfront were originally of this construction, (and possibly the Warren Street Terminal as well). All the Howe Truss style float bridges were of creosoted wood construction, with the exception of the pontoon tank, hawser winch mechanism and the threaded rods and brace plates.
If there were Howe Truss style float bridges
located at Palmer's Dock / Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal, they were
all eventually replaced with either pony truss or pony plate girder throughout
the years, so that none remained by 1914, the earliest dated photo we have
seen to date. The actual date remains unknown when last Howe Truss was removed
from Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal service. By viewing the 1924 aerial
photo, the only remaining Howe Truss in Williamsburg by that year was the
Pennsylvania Railroad's North 4th Street float bridge.
Surviving Float Bridges of the B.E.D.T
As of November 2008, Paul Strubeck informs me that the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal North 5th Street Float Bridge is no more. I was fortunate to have photographed it just a few months prior in July 2008, from on board the Lehigh Valley tugboat "Cornell" on a tour of NY Rail Marine facilities.
So, we are now only able to enjoy the sight of one surviving float bridge owned by the BEDT: the Pidgeon Street float bridge (pony truss) in Long Island City, Queens.
The Pidgeon Street float bridge is derelict, (abandoned in place) and is partially are sunk, with the timber decking having been removed. The bridge builders plates has been removed; and so to the lucky owner(s) of both the Pidgeon Street and North 5th Street float bridge builders plates, please feel free to forward pictures of either / both bridge builders plates!
Here is one of the last photos of the North 5th Street float bridge before it's removal:
North 5th Street float bridge (Williamsburg, Brooklyn) - July 12, 2008
P. M. Goldstein photo
The following are photos of the "second" Pidgeon Street float bridge. Please take note that this float bridge was installed at this location sometime after 1958, as a photo of the float bridge in place at this location in 1958 is of a different construction design. Further information and the image of this original float bridge can be found in the Pidgeon Street chapter: Pidgeon Street
Pidgeon Street (Long Island City, Queens) float bridge (second) - July 2008
both photos (bottom): P. F. Strubeck
If one considers the Brooklyn Navy Yard and Greenville, NJ float bridges (which were technically not BEDT even though they were contracted to use them), they survive as well. The replacement float bridge and original gantry for the Brooklyn Navy Yard remains as of July 2008, in an unused and derelict state. In the following photo, the gantry can be seen from the East River:
P. F. Strubeck photo - July 2008
Also, the ex-Pennsylvania RR float bridges located in Greenville, NJ: numbers 9½ - 12 (number 13 & 14 collapsed in 1992 and were subsequently removed); remain in various states of usage or abandonment.
As stated above, John McClusky took extensive images of the former North 9th Street float brdige, now located at Brooklyn Navy Yard and his album may be viewed here:
Structure 713 - Brooklyn Navy Yard; John McCluskey.
Employee & Staff List
The Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal employed a rather large staff. In the Public Service Commission report of 1915, it recorded a staff of 458, inclusive of it's executive administration. In this publication is a breakdown of departments and employee staffing, and I have included an image of that categorization breakdown:
Take note of the last line: Policemen and watchmen: 13; what I consider to be a sizable force in 1915. One must remember, the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal not only employed those people necessary for railroad operations; but also for their nautical operations, including the piloting and maintenance of the Tugboat and Carfloat fleet. But oddly, what I do not see on this list is captains, mates and deckhands; unless they are cumulatively listed under "Floating equipment employees".
In 1959, it would go on to report in a Railroad Magazine feature article a significantly lower amount of 252 employees, inclusive of it's executive administration.
I have also found that compiling this personnel information has been the most difficult aspect of my assembling a detailed history of BEDT operations. Even more difficult are finding the names of the Palmer's Dock and East River Terminal employees and administration.
I have realized that one person was omitted from the list below, that being Lowell Palmer. One has to remember him as a "founding father", as well as a partner with Havemeyer's & Elder in the creation of the East River Terminal. We also know he would come supervise the daily operations of East River Terminal, but his exact title is unknown. So without undue insult to his importance in the history of Palmer's Dock, East River Terminal / Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal, he stands above the rest, until his title is learned.
To date, only a few BEDT employees (J.
Roborecky, F. Laczynski and J. Rodecker) and two relations (T. Hendrickson
& M. Brusich) of BEDT employees (F. Hendrickson & N. Brusich
respectively) have contacted me. Hopefully that number will grow as this
website gains momentum, and I certainly invite all BEDT alumni to contact
me! I sincerely hope more employees and the descendants thereof would contact
me as I would like to assemble a moderately complete list of BEDT veterans.
I have heard third hand, that there is only one surviving steam locomotive
engineer, and does not wish to be bothered. So until more of these former
employees and relations thereof contact me; I only have the following information
to offer which has been complied from those people that have contacted me
and from literary sources.
In some cases, you will notice a particular person is listed in two separate titles / offices during the same time frame. As this data is compiled from different documents, it is unclear whether that person genuinely held two offices during the same time frame, or that person changed positions / titles.
Are you a BEDT "alumni" or a descendant
E.R.T / B.E.D.T. Employees
|Henry O. Havemeyer, (uncle)
Henry O. Havemeyer, Sr. (nephew)
Marion M. McClellend
Nicholas G. Cutter
President & General Manager
| 1875 - 1907
< 1917 >
< 1965 - 1972 >
|Henry O. Havemeyer, Jr. (son of nephew)||Assistant to President||1926 >|
|Henry O. Havemeyer, Sr. (nephew)||Executive Vice-President & Treasurer||< 1952 - 1965?|
|Christine A. Pasquariello||attorney / senior vice president (BEDT/NYD)||< 1981 - 1983 >|
|Frank F. Dayton||Vice President of Operations||< 1972 >|
Edward C. Potter, Jr.
C. G. Phillips
H. J. Shepard
Marion M. McClelland
Nicholas G. Cutter
J. D. Mead
|< 1917 >
< 1912 - 1920 >
< 1921 >
< 1952 >
< 1952 -1965 >
< 1963 - 1969 >
< 1979 >
< 1981 >
|Frederick C. Havemeyer
Treasurer (also manager of revenue accounts,
personnel & purchasing & stores)
|< 1917 >
< 1969 - 1972 >
|Edward C. Potter Jr.
Charles H. Jackson
||< 1917 >
< 1917 >
|Charles R. Heike||Secretary & Treasurer||< 1907 >|
|J. H. McCafferty
L. H. Shereff
|Secretary (also Sec'y of Eat
River Terminal RR)
||< 1926 - 1942 >
< 1969 - 1972 >
|Rae Sokoloff||Assistant Secretary||< 1972 >|
|Harry A. Coop
||< 1926 >
< 1972 >
|T. F. Smith||Auditor of Freight Accounts||< 1926 >|
|J. D. Mead||Terminal Engineer||< 1952|
|J. O. Havemeyer, Jr.
Henry O. Havemeyer
C. G. Phillips
H. H. Shepard
Marion M. McClelland
||< 1910 >
< 1920 >
< 1921 >
< 1927 >
1938 - 1961
|Edward C. Potter Jr.
John T. Moore
|Assistant General Manager||1909 - 1912
< 1968 >
|General Superintendent (ERT)
General Superintendent (BEDT/NYD)
|< 1917 >
< 1979 >
|John Moore||Terminal Superintendent||< 1977 >|
|W. J. O'Keefe||Superintendent and General Agent||< 1969 - 1972 >|
|Riley L. Williams
(also shown as
Frank F. Dayton (also shown as VP of op's)
||< 1926 - 1942
< 1968 - 1972 >
|Charles Ferris||Mechanical Superintendent||< 1917 >|
P. J. Martin
|Superintendent of Equip. &
||< 1910 - 1917 >
< 1916 - 1927? >
< 1952 >
|R. J. King||Manager of Data Processing||< 1972 >|
|?. Dettman||Chief Dispatcher (Tugs)||< 1942 >|
|Anthony A. Lembo||Tug Dispatcher & Terminal Sup't||< 1968 >|
|J. Todd||Master Mechanic||< 1952 >|
|Riley L. Williams
Superintendent of Maintenance
|< 1963 - 1969 >
< 1972 >
|Raymond Aufiero||Mechanic||< 1978 - 1983 (transferred to NYCH)|
||< 1968? -1983?>
|H. G. Callaghan||Chief Electrician||< 1960's >|
|Howard Morganstern||Electrician||< 1978 - 1983 (transferred to NYCH)|
|C. E. Engler||Freight Claim Agent||< 1926 >|
|G. E. Gibson
Nicholas G. Cutter
< 1952 - 1965 >
|J. D. Mellett||Store Keeper||< 1969 >|
|J. M. Rodecker, Jr.||Personnel||< 1968 >|
|M. Rodecker||Chief Clerk||< 1970's >|
|Edward C. Potter Jr.||Clerk||1908-1909|
|Kenneth G. MacCart||Chairman of the Board||1969|
|Millicent De La Cruz||Payroll||< 1981 >|
|Van Grace||Labor / Employee Relations||< 1981 >|
Employees - Marine Department
|Einar Boe||chief engineer||< 1930 (died - drowned in Invader sinking of 1930)|
|Charles Braner||seaman||< 1942 (died - fell overboard from Invincible)|
|?. Sehen||seaman||< 1942 >|
|Nicholas Brusich||captain||< 1942 - 1947 >|
|William Cunningham||chief engineer||< 1947 >|
|A. Soovedra||engineer||< 1964 >|
|Joseph Fadde||mate||< 1947 >|
|S. Poskonka||mate||< 1964 >|
|Joseph Kurophewa||fireman||< 1947 >|
|William Reynolds||floatman||< 1947 >|
|P. Doshner||floatman||< 1964 >|
|William Bruck||deckhand||< 1947 (died - drowned in Invader sinking of 1947)|
|R. Devlin||deckhand||< 1964 >|
|Sal Notarile||captain||< 1971 >|
|Joe Finley||deckhand & trainman|
|"Boom Boom" Curtain (?)||captain||< 1968 - retired prior to 1983|
|Willie Thom||deckhand / bridgeman||< 1970? - >|
Employees - Railroad
|?. James||conductor||< 1902 >|
|Harry Lynch||conductor||< 1983|
|Benny Kubicki ª||conductor|
|Larry Litler||conductor||< 1972 >|
|Franklin Young||conductor & brakeman|
|?. Moore||locomotive engineer (steam)||< 1902 >|
|Robert Marshall||locomotive engineer (steam)||1898 - 1931|
|Frank Marrs||locomotive engineer (steam)||< 1953 (injured in 14 Firebox Explosion)|
|Joseph Keane||locomotive engineer (steam)||< 1963 >|
|Sean McLoughlin||locomotive engineer (steam)||< 1961 >|
|Thomas Conroy||locomotive engineer (steam)||< 1950's >|
|H. Lewis||locomotive engineer (steam)|
|Manuel Porto||locomotive engineer (steam & diesel)|
|Frank Pagnotta||locomotive helper & engineer (steam & diesel)|
|Al Pernas||locomotive helper & engineer (steam & diesel)|
|Joseph Franco||locomotive helper & engineer (steam & diesel)|
|B. Dorado||locomotive helper & engineer (steam & diesel)|
|Jack Sweet||locomotive helper & engineer (steam & diesel)|
|Joseph Roborecky||locomotive engineer (diesel)||1968 - 1983|
|Vincent Callahan||locomotive engineer (diesel)||< 1979 >|
|Robert BellaRosa||locomotive engineer (diesel)||< 1979 >|
|Joseph Milici||locomotive helper (diesel)|
|Ken Seiffert||locomotive helper (diesel)|
|H. Bader||locomotive helper (diesel)|
|Salvatore Bianci ª||locomotive helper & engineer (diesel)|
|Bert Walter||locomotive helper & engineer (diesel)|
|J. Kreitz||locomotive helper & engineer (diesel)|
|Barney Sullivan||locomotive helper & engineer (diesel)|
|?. Heagney||locomotive hostler (steam)||< 1947 - ? > (injured in fall, unknown if returned to work)|
|J. McDermott||brakeman||< 1902 (died in Palmer's Dock accident)|
|J. Donaughey||brakeman||< 1902 (died in Palmer's Dock accident)|
|Francis Hendrickson||brakeman||< 1972 (died in BEDT accident)|
|?. Bekanich||brakeman||< 1972 >|
|Kenneth Garrison||brakeman||< 1981 >|
|Charlie McClellandª||brakeman||< ? - 1983) (transferred to NYCH)|
|N. Yocavelli ª||brakeman|
|Fred Breimann||brakeman||worked one month after Bush Terminal closed|
|Mike Mazone ª||yardmaster|
|Steve Hernick ª||yardmaster|
|Ralph Mele||conductor & yardmaster|
Employees - Shop / Maintenance
|Paul Bovitas||welder||(to NJT)|
|Willie||machinist||< 1963 >|
|Frank Laczynski||machinists helper||1974 - 1980|
Employees - Miscellaneous
|Joseph Kafline||horse driver||< 1917 (died in wharf collapse)|
ª = spelling may be incorrect
While I may have a fixed date of service for that particular person working in that position,
the left and right facing arrows denote possible previous or subsequent history in the position.
If I do not have the employment start & end dates for that person, only one year is shown.
|113 Wall Street||NY, NY ...||ca. 1910|
|129 Front Street||NY, NY||ca. 1916|
|25 Broadway||NY, NY||ca. 1926||executive offices|
|111 Broadway||NY, NY||ca. 1954||(Havemeyer & Elder)|
|86 Kent Avenue
||Brooklyn, NY 11211..||ca .1917 - 1983...||main office
(212) EVergreen 8-8300
The following is a scan of the June 1969 Official Guide.
courtesy of P. F. Strubeck
added 26 Nov 2008
Accidents, Injuries and Fatalities
.. Not to appear morbid or dramatic, but sometimes the only way to remember the sacrifices made by railroad employees is to recall the incidents in which they were involved in. Railroading has always been a dangerous occupation, especially so in the early 1900's. The Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal was no exception to being a hazardous work environment due to its industrial nature, but even it was more so when you also add the switching and marine aspects of employment there. There are a wide variety of incidents to be considered from working at the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal, which in turn caused any number of injuries or worse: boiler / firebox explosions (burns & scaldings); sinking & capsizings (drownings); and those types of injuries normally associated with the transportation industry: "run overs" (where a person is run over by equipment); crushings (i.e.: between a wall or two pieces of equipment); and of course, slip & falls.
This page was created to consolidate all the reports and submissions from various sources into one location and place them into chronological order, as there were listed rather disjointedly in the "Memoirs" chapter on this main BEDT website. Not an easy task, the only way to learn of these incidents was hours of searching the web, newspaper archives, obituaries, or direct recollection of employees and their descendants.
In later years and in most cases, the Interstate Commerce Commission sent an investigator to (what else?) investigate the incident, especially those involving a fatality. But even this is not foolproof, as several incidents we know of involving a fatality or serious accident, does not appear in the online archives of the I.C.C. However, like almost all other documents relating to the operations of Palmer's Dock and Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal, these reports have not yet turned up for review. In those cases where reports and newspaper articles have been located for a specific incident, a link is provided to those documents.
There are however several promising leads in finding accident reports of the BEDT in at least two repositories of I.C.C. documents, those being the National Archives in College Park, MD; and the Kheel Center at Cornell University, Ithaca, NY. Naturally, all readers are encouraged to continue to submit information on currently unlisted incidents, or to submit specific dates and / or facts about those incidents that are listed.
|List of Accidents, Injuries & Fatalities|
Vintage Films of the BEDT
In this chapter, there are now two films (converted to digital format) of the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal in action!
The first video was a 16mm with no sound taken by Mr. Robert B. Hart on Tuesday, July 2, 1957. I met Mr. Hart at the Clark, NJ "Mother Seton H.S." Train Show on 06 March 2011, and he informed me he had this footage. Mr. Hart already had it converted to digital, so he mailed me the DVD and I received it 15 March 2011. In this video, you will see #11 and #16 in operation.
The second video clip was 8mm with no sound. I acquired it back in 2006. The original film footage was taken by Gerald Landau, and I acquired it from Norm & Marie Wright. Unfortunately, the date that the original film was "shot" is not known. In it, we see #10, #12 operating with #11 is already out of service and being cannibalized. With #10 still in service and #11 out of service would place the date of the video after September 1958 (when #11 was taken out of service) and before October 1962 (when #10 was taken out of service).
July 2, 1957
B.E.D.T. Equipment Rosters
Due to the enormous content of information and photographs compiled regarding the rosters of Palmer's Dock, East River Terminal Railroad and Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal Steam & Diesel Locomotives, Tugboats, Carfloats and Non-Revenue Equipment; this main website was getting slow in loading. Therefore at the request of those loyal visitors; those images ansd rosters are now on their own pages.
These can be accessed through the following link:
B.E.D.T. Property & Operations Photographs
.. This page is a compilation of photographs showing the various buildings, structures and property serviced by the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal throughout its history.
Of particular interest are the recently acquired W. R. Harrison Terminal Reconstruction & Survey images from 1918 through 1919. This series of 62 images are the best known visual recording on how the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal appear ed before and during its last major reconstruction. Individual buildings may have been razed or constructed, but these image show a major renovation encompassing most of the Terminal. These images due to thier quantity and size Have been published on their own respective page.
W. R. Harrison Terminal Reconstruction & Survey
Assorted Property Images:
Attention Railroadiana Collectors, Auction Houses and Dealers:
I am very interested in procuring any of the Baldwin and/or H. K. Porter steam locomotive builders plates, as well as the ALCo / GE diesel locomotive builders plates or number boards that were assigned to those locomotives, as well as builders plates or appliances (marker lights, compasses, engine telegraph, etc.) from any of the tugboats owned by the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal.
If you know the whereabouts of or own any of these items, and I can interest you in parting with them; please feel free to contact me at:
My personal collection of BEDT Boxcar Seals, Matchbooks, Forms, Letterheads, Maps and Advertising can be viewed here:
Due to the size, complexity and ever expanding contents of the Memoirs chapter of this website, it has been moved to its own page.
You may continue to view the Memoris through the following link or the link in the subpage (file cabinet) directory at the top of this website:
- Locomotives - Tugboats - Carfloats - Structures - Layouts -
This chapter is for all those BEDT fans out there building models. All are invited to submit .jpg photo(s) of their BEDT models! Models from any era, in any scale, and in any phase of completion are welcome. All submissions will be listed on a consolidated subpage with other submissions and linked in this chapter and in the Main Index.
With your submission, I request that you
location if desired,
manufacturer of model or major components used in scratchbuilding your model,
time in construction, and
any other details you would like listed (types / colors of paint, superdetail parts, etc.)
To submit photos of your model, for more information or for suggestions, please email me: firstname.lastname@example.org
The following link will take readers to a glossary of definitions indicative to rail - marine terminal operations:
Photographs & images
courtesy of the archives
John S. Murray
Benjamin W. Schaeffer
RR Museum of Pennsylvania
Bibliography, Resources & Suggested Reading:
Please note, I am not responsible for inaccuracies published by other sources.
For more information and other websites about B.E.D.T. History & Locomotives:
please visit the following links:
S. Berliner III BEDT Website (comprehensive BEDT)
Florida Rail Road Museum [formerly known as FGC Museum] (#12)
Strasburg Railroad (#15)
Michael Brusich's tribute to his grandfather Nicholas Z. Brusich (BEDT Tugboat Captain)
BEDT Forum (thermomod)
BEDT Tribute Forum (railfan.net)
BEDT 14 Forum (Railway Preservation News)
RailMarine Operations Forum (all New York Harbor area Marine-Rail operations)
Dave Keller's LIRR Website (LIRR history)
Steve Lynchs' Long Island Rail Road Links (LIRR & Other RR's on LI)
www.SteamLocomotive.Info (all steam locomotives)
BrooklynPix.com (The Most Comprehensive Collection of Old Brooklyn Photographs)
BQEphoto.com (New York City architecture, structures and history)
Morning Sun Books (various authors and topics on railroad in the New York City Area)
Please note, I am not responsible for
inaccuracies & erroneous information published by other
and this links and their contents are furnished here for your convenience.
Special Thanks to:
for use of his bricked up BEDT doorway arch photo
information, access to archives and copies thereof regarding BEDT documents in RR Museum of Pennsylvania
Sam Berliner, III
for information, suggestions, feedback and improvements regarding this website;
for information, photos and sharing his "other" Bill Paxton BEDT Painting
for making available the 1927 ICC Valuation Report, Boiler Reports and other documents
for making available his grandfather's BEDT documents and newspaper clippings on the Invader
for use of his 11" x 14" action photos in his archives and for his
continuous "wet" (dark room) printing of the BEDT negatives I continue to purchase
for the gracious use of his BEDT archives
for ownership documents on BEDT #16
for advice and suggestions;
for the use of his photographs
ALCo S1 information & specifications
Warren Street Terminal information and track maps, Palmer's Dock & BEDT history
continued research and contributions to this website, financial assistance
for sharing his recollections, making available his father's (a BEDT Conductor) photographs, pre-1906 history research
including locating an image of Lowell Palmer, and ongoing research and contributions to this website
for hosting my websites on trainweb.org and for providing the necessary space to host the larger size images
for his BEDT art, goat jokes, immoral support and the fact he is a true science icon
(and a testament to the missing link theory)
for contributing his BEDT image archives
for the images and information on #6, #7, #8, #9; feedback, additions, suggestions & BEDT diesel roster,
and for his continuous "wet" (dark room) printing of the BEDT negatives I have accumulated and continue to purchase
for allowing use of Roy Linscotts' Jr. Locomotive Notes.
Please visit their website at www.linscottstrains.com
for proffering my websites on his LIRR History website
for generous use of his photographs
(please note - all Mahlkov photos are free domain and are not copyrighted)
great-grandaughter of Einar Boe, marine engineer killed in Invader sinking of June1930
for providing newspaper articles of the sinking and obituary.
use and scans of his BEDT marine & locomotive images
Baldwin builders specs & data for the East River Terminal locomotives
former NYD employee
operational information and historical data for NYD / BEDT operations
who is about to find out what a being "BEDT widow" is all about
for ownership history on #16
for his intentsive notes from his visits to the BEDT for many years
for submitting his father's great color BEDT photos from 1958
his comprehensive locomotive builders records and information
for years of service data on BEDT Invincible
co-author, current photos of BEDT #16, BEDT diesels, ALCo S1 diesel information, proof-reading,
suggestions, revisions and ongoing research and contributions to this website
for the use of his photographs
for 1960's BEDT operations information, the 1907 Bromley map, Palmer's Dock history & research
and ongoing research and contributions to this website
for his photo contribution of BEDT 25 pre-Bicentennial paint scheme
Norm & Marie
for the use of Gerald "Jerry" Landau's archives;
for the use of his photos and reprint permission of photos in his Morning Sun Books publications
for allowing me to procure and use Frank Zahn's NY Industrial / Terminal Railroad photo archives
for making her uncles archives available to me for use on this site;
for information on his ownership of #12, memoirs and photo histories
of the DeGolyer Library of Southern Methodist University
for access to and furnishing photographs from the Everett L. Golyer Jr. railroad photographs archives
of the G. W. Blunt Library of Mystic Seaport Museum & Library
their research and archive staff for copying and furnishing BEDT vessel history & information
and perhaps most importantly, to:
former BEDT employee
for taking the time to be interviewed, share his memories and explain BEDT operations at length
and ongoing research, contributions and assistance in maintaining this website
co-author, I.T. knowledge & advice and all around therapist
This website is respectfully & proudly dedicated to my father Stan
Quite simply, he is solely responsible for my interest in railroading, and for that I shall forever be indebted.
See you at the next stop dad.
For those of you who have not yet realized it, this website is a labor of my affection for the Brooklyn Eastern District Terminal. I spend quite a deal of my free time on it; improving it, adding to it and correcting errors.
Many of you loyal readers have suggested, and rightly so; to publish this website to a bound book. While the thought of such flatters me, and while quite honestly I know I am capable of drafting the manuscript; there are a few reasons I have chosen not to.
The first and perhaps most important to
the photo contributors: This website is non-profit and non-commercial. I
see no income from it's existence. Matter of fact, the research that is incurred
with a task of this magnitude sometimes leaves me strapped for funds. In
any event, this not for profit status allows me some latitude in publishing
photographs from archives. From my understanding, to obtain copyright
permission from each and every contributor would be expensive and time
consuming, and I feel I would lose some of the "good faith" photographic
contributions made in the spirit of railfanning. ("I'm sending these to you
to use on your website provided you don't sell them. Just put my name
Essentially, if I published a book, I feel I would be selling these photos as well. So it is easier to keep this a friendly contribution based website, where we all share in the glory of our BEDT photographs, located in one place.
The second reason, which I have to say;
is quite important to me. Once information is published to a book, that's
it: it's printed, errors and all. I am a perfectionist and I've spent many
a sleepless night editing to get things just so... Sometimes, only to tear
it down and start over, because something just doesn't seem or look right.
Also considering that in a historical reference such as this; some dates are estimated, names may not be spelled correctly or locations misstated, and information from previous sources are incorrect, and in some instances I screw things up, transpose information, data, dates, etc. In short, I make mistakes and I like the immediate opportunity to correct those mistakes when they are discovered. I personally have a "hang up" with erroneous information that cannot be changed; i.e: when its printed in a book format and we know after publication that it's incorrect.
In this website format, when I receive a correction: I correct my webpage and upload and make a note in the revision list. That's it, it's fixed with a few keystokes. With a printed object, nothing can be done unless I decide to print a second volume or use an online addendum, that I can only hope that the book purchasers find..
One of the drawbacks to a bound / printed
book, is size limitation on graphics, maps, etc. While a foldout can be pasted
into a book, production costs are very expensive. Some of the track map are
3 feet by 5 feet!
With this website however, I can scan oversize images and put a link to it, where as you the reader can reference that oversize image. Then you can enlarge, reduce, zoom, etc. on the portion of the graphic you desire.
Finally, as this page increases in publicity,
more and more data arrives from sources for me to add. This website started
out in mid-2004 at less than 50 kilobytes, with maybe 25 "steam locomotive
only" photos. As of May 2007, I broke 400,000 bytes and that is not including
the photo pages, which now encompass diesel locomotives, miscellaneous equipment,
tugboats, carfloats, and property. In March of 2008, the main page broke
Also, in a printed format and once published, I can't add something I deem important, i.e.: a previously undiscovered link or connection or an influential event, an undiscovered demonstrator locomotive, or perhaps that yet undiscovered photo of the "Frederick Havemeyer". Any of these would warrant an immediate update to this website and I would not have that luxury with a printed publication.
So, and until further notice; all you BEDT fans will have to cope with the electronic format and I hope you understand my decision! :o)
Like what you see?
Click here to sign the Guestbook!
Please click on the book below and feel free to sign the guestbook... Leave a comment or suggestion if you would like!
RETURN TO INDEX
About the author:
Please click here
to learn about the
|Bush Terminal||207th St Yard (IND / NYCTA)|
|Degnon Contracting / Degnon Terminal...||Wallabout Terminal (DLW)|
|Goodwin - Gallagher Sand & Gravel||Wallabout Station (Erie)|
|Atlas Terminal||G & R Packing||Pouch Terminal||Wallabout Union (PRR, NYC, LV, B&O)|
|Bronx Terminal (CRRNJ)||Harlem Station (Erie / EL)||Procter & Gamble||West 15th St Freight Yard (CRRNJ)|
|Bronx Terminal (LV)||Harlem Transfer (DL&W)||Queens Subway Apartment & Loft Building||West 23rd St Freight Sta (NYLE&W / Erie)...|
|Jay Street Terminal / Connecting||West 26th St Freight Sta (B&O)|
|New York Cross Harbor||West 27th St Freight Yard (LV)|
|New York Dock||West 28th St Freight Sta (Erie / EL)|
|Brooklyn Wharf & Warehouse||New York New Jersey Rail / Port Jersey||South Brooklyn Terminal / Brooklyn Marginal..||West 37th St Freight Sta (PRR)|
|25th St / South Brooklyn Terminal (DLW)|
May the little railroad with the big name live on in our memories and never be forgotten.
gfy RFM DK JL NM RM